A Data Point Ignored in SiCKO
Tony Blair poured millions into Britain's socialized healthcare system, pumping unprecedented resources into a healthcare system that Michael Moore admires and the American left loves. This is the result:Wait just a second, says Ezra Klein:More than 70,000 Britons will have treatment abroad this year – a figure that is forecast to rise to almost 200,000 by the end of the decade. Patients needing major heart surgery, hip operations and cataracts are using the internet to book operations to be carried out thousands of miles away.
India is the most popular destination for surgery, followed by Hungary, Turkey, Germany, Malaysia, Poland and Spain. But dozens more countries are attracting custom. Research by the Treatment Abroad website shows that Britons have travelled to 112 foreign hospitals, based in 48 countries, to find safe, affordable treatment.
Indeed, there are more Americans -- 100,000 -- traveling abroad for cosmetic surgery alone than there are Britons seeking any type of services in foreign lands. America is actually driving the medical tourism industry that some Britons are taking advantage of. The growth of foreign treatment centers aren't a result of the failings of the British health care system (of which there are many). They're a result of the cost of American health care, and the huge numbers of sick individuals we price out.Well, first things first. There are five times as many Americans as Britons, so comparing raw numbers isn't appropriate. Also, Americans are going for plastic surgery while Britons are seeking treatment abroad in order to stay alive. Obviously they aren't the same. In addition, the American model is a free trade model, so "medical tourism" isn't exactly a critique of the system; it's part of the system. Seeking out lower prices for procedures is what you're supposed to do. In Britain, however, everything is intended to be provided by the government (and at much lower cost, as Klein goes on to remind us). But the fact is that the service is so unsatisfactory that people are choosing to opt out of Britain's system in favor of the free trade model. The fact that citizens living in countries which provide UHC are choosing to forego the free coverage (for which they've already paid, through taxes) in favor of a free exchange is not supportive of arguments in favor of UHC.
So, tell me: how is this supposed to support Klein's position that we should move to a European-style UHC system post-haste?
Labels: Health Care, Michael Moore
