Sunday, September 23, 2007

Words of Wisdom from Joseph Schumpeter

From a Reason Magazine review of Thomas McCraw's Prophet of Innovation: Joseph Schumpeter and Creative Destruction:

“Capitalism stands its trial before judges who have the death sentence in their pockets,” wrote Schumpeter. “The only success a victorious defense can possibly produce is a change in the indictment.” Thus the major indictment of capitalism by the socialists of the 1850s was for immiserating the working people. When this proved scientifically wrong, the socialists of the 1890s indicted it for imperialism. When that too proved wrong, at any rate by the lights of the best economic scientists who troubled to look into the matter (among them Joseph Schumpeter), the socialists of the 1950s indicted it for alienation. When this accusation seemed less fresh, the socialists of the 1990s indicted it for environmental decay. Schumpeter wrote that “such refutation,” rationally proving the latest indictment wrong, “may tear the rational garb of attack [on capitalism and all its work] but can never reach the extra-rational driving power that always lurks behind it.”
Schumpeter, like Marx, believed that the collapse of capitalism was inevitable for sociological reasons. Schumpeter rued this perceived reality, Marx celebrated it. Were it not for Hayek and Friedman, they both might have been right (and they might still be). But the lesson here is to watch the shifting rhetoric of anti-capitalists. If they are unsuccessful with one attack, they will simply move to another one, hoping to overwhelm people with accusations until they start believing they are true.

They keep cycling back through the list -- immiseration of workers, imperialism, inequalities, environmental collapse -- as needed, neglecting history and scientific study in favor of rhetoric and ideology. Schumpeter recognized this early on, and his words still carry much weight today.

Labels: ,

1 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Interesting to know.

November 10, 2008 at 5:49 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home