Tuesday, October 30, 2007

A Data Point Ignored in SiCKO

Andrew Sullivan's got the goods, quoting the Telegraph:

Tony Blair poured millions into Britain's socialized healthcare system, pumping unprecedented resources into a healthcare system that Michael Moore admires and the American left loves. This is the result:

More than 70,000 Britons will have treatment abroad this year – a figure that is forecast to rise to almost 200,000 by the end of the decade. Patients needing major heart surgery, hip operations and cataracts are using the internet to book operations to be carried out thousands of miles away.

India is the most popular destination for surgery, followed by Hungary, Turkey, Germany, Malaysia, Poland and Spain. But dozens more countries are attracting custom. Research by the Treatment Abroad website shows that Britons have travelled to 112 foreign hospitals, based in 48 countries, to find safe, affordable treatment.



Wait just a second, says Ezra Klein:

Indeed, there are more Americans -- 100,000 -- traveling abroad for cosmetic surgery alone than there are Britons seeking any type of services in foreign lands. America is actually driving the medical tourism industry that some Britons are taking advantage of. The growth of foreign treatment centers aren't a result of the failings of the British health care system (of which there are many). They're a result of the cost of American health care, and the huge numbers of sick individuals we price out.
Well, first things first. There are five times as many Americans as Britons, so comparing raw numbers isn't appropriate. Also, Americans are going for plastic surgery while Britons are seeking treatment abroad in order to stay alive. Obviously they aren't the same. In addition, the American model is a free trade model, so "medical tourism" isn't exactly a critique of the system; it's part of the system. Seeking out lower prices for procedures is what you're supposed to do. In Britain, however, everything is intended to be provided by the government (and at much lower cost, as Klein goes on to remind us). But the fact is that the service is so unsatisfactory that people are choosing to opt out of Britain's system in favor of the free trade model. The fact that citizens living in countries which provide UHC are choosing to forego the free coverage (for which they've already paid, through taxes) in favor of a free exchange is not supportive of arguments in favor of UHC.

So, tell me: how is this supposed to support Klein's position that we should move to a European-style UHC system post-haste?

Labels: ,

Preach It

Megan McArdle answers pretty much every criticism made of school voucher plans. She finds them wanting.

My instinct tells me that opponents of school vouchers are primarily motivated by a few biases:

1. Anti-market bias - voucher opponents are nearly always left-of-center, and agreeing to a voucher plan is a tacit admission of failure of a large-scale government operation (similar arguments were made in opposition of welfare reform in 1990s). Admitting that the government can't operate the education system efficiently makes one wonder if it could operate the health care system (or anything else) efficiently either, doesn't it?

2. The "It's My Money" Reactionary Bias - Call this the "I don't want my tax dollars supporting religious lessons in schools" syndrome. McArdle mentions this one, and has a good point: religious fundamentalists don't want their tax dollars supporting evolution lessons, or sex ed, or secularism, etc. Others are opposed to multi-cultural lessons, or biased history books, or whatever. The point is, nobody gets exactly what they want. If the point is to educate children, then the primary concern should be to educate children and not to bitch about where your tax dollars eventually end up. Additionally, under a voucher system parents would actually have choices over what their children are taught. So, those who don't want religious instruction for their kids will have secular options; those who don't want secularism taught to their kids will have religious options. Opposing vouchers is opposing choice.

McArdle has much, much more. It's worth reading the whole thing.

Sunday, October 28, 2007

Best. Play. Ever

Labels: ,

Thursday, October 25, 2007

Or, There's Option "B"

Matthew Yglesias is clearly not following Christopher Hitchens' drift:

I briefly considered responding to Christopher Hitchens' defense of "Islamofascism" (the term not the doctrine) via a roundabout discussion of Orwell fetishism, but suffice it to say that I identify with the pragmatist tradition and the thing to ask about a term like this is what does "Islamofascism" do.

And it's pretty clear what it does, namely provide a spurious patina of unity and sameness to diverse phenomena involving Muslims Behaving Badly so that al-Qaeda, Hezbollah, Hamas, Iran, Assad, Saddam, Iraqi insurgents, Somali Islamists, plus sundry oppressive folk practices common in portions of the Islamic world like female genital mutilation in parts of Africa, "honor killings" in parts of South Asia, etc. The question to ask ourselves is what, if anything, is accomplished by devising and deploying a term that unites all those phenomena. If you want to use emotional outrage at 9/11 to leverage political support for an invasion of Iraq, then the answer is obviously "yes." Similarly, if you want to leverage outrage at 9/11 into political support for a bombing campaign in Iran then the answer is "yes."

But I don't want to do either of those things, and, indeed, I think the people who do like to do those things are having an immensely detrimental impact on our ability to understand events in the contemporary world and pull the United States out of the foreign policy tailspin we've been in recently. Which is a long way of saying, I'm not buying.

Or there's another option: one might despise religion in general, and especially the oppressive elements espoused by fundamentalist practitioners of one particular religion (including, to greater and lesser degrees, all of the groups listed by Yglesias and many others). One might even, if one was a writer, write a book on the topic. And, if so, one might call it something like God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything.

Oh, wait.

(for the record, Hitchens doesn't support bombing Iran.)

Labels:

Shift Happens

The Last of the Mohicans music is a bit much, but I'm a sucker for these kind of things. It is pretty amazing how quickly the world changes.

Today's Sign That the Apocolypse Is Upon Us

John McCain's daughter has a campaign blog (er, "blogette"). It's all like, "OMG, this campaign is sooo neat! And my shoes are awesome!"

She brought friends, and they take pictures. Oh, and the post iTunes playlists.

Labels: ,

Have American Middle Incomes Stagnated?

Yes, says Paul Krugman and many other class warriors, and it's due to rising income inequality. Not so fast, says the Federal Reserve. The rub? Basically, Krugman (et al) forget to include noncash payments (i.e. retirement accounts, health insurance, stock options, etc.) in their calculations. These are all compensation for work which really didn't exist several generations ago. Now, they represent a very significant portion of total compensation for many American workers, especially in the middle class.

(ht: Greg Mankiw)

Labels: ,

A Valuable Resource

Eliezer Yudowsky (of Overcoming Bias fame) has written a very helpful, very valuable "Intuitive Explanation of Bayesian Reasoning". Well recommended for anyone who seeks to understand Bayesian statistical methodology, and/or how to think logically.

Sometimes Performance Art Is Great

Like when 111 shirtless men invade a NYC Abercrombie & Fitch store to ridicule their model.

Labels:

Monday, October 15, 2007

Giuliani's Record

Matthew Yglesias wonders what Rudy's record as crime-fighter from Gotham has to do with being president:

More seriously, contemplating the main thing that one might give Giuliani credit for -- New York City's larger-than-average crime drop in the 1990s -- just makes you realize that no matter how much credit you think he deserves for it, it has nothing to do with running for president. The president can't reform local departments' policing procedures.
I agree with Yglesias's conclusion: Giuliani is not qualified to be president. But this is not the best way to go about proving it. On one level, Yglesias is right: being a good local crime-fighter has nothing to do with being president. What does have something to do with being president, however, is properly managing an executive office, and using the tools at your disposal to improve the lives of those you represent. So, it's not important that Guiliani fought crime well, specifically; it's important that Giuliani did anything well.

This only goes so far, of course. There are all sorts of other prerequisites for being worthy of consideration for president. These include some sort of foreign policy capabilities, respect for the rule of law, an active mind, a clear domestic agenda (which runs deeper than attempting to co-opt Reagan's legacy), and high level of personal integrity (this last one is negotiable). Rudy possesses none of those things, which is why he shouldn't be president. This should be the line of attack.

Labels:

Back

I apologize for the absence. I've been exceptionally busy with school-related activities. Notably, I took the GRE on Saturday after having spent the past few weeks studying for it. Regular posting should resume now.

Monday, October 1, 2007

Whose Money Is It, Anyway?

Ezra Klein approvingly quotes Robert Reich suggesting that we should, in effect, end the tax exemption for charitable donations, and adds some commentary of his own:

"I'm all in favor of supporting the arts and our universities," writes Robert Reich, "but let's face it: These aren't really charitable contributions. They're often investments in the lifestyles the wealthy already enjoy and want their children to have too. They're also investments in prestige -- especially if they result in the family name being engraved on the new wing of an art museum or symphony hall."

Agreed. The tax deductibility of charitable donations to private universities, the arts, and so forth are a bit of a scam. This year the Treasury will forgo $40 billion in tax revenue due to the deductibility of philanthropic donations. That makes sense when the money is going to feed the poor -- but studies show that only 10% of charitable donations go directly to the poor. And there's no reason the rest of us should be subsidizing an I-banker's desire to fund a named chair at his alma mater and, oh yeah, help his kid get into the school to boot.

Additionally, charity has become something of a lifestyle, with large donations buying you entrance into concerts, gala dinners, special exhibits, networking events (see Global Initiative, Clinton), and much else. In such cases, charitable donations are closer to purchasing tickets than selflessly and anonymously giving up private wealth for public ends. "Awhile ago," says Reich, "New York's Lincoln Center had a gala supported by the charitable contributions of hedge-fund industry leaders, some of whom take home $1 billion a year. I may be missing something, but this doesn't strike me as charity. Poor New Yorkers rarely attend concerts at Lincoln Center." And they shouldn't be subsidizing those who do.



The unspoken assumption here is that Klein believes that peoples' money does not belong to them, but rather to the government. In other words, allowing people to channel their money to the programs they'd prefer to improve should be disallowed.

So here's a question for Klein/Reich: the government taxes citizens to pay for all sorts of programs, including funding for the arts and education. The government, in fact, pays for a lot of arts and education programs which primarily benefit the relatively wealthy. Why are they better at distributing that money than individuals, for whose interests the government is (presumably) acting?

Not only that, but who gets to decide what is a "real" charity and what isn't? A lot of "real charities" -- e.g. food banks and homeless shelters -- are run by religious groups who use the opportunity to proselytize. Should they be exempt, since the government isn't allowed to endorse religions? What if one wishes to donate to a relatively wealthy public school in Manhattan? Should the gift be refused tax-exempt status because there are poorer schools in Queens?

Who cares if some of the reasons people donate are self-serving? The point of the exemption isn't to boost some particular charity over others; the point is to give citizens more direct control over where their money ends up. That is a fine end unto itself, and one that Klein/Reich don't even consider.

Labels: , ,