Monday, July 30, 2007

U.S. vs. Kenyan Farmers

A nice little NY Times piece which reinforces how small pieces of U.S. legislation can have dramatic effects on the developing world. Some good bits:

Families participating in an American-financed irrigation project from 2002 to 2006 were promised payment in corn for clearing the land and digging canals. The Kenyan government objected to the importation of American corn because the country was awash in a bumper harvest that had caused corn prices to plunge.

The result: American officials, prohibited by law from buying the corn locally, could not deliver it. As the impoverished families waited in vain for sustenance from the American heartland, malnutrition among the youngest children worsened and five people died of hunger-related causes.

Across Africa, the United States is more likely to give people a fish — caught in America — that feeds them for a day than to teach them to fish for themselves. Since last year, for example, the United States has donated $136 million worth of American food to feed the hungry in Kenya, but spent $36 million on agricultural projects to help Kenyan farmers grow and earn more.

And even that small budget for long-term projects in Kenya is expected to dwindle. The United States Agency for International Development, known as Usaid, in seeking to concentrate scarce resources, has dropped Kenya from the list of countries eligible for undertakings like the irrigation project here.



USAID is one of the best U.S. government agencies. They do a lot of great work -- under the radar -- in underdeveloped countries. Unfortunately, they often have their hands tied by domestic legislation which hurts foreign countries to benefit special interest groups in the U.S. The culprit this time? As is usually the case when it comes to agriculture policy, it's the farm lobby; the bloated Farm Bill prevented the government from honoring its commitment to starving Africans to provide them food, unless that food was grown in the U.S. Sounds like an okay deal, right? But the economics of this presents a harsher reality. By shipping in American corn, the price of domestic corn (in Kenya) was depressed, so local farmers had to either sell their own at deflated prices, or not sell it at all. So the net effect was that the country actually got poorer through the mechanism of our aid, and some of the people actually starved to death while waiting for the promised food. All this so that rich farming corporate conglomerates could receive huge subsidies from the U.S. public in order to grow food. A bit from the article highlighting how USAID's hands were tied:

Members of Congress who favor the current system say the support of influential commercial groups is needed to sustain political support for food aid. They warn that ill-timed purchases of food in Africa in times of scarcity could send food prices higher, harming poor consumers.

But critics in Congress contend that the United States could feed far more people more quickly if it could buy surplus food in Africa. It might also help boost the incomes of African farmers, by providing a market for their crops, they say.

The Bush administration is now trying to change the law so that up to $300 million of food can be bought in poor countries during emergencies.

The criticism of those favoring the status quo might be valid: if we buy food locally (in Africa), then the increased demand could (probably will) increase prices for everyone else. But it should also boost employment, wages, and production which should bring the market back into equilibrium pretty quickly. As the article points out later, Iowa alone got $1.58bn in farm subsidies in 2005. In other words, American farmers are well taken care of; the piddling amount that we propose to purchase in Kenya shouldn't greatly effect their bottom line.

The U.N. recognizes this; they did what USAID couldn't (but wanted to do): bought the food in Africa and gave it to the starving people.

Still the program has been a success, despite the U.S.'s backwards agro policies. Poor Kenyans now have irrigable land for the first time, and many of them are on the path to self-sufficiency. That is a good thing, but the lesson must be learned: freeing up USAID to act in the best interests of those whom they are charged with helping will have the best possible effects. This can help the U.S.'s standing as well; we may have lost the MidEast to radicalism. We should make sure that we don't lose Africa as well.

Labels: ,

The New Anglo-American Relations

Brown and Bush project a united front, but it's difficult to believe that U.S./U.K. relations will be as cozy as they have been since Blair took office and allied himself with Clinton and Bush. The war in Iraq certainly took their toll on Blair, and Brown seems prepared to not make the same mistake. At the same time, he recognizes the need to stay close to the U.S. As the global power dynamics shift from Old Europe (U.K., France, Germany) to New Asia (China, India) in the coming decades, the U.K. will have to stay close to the U.S. to maintain any significant global influence. The U.S. needs the U.K. as an ally in Europe, as the Old World becomes more and more resentful of the U.S.'s hegemony. A few interesting things from the article:

Mr. Brown, who has eschewed the use of the phrase “war on terrorism,” nonetheless hailed Mr. Bush’s leadership in his campaign against terrorism. “In this century, it has fallen to America to take center stage,” he wrote. “And let me acknowledge the debt the world owes to the United States for its leadership in this struggle.”
This is an important point which is often lost in the discussion over Iraq. Only the U.S. has the global military capabilities to truly fight terrorist organizations and control rogue states. And the U.K. (and perhaps France and Germany) face a much stronger terrorist threat than we do. If we decide to just let everyone fend for themselves, it could happen at the detriment of the U.K. and Europe.

On the flip: the U.K. faces more exposure to domestic Islamic terrorist threats than the U.S. does, but that also gives them more opportunities to gain intelligence on global networks which threaten Western democracies. The U.S.'s opportunities are essentially limited to Iraq and Afghanistan, and those gains have (obviously) been limited. Indeed, we might be making the situation worse for ourselves in those places. Keeping Europe on our side in the struggle against terrorism is essential, and the U.K. is uniquely positioned to do that.

Elsewhere:

But even the opinion article pointed up subtle differences, for instance with Mr. Brown referring to the acts of such groups as Al Qaeda as “a crime,” and citing the importance of law enforcement in combating terrorists.

During the 2004 presidential race, Mr. Bush and his re-election campaign had leveled harsh criticism against his Democratic opponent, Senator John Kerry of Massachusetts, for referring to law enforcement action against terrorism, saying it proved Mr. Kerry did not view the threat seriously. Mr. Bush usually refers to terrorist attacks as acts of war.

Asked today whether Mr. Brown’s approach to terrorist groups represented an underlying difference of philosophy, Mr. Bush said it did not and acknowledged that law enforcement tools are part of the fight against terrorism.

This is the biggest wedge between the U.S. and the rest of the Western democracies. They (rightly) view terrorist actions as international criminal activity, like drug smuggling or arms sales. Obviously, if a specific foreign nation directly subsidizes such criminal actions, then they may be treated as acts of war (e.g. Afghanistan). But to the extent that these actions are being conducted by individual, multinational, private groups, they should be treated as crimes rather than acts of war. This is a fundamental philosophical difference between Europe and the U.S. They view Gitmo and the suspension of Habeas Corpus and the denial of Geneva protections as ridiculous abuses of power, and they are right. Bush views them as necessary (and, supposedly, temporary) actions in a time of indefinite war. Bush's thinking is fundamentally flawed, for a number of reasons which I won't bother going into during this post. Needless to say, he comes across as an authoritarian, and Europe likes nothing less than that. They learned their lessons w/r/t executive abuses of power in the 20th century. That, along with the chip on their shoulder which comes from being second-rate powers now, will preclude them from buying whatever America is selling without asking questions.

The next U.S. president will an immediate opportunity to ingratiate him/herself with the rest of the world: He can formally apologize for Abu Ghraib, close Gitmo and send everyone there to an international tribunal or trials in their own countries, present legislation to Congress to revoke the Military Commissions Act, proclaim that the use of "enhanced interrogation techniques" ended with the Bush administration, and reinstate the Writ of Habeas Corpus. Hillary Clinton won't do any of these. Neither will Giuliani or Romney. McCain might do a few. Obama is probably the best chance for a severe straightening of our legal system w/r/t detainees. In the linked article, Bush said that the U.S. and U.K. remain strong allies because "We have common interests throughout the world, but it’s an important relationship primarily because we think the same: We believe in freedom and justice as fundamentals in life." The rest of the world isn't buying it for obvious reasons. The next U.S. president will have the chance to change that perception.

Labels: , ,

Friday, July 27, 2007

How Politics Corrupts Good Economics

A good NY Times article highlighting the political difficulties in reforming the bloated farm bill. This bill is a classic example of special interest groups hijacking the government for their own benefit. It is often, and appropriately, called "welfare for the rich," since most of the farm subsidies go to large corporate conglomerates (e.g. Archer-Daniels Midland).

But opposing the subsidies can cost Congressmen their seats. So the likelihood that subsidies will be eliminated is very slight. This has real costs for the U.S. economy, but it also is a large sticking point in getting support for international free trade agreements in other countries. Reforming the bill real have real benefits for the domestic and international economies, will improve the U.S.'s standing in the world, and help open up developing countries to liberalize and develop through trade. But those benefits are likely to be lost to political self-interest groups.

Labels: ,

The Definition of Chutzpah

So now Alberto Gonzalez lied under oath in order to protect "national security". No perjury... just protecting the national interests from those pesky Congressman. If that's the case, then why are James Comey and Robert Mueller speaking openly about the meeting, and directly contradicting Gonzalez in the process?

Labels:

Thursday, July 26, 2007

Ethnic Cleansing and the Partition of Iraq

Andrew Sullivan sees evidence of ethnic cleansing in Iraq, and suggests that partition is the only way out:

Baghdad is close to being divided into homogeneous neighborhoods, Shia and Sunni. The 600 dumped bodies in the last month are part of the cleansing. We keep talking about the horrors that would follow a US withdrawal. But the horror of cleansing is occurring under our watch. Troop deployments in neighborhoods most dangerous to US troops facilitate it. Probably can't be helped, but it's worth noting that the numbers of sectarian murders, according to IraqSlogger, are back up to pre-surge levels. Cleansing may well be inevitable, and may in fact be necessary for some kind of peaceful partition to emerge. But it isn't pretty. And it's already here.

He then cites this IraqSlogger report as evidence:

A quick look at the map shows that over half the bodies are found in five specific districts of Baghdad: Amil (100 bodies), Saidiya (84), Bayya’ (67), Sadr City (39), and Dora (33), respectively. With the exception of Sadr City and Dora, both of which are almost completely cleansed from their former minority Sunni and Shi’ite communities, all mentioned districts are mixed and are witnessing a power struggle between Sunni and Shi’ite militants to control them and drive the other community out.
So yeah... in some places ethnic (i.e. well, sectarian anyway) cleansing is occurring or has already occurred. But this is not something which can help a "peaceful partition" since ethnic/sectarian cleansing is, by its nature, violent. As in, not peaceful. Not only that, but how does Sullivan propose "partitioning" Baghdad? Don't you think they'd fight over that, as well? And over the dividing lines of the rest of the country? Who exactly gets what? If they are fighting now, what makes Sullivan think that the fighting will stop if we start taking land and property and power from one group and giving it to another one? That's to say nothing of the fact that the international community despises partition, which is why Kosovo doesn't have its own state yet. In fact, I can't think of any notable nation or international group which would support partition.

This way of thinking confuses me. It strikes me as being very naive, and poorly thought out. Maybe I'll write Sullivan a letter, since he doesn't allow comments, but regularly prints e-mails from readers.

Labels:

Sunday, July 22, 2007

Turkish Election

The legislative election in Turkey yielded a surprisingly-high margin of victory in favor of the ruling Prime Minister. I don't know much about Turkey's politics, except that they are caught in between the MidEast and Europe, but this article gives a good overview of the situation.

Changing the Income Inequality Debate

An important paper by Steve Kaplan and Joshua Rauh, pointed by Tyler Cowen, who says this:

Here is the link, here is the non-gated version. How about this bit from the text?:

...the top 25 hedge fund managers combined appear to have earned more than all 500 S&P 500 CEOs combined (both realized and estimated).

This is important too:

...we do not find that the top brackets are dominated by CEOs and top executives who arguably have the greatest influence over their own pay. In fact, on an ex ante basis, we find that the representation of CEOs and top executives in the top brackets has remained constant since 1994. Our evidence, therefore, suggests that poor corporate governance or managerial power over shareholders cannot be more than a small part of the picture of increasing income inequality, even at the very upper end of the distribution. We also discuss the claim that CEOs and top executives are not paid for performance relative to other groups. Contrary to this claim, we find that realized CEO pay is highly related to firm industry-adjusted stock performance. Our evidence also is hard to reconcile with the arguments in Piketty and Saez (2006a) and Levy and Temin (2007) that the increase in pay at the top is driven by the recent removal of social norms regarding pay inequality. Levy and Temin (2007) emphasize the importance of Federal government policies towards unions, income taxation and the minimum wage. While top executive pay has increased, so has the pay of other groups, particularly Wall Street groups, who are and have been less subject to disclosure and social norms over a long period of time. In addition, the compensation arrangements at hedge funds, VC funds, and PE funds have not changed much, if at all, in the last twenty-five or thirty years (see Sahlman (1990) and Metrick and Yasuda (2007)). Furthermore, it is not clear how greater unionization would have suppressed the pay of those on Wall Street. In other words, there is no evidence of a change in social norms on Wall Street. What has changed is the amount of money managed and the concomitant amount of pay.

There is a great deal of analysis and information (though to me, not many surprises) in this important paper. The authors also find no link between higher pay and the relation of a sector to international trade.

The broader the literature gets in studying the make-up and causes for the big wage share gains by the top 1%, 0.1%, and 0.01% of the income distribution, the more it looks like the system isn't biased in favor of the rich, as so many left-of-center economists shrilly maintain. It looks like Superstar Economics combined with incentivized tax shifting is the major cause of increased inequality. It looks like Piketty-Saez aren't the end of the discussion. It looks like more natural workings of the economy, even if there is some irrationality behind it (i.e. huge pay increases for hedge fund managers).

I'm waiting for Krugman's inevitable reply with baited breath.

Labels: ,

The Economic Idiocy of Harry Potter

Megan McArdle, in the Guardian, explains JK Rowling's difficulties. The upshot:

This matters. If the cost of magic isn't well defined, how do we know what resources, other than plucky determination, Harry needs to defeat Voldemort? We certainly can't rely on his mental acumen; he's spent the last two books acting like a brain-damaged refugee from The Dirty Dozen.

Labels:

Friday, July 20, 2007

Is ethanol good or bad?

Daniel Gross asks the question, then briefly runs down environmental, economic, and humanitarian arguments against expanding ethanol use, before trying to quickly dismiss them:

While I'm as susceptible to Malthusian thoughts as the next paranoid guy, I find much of the anti-ethanol case to be unpersuasive. In each instance, the haters would have us look at ethanol, and the ill effects its greater use would assuredly produce, largely in isolation. Might the production of corn ethanol cause pollution? Of course. Is it worse than the sort of pollution created by other types of energy production—i.e., coal and oil? Probably not. Does greater use of corn for ethanol help spur price increases for food? Sure, but so do many other factors, like, say, the transformation of China from a subsistence farming economy into a more modern one. Is ethanol more inefficient, and hence more costly, than gasoline? Yes. But our heavy use of gasoline imposes all sorts of other costs—from pollution to the hundreds of billions of dollars we spend each year in Iraq. Factor those in, and ethanol no longer seems like such an economic loser.

I don't really agree when he says, "the haters would have us look at ethanol, and the ill effects its greater use would assuredly produce, largely in isolation." Environmentalists don't just dislike ethanol because of the fertilizer and run-off, and they acknowledge that it is less polluting than oil or coal. But the net energy gain from using ethanol is barely positive -- if it is at all -- so we are using coal and oil inputs to produce ethanol energy, which we are then using. So we're still getting the oil and coal pollution, plus we're getting the negative environmental aspects of ethanol. In addition, there are a lot of other forms of alternative energy which could have greater effects on lowering pollution and carbon emissions, but are being crowded out by all the investment in ethanol production and infrastructure.

His point about the cost of ethanol raising food prices, especially for those in the developing world, is even less valid. Yes, China's movement from an agrarian to industrial society is having an effect on world food prices, but that would happen whether we use ethanol or not. Ethanol is adding to the problem, in a very real and significant way. The effects are especially pronounced in Central and South America, where poor peasants in some areas are literally unable to afford corn to make tortillas; they have to resort to wheat, which is an inferior good in those societies.

The point about economic efficiency is also wrong. As I said before, since ethanol production requires large inputs of fossil fuels, the costs of pollution aren't abetted much, if at all. And the notion that we are spending billions in Iraq solely in order to secure oil fields is simply laughable. The fact of the matter is, oil use is largely subsidized by foreign countries, who spend the money to find and extract the oil before it is refined in the U.S. With ethanol, we subsidize our farmers, and have to pay for all the infrastructure ourselves. That it is a net loss on economic terms is inarguable.

Daniel Gross is usually much, much better than this.

Labels: , ,

Quote of the Day

George Packer, in The New Yorker, regarding Iran:

The regime there is brutal, and we should talk to it.
There is a lot of truth to this sentiment. The whole article is very good, and should be read.

(ht: Daniel Drezner)

Labels:

More "What Genocide?" Blogging

Matthew Yglesias doesn't agree with me when I say that Barack Obama's attitude towards Iraq -- withdraw even if it means genocide -- is stupid and wrong. Here's Yglesias' rationale:

Just because there's a very bad situation someplace doesn't mean you take action to halt it whether or not that action will work, makes strategic sense, or is likely to improve the situation. Occupying Iraq isn't working, and can't be made to work; the fact that more tragic days are likely ahead for the Iraqi people is no reason to stubbornly continue a failed policy.
Well, it depends on what he means by "whether or not that action will work or is likely to improve the situation". For example, Sen. Obama admitted that withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq will likely cause a genocide. Yglesias has said similar things in the past. So, a continued U.S. troop presence will "work," if your definition of "work" is to prevent a genocide from occurring. But that's not what Yglesias and Obama mean. What they mean is that a continued U.S. military presence will not bring out a short-term solution to the underlying problems in Iraq, and it won't be able to stop all the violence. Therefore, in their view, we should pull out and allow the genocide to begin. In other words, they think that because the U.S. can't achieve objective "A" (say, relative peace and stability in Iraq) that they should therefore not pursue objective "B" (prevent a genocide from occurring by sustaining a military presence in the country). But that simply doesn't follow.

Preventing genocides from happening with a large U.S. military presence can "work". It's working now in Iraq. It worked in the former Yugoslavia in the '90s, when NATO and the U.N. finally put troops on the ground. In fact, it would be hard for me to imagine a scenario in which it won't work, since the U.S. military is clearly superior to any other force in the world in head-on combat. Small-scale bombings and killings will continue in Iraq for a while. But if we leave, that small-scale violence will turn into large-scale massacres. Instead of 50-100 being killed every day, it may be more like 500-1000. This is not something I'm willing to blow off as easily as Yglesias and Obama.

If they want to make the case that we should pull out of Iraq -- despite the fact that it will cause a genocide -- because we really shouldn't care about Iraqis and should only be concerned with the safety and well-being of our own troops, then they have my invitation to make the case. But they can't prove one point by denying another one; just because Iraq policy has failed so far in fulfilling its first objective doesn't mean that staying to prevent a large-scale genocide from occurring (and being fueled by Saudi Arabia and Iran) isn't a viable position. It is.

UPDATE: Thomas P.M. Barnett agrees with me:

Odd and bad argument for Obama to make, one that paints him in a corner. Citing the slippery slope argument that says, "If I don't do it everywhere, then I must not do it anywhere" is foolish and self-restricting. I can't believe Samantha Powers let's him spew that.

Labels:

Stupidest Blog Post Ever... Context.

So yesterday I wondered if TAPPED had posted the stupidest blog entry ever. Today, we get some context:

RUSSIAN KIDS LEARN PUTIN ROCKS. The Bush years have sucked, but at least American text books aren't edited by the current administration. According to the Washington Post, Russian history and social studies text books "reflect the themes dominating official political discourse here: that Putin restored Russian strength and built what the Kremlin calls a 'sovereign democracy' despite American efforts to isolate the country."

The books say the American empire may be nearing a "final collapse" and that the Ukrainian Orange Revolution snatched a fair victory out of the hands of Russian forces in the country. Stalin is lauded as "the most successful leader of the U.S.S.R."

Creepy.

So the reason why Stalin is more popular than Bush? Because Russians don't enjoy a free press, and are indoctrinated in schools.

Labels: ,

Don't Mind the Genocide in the Corner

Barack Obama says "Genocide? What genocide? Oh... that genocide. Ah, don't worry about it":

Democratic presidential hopeful Barack Obama said Thursday the United States cannot use its military to solve humanitarian problems and that preventing a potential genocide in Iraq isn't a good enough reason to keep U.S. forces there.

"Well, look, if that's the criteria by which we are making decisions on the deployment of U.S. forces, then by that argument you would have 300,000 troops in the Congo right now — where millions have been slaughtered as a consequence of ethnic strife — which we haven't done," Obama said in an interview with The Associated Press.

"We would be deploying unilaterally and occupying the Sudan, which we haven't done. Those of us who care about Darfur don't think it would be a good idea," he said.

The big difference, however, is that we would be causing a genocide in Iraq, rather than intervening in one that's already on-going. I don't think that's a subtle distinction. And besides, is he really comfortable saying that the U.S. ought not use its military to prevent genocide? What else should we be using it for? I thought the biggest failures of U.S. foreign policy in the 1990s was that we didn't intervene in Rwanda, and that we intervened too slowly in the former Yugoslavia. I thought that most people, especially on the left, thought that we should have intervened in Darfur.

Is Sen. Obama a closet isolationist?

Labels:

Thursday, July 19, 2007

Reversal

Religion is growing in Europe and shrinking in the U.S. I'm not too surprised... this sort of thing seems to be cyclical, as one generation overreacts to the previous one. The pendulum swings back and forth.

Weird

Apparently, Yassir Arafat died of AIDS, and was probably a homosexual. I literally had no idea.

Beckham Blogging

I'm watching him being interviewed at the half of the MLS All-Stars v. Celtic FC exhibition. Dude is slick. He's wearing a cummerbund with an open-collar shirt, black jacket, and a lotta cuff.

And he's got his talking points together. He calls it "soccer," talks about building up the sport in the U.S., calls himself an "Ambassador for MLS," talks about "soccer moms" and calls Posh one with a smile. Dude should run for office.

He's already sold 250k jerseys in the past month or so. That's the most in MLS history, by far. The L.A. Galaxy say that jersey sales and advance ticket sales have already paid for his entire contract. And he hasn't even played a game yet. Amazing what a Posh marriage and having a Kiera Knightley movie named after him has done for the guy.

(alright... I guess he's had an okay career.)

Labels:

Stupidest Blog Post Ever?

TAPPED vies for the title with this doozy:

BUSH: LESS POPULAR THAN STALIN. Whenever I see approval ratings for President Bush, I always think of a Harper's Index stat printed in January of 2006 that compared Bush's popularity among Americans to Stalin's popularity among Russians. Of course, that statistic was printed 18 months ago, when the two ratings were neck-in-neck at 37%.

So a new poll from Strategic Vision (via the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel) finding Bush's latest rating at a dismal 19% puts our president a far cry below the iconic leader of an oppressive communist regime who systematically murdered millions through forced famines, labor camps, and political purges. Enough said.

Now, I know there's a bunch of snark here. But to even make this post -- with one eye cocked, I'm sure -- is idiotic for a few reasons.

1. One poll is about a sitting president in one country. The other is about a dead person in another country. Apples and Oranges. But the lack of scientific rigor isn't the main point.

2. Many people in Russia still long for the "good old days" of the Soviet Union. And the Soviet Union was (arguably) at the height of its power during Stalin's reign. It's like Americans being nostalgic for the Greatest Generation and WWII despite the lack of civil rights. The Russian experience over the last decade-and-a-half has not been great, so longing for past glories makes sense. I imagine there are some in Iraq who hated Saddam but would bring him back if they could.

3. Many Russians are probably deluded as to the evils of Stalin. After all, for much of their lives, the education system and media were state-institutions. I know that "de-Stalinization" rectified some of that, but maybe not all of it. Think of how easily we forgive our past presidents for slavery, genocide, and war-mongering.

I could go on, but frankly I'm too flabbergasted.

Labels:

Happy Birthday, Nelson

It's Nelson Mandela's 89th birthday, so what better time to rip him a new one? At Foreign Policy, Blake Hounshell remembers Mandela's record on HIV/AIDS in S. Africa. It's not so good:

Although then-Vice President Thabo Mbeki (for years, an AIDS denialist) deserves most of the direct blame for South Africa's 1990s AIDS disaster, it was Mandela who was ultimately in charge at the time. In 1996, his government spent 20 percent of its annual AIDS budget on "a contract for a theatre company to produce a show with questionable public-health messages," according to Zeitz. Following that error in judgment, Mbeki pushed Virodene, an AIDS medicine produced in Africa, through the government's approval process. Virodene was later deemed to be "unfit for human consumption."

Then we find out about The Elders, which might be the most laughably stupid idea with a lot of money behind it to come around in a long time. Basically, it's a bunch of old, feel-good former leaders who have been given a platform (read: money) by Richard Branson and Peter Gabriel (yes, that Peter Gabriel) to pontificate on global issues. The group includes Mandela, Bishop Tutu, Kofi Annan, Jimmy Carter, and others. Daniel Drezner has some fun at their expense:

Cue the press release:

Out of deep concern for the challenges facing all of the people of our world, Nelson Mandela, Graca Machel, and Desmond Tutu have convened a group of leaders to contribute their wisdom, independent leadership and integrity to tackle some of the world's toughest problems.

Nelson Mandela announced the formation of this new group, The Elders, today in a speech he delivered on the occasion of his 89th birthday. He was joined by founding members of the group, Desmond Tutu, Graca Machel, Kofi Annan, Jimmy Carter, Li Zhaoxing, Mary Robinson and Muhammad Yunus. Founding members, Ela Bhatt and Gro Harlem Brundtland were unable to attend.

"This group can speak freely and boldly, working both publicly and behind the scenes on whatever actions need to be taken," Mandela commented. "Together we will work to support courage where there is fear, foster agreement where there is conflict, and inspire hope where there is despair."

Tutu, Chair of The Elders remarked, "Despite all of the ghastliness that is around, human beings are made for goodness. The ones who ought to be held in high regard are not the ones who are militarily powerful, nor even economically prosperous. They are the ones who have a commitment to try and make the world a better place. We -- The Elders -- will endeavor to support those people and do our best for humanity."

The Elders will use their unique collective skills to catalyze peaceful resolutions to long-standing conflicts, articulate new approaches to global issues that are or may cause immense human suffering, and share wisdom by helping to connect voices all over the world....

"I see The Elders as a small but independent group that may fill an existing void in the world community," said Jimmy Carter. "Almost impervious to the consequences of outside criticism, the group will conduct unrestrained analyses of important and complex issues and share our ideas with the general public and with others who might take action to resolve problems."

The Elders will invite new members who share the attributes of the original ten: trusted, respected worldly-wise individuals with a proven commitment and record of contributing to solving global problems.

You can read Michael Wines' New York Times write-up by clicking here.

Before I succumb to the Elders' power of unrestrained analysis, I have to point out that their website makes the language in the press release seem modest. My personal favorite: "Never before has such a powerful group of leaders come together. Free from political, economic or military pressures. The only agenda of The Elders is that of humanity." I mean, with an agenda like that, Bush would be a fool not to turn over Iraq to them.

The founders of The Elders are Richard Branson and Peter Gabriel (according to Wines, “I was talking about the need for a group of global elders to be there to rally around in times of conflict,” [Branson] said, “and Peter said he’d had a similar idea.”), so you know this group will have both plush travel accomodations and a kick-ass theme song (they're so much... larger than life). Just imagine Jimmy Carter parachuting into Iraq to solve the civil war there backed by this song. Or, better yet, Desmond Tutu standing in the West Bank with a boom box over his head playing this song over and over again until all sides relent.

I could go on and on with the mockery (just imagine the supervillians that will unite to counter The Elders!!), but that's not really fair. This group has a large enough collection of Nobel Peace Prizes to ponder: bombastic language aside, will The Elders actually have any influence?

My hunch is "not much", based on this quotation from Wines' story:

Asked how [The Elders] differed from what United Nations diplomats were supposed to do, Mr. Annan replied: “We are not out to defend the positions of any institution or government. We’re ordinary global citizens who want to help with the problems of the world.”
While Track II diplomacy has its occasional uses, the fact is that most conflicts in the world usually require the cooperation of powerful institutions and governments. And sometimes they disagree -- not because of misunderstandings or mispeceptions, but because their interests genuinely diverge. And all the cajoling of all the trained negotiators in the world won't fix that problem.

The Elders won't be able to solve the conflicts that bedevil Iraq, or the Greater Middle East, or Darfur, or Somalia, or Nigeria, or Colombia, or Kosovo, and so on. At best, they will be able to leverage their star power to address problems or conflicts that are so off the radar that the great powers truly do not care... think Congo, for example.

Of course, once they start wearing capes, all bets are off.

UPDATE: Blake Hounshell finds another reason to be wary of The Elders.

ANOTHER UPDATE: I believe The Elders have found their Zan and Jeyna!!!

Mark Steyn alerts me to a Nick Clooney column alerting me to yet another new grouping of famous progeny. According to Clooney, they are called -- I swear I am not making this up -- the "Gen II Peace Team"!!! Click here to read their press release:

The Gen II Global Peace Initiative will work to promote world peace and nonviolence by building on the examples set by members' parents and grandparents to inspire current and future generations to fight injustice and encourage nonviolent means to achieve positive change. They will examine a range of options that will draw attention to humanitarian crises and potential solutions to conflict and to decide on a series of initial fact-finding missions to such "hot spots" as Darfur, the Middle East, Burma and Korea.
Among the participating luminaries listed is Naomi Tutu, daughter of Desmond Tutu, Chair of the Elders.

I, however, refuse to take the Peace Team until they have a pet monkey.

If The Elders and the Peace Team ever unite forces.... hoo, boy, look out.


How pissed must Bono and Bill Clinton be that they weren't invited? Must not be old (or irrelevant) enough yet.

Stupidest Fatwas Ever

Foreign Policy has the list. Naked sex, breast-feeding amongst coworkers, Pokemon, and polio vaccination. Wow.

Tuesday, July 17, 2007

Bhagwati on Doha

A nice piece. His perspective is often the opposite of, say, Rodrik's: Bhagwati still sees large gains from trade on the table, while Rodrik thinks that further liberalization will have a smallish effect on rich countries, but could have a harsh effect on (certain) poor countries. I tend to side with Bhagwati, although I'm not sure I'm as much of a true believer as he. Either way, a great, concise round-up of the issues stalling Doha, and how the U.S. and E.U. are primarily to blame.

The essential outlines of the deal among the G-4 were clear. The EU had to give on agriculture where its barriers and subsidies were huge. With negligible comparative advantage in agriculture, it did not seek concessions in this sector from India and Brazil, but rather wanted reciprocal concessions in manufactures and services. The problem with the US was that it had a strong farm lobby that would not permit meaningful reduction in the substantial US subsidies simply in exchange for concessions in manufactures and services; it sought “sectoral reciprocity” in agriculture itself.

But the problem is that the USTR, reflecting successful lobbying, has wound up making maximalist demands and minimalist concessions: a situation that is properly unacceptable to India and Brazil.

Regarding concessions, the US negotiating position is almost pathetic. Just recall that, even as the G-4 talks were in progress at Potsdam, the agriculture subcommittee of the US House of Representatives voted to retain the subsidy portion of the 2002 Farm Bill for another five years. At Potsdam, Ms. Schwab did not budge from her past hard-line position but insisted, even as she could not offer any ready concessions on US agricultural subsidies, that the poorer countries must offer more!

The problem that Ms. Schwab cannot ignore is that it is politically impossible for a democratic developing country such as India to persuade an aroused public opinion that its farmers, often at the margin of subsistence, should agree to competition from rich-country farmers who are being heavily subsidized. Unless the US, and also the EU, address this issue meaningfully, there is no prospect of movement on Doha.

So there is hope. But only if the U.S. farm lobby steps out of the way, or legislators finally grow some balls (and common sense) and oppose renewal of the 2002 Farm Bill. Which is, essentially, welfare for rich people.

Labels: , ,

Hmm




A mini-furor over the WSJ's supposed discovery of the Laffer curve last week, pictured above. Brad DeLong, Mark Thoma, probably-Jane Galt, Kevin Drum, Matthew Yglesias, and others have all pointed out the fact that the picture on top is especially dishonest. By drawing their line through an outlier, and then surrounding the rest of the data points inside the bell, the WSJ is portraying something that isn't really there. A better way to draw the line was provided by Thoma, shown second. The conversation eventually veered all over the place, touching on such topics as whether or not to include Norway in the first place, whether or not to include U.A.E., whether or not there was a measurement bias, whether or not sociology is worth a shit, etc.

But what interests me is something not discussed. What does the U.S. have the highest corporate tax rate, but receives less revenue from it, as a % of GDP, than any other country with anywhere near the same rates?

Quick guesses: tax shifting may be involved; Bush's tax "cuts" taxed individuals at lower rates than corporations, so high-income taxpayers shifted their income from businesses to individuals. Or, not all corporations at taxed at the same rates; small businesses pay less, etc. I don't know whether or not this data includes capital gains tax rates, but if so, that could play a role as well.

Labels:

Nationalistic Socialism In Practice

And no, I don't mean Naziism. I mean the anti-internationalist/anti-American/neo-Marxist rhetoric which commonly comes from S. America these days.

This week's example is... Evo Morales in Bolivia. You may remember that Mr. Morales unceremoniously booted foreign companies out of his country last year, because they were exploitative and keeping the poor down and etc. Well... it didn't seem to work so well:

Bolivia is courting foreign energy investors again, less than 15 months after President Evo Morales ordered troops to occupy oil and gas fields as part of his plan to take control of the country's natural resources.

Investment in natural gas exploration and production has plummeted in the wake of Morales's nationalizations and contract revisions, putting at risk his promise to add 20 million cubic meters of gas exports a day to Argentina by 2011, almost triple the current amount. Without new sources of gas, Argentina, Chile and Brazil, Bolivia's biggest gas customer, face a growing prospect of energy shortages and rationing.

``The government is realizing it needs foreign investors, but it wishes it didn't,'' said Carlos Alberto Lopez, a Bolivian oil and gas analyst and former secretary of energy. ``Venezuela has been a big disappointment for them and now they are knocking on everyone's doors,'' he said by phone from Santa Cruz.

Morales's plans to rely on Venezuela's state oil company Petroleos de Venezuela SA, known as PDVSA, haven't panned out yet. Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez pledged in May 2006 more than $1.5 billion of new investment to explore for oil and gas and to build refining facilities and service stations.

You bite the hand of international economics, and it bites back. Hard.

Labels: , , ,

To Withdraw Or Not to Withdraw... That Is the Question

Anne Applebaum in WaPo:

"No troops? Though deeply appealing to the "we told you so" crowd, this plan is clothed in the greatest degree of hypocrisy. How many of the people who clamor for intervention in Darfur will also be clamoring to rush back into Iraq when full-scale ethnic cleansing starts taking place? How many will take responsibility for the victims of genocide? I'm not saying there will be such a catastrophe, but there could be: Mass ethnic murders have certainly been carried out in Iraq before."
Matthew Yglesias responds:

This line of argument has been in vogue for some time now, but it seems singularly nonsensical. For one thing, I think there are real questions about the math -- how many people arguing for withdrawal for Iraq really are advocates of large-scale insertion of US ground forces to Darfur? Not me! Numbers aside, I think it's fairly obvious that if the US does withdraw from Iraq and full-scale ethnic cleansing does result (something Applebaum concedes is by no means certain) that very few withdrawal advocates are going to be clamoring for intervention. Here, I guess, is where the hypocrisy comes into play.

But it's not actually hypocritical to favor interventions to prevent mass slaughter where you think such interventions will be effective, but not otherwise. The idea that consistency's sake requires one to either be a pacificist or else to support whatever military adventure happens to be fashionable in the Washington Post opinion pages at the moment is daft.



It's "daft" and "singularly nonsensical"? I mean... no it isn't. It's true that wonky types like Matt don't want to withdraw from one country only to invade another, but the sort of "Hollywood left" -- the Clooneys, et al -- want us to do exactly that (as do many in the university scene). And, to be perfectly clear, stopping genocides is a perfectly fine use of the U.S. military, and we can stop pretty much any genocide we want to stop.

Matt seems unsure that genocide will occur if we leave Iraq. But his whole rationale for wanting to leave is that the two sides are irreconcilable, and they've got to duke it out once and for all. We can't fix it, they've got to have it out. So, basically, he's predicting an escalation of violence once the prevailing authority (the U.S., such as it is) leaves. Much of Iraq has already been ethnically cleansed, but the violence hasn't stopped. The only thing keeping it from all-out, open genocide -- a la Bosnia -- is the U.S. military. Perhaps Ms. Applebaum is unwilling to predict it; perhaps Matt doesn't want to believe it (or simply doesn't care); but it is the most likely result. Factor in Saudi Arabia and Syria/Iran using Iraq as a proxy war, and large-scale genocide seems like the only likely result.

Some of Matt's comments recognize the Bosnia similarities, but then get the story wrong. The violence there didn't magically end one day; it was through NATO intervention and the involvement of the West on the peace negotiations (and promises of Western enforcement) that peace occurred. The peace accords were signed in Dayton, OH, not Sarajevo, with Clinton, Chirac, Kohl, and Major all present. The U.N. also had troops on the ground from the first year of the war until the end of it. That war would not have ended so quickly without a LOT of pressure from the international community, or without military engagement.

Matt's question at the end similarly looks at things the wrong way. Does he really think that the U.S. couldn't prevent some or most of the killing in Sudan, had we acted earlier? Does he really think that the situation in Iraq won't deteriorate massively if we leave? How, exactly, does he define an "effective" military intervention?

Honestly, from this vantage point, it seems like Yglesias has decided that the cost to Americans of staying in Iraq is too high to warrant staying; whatever happens to Iraqis after we leave doesn't factor into his calculus. And that is truly daft.

Update: Brad DeLong apparently likes what Yglesias has to say.

Update2: Scott Lemiuex doesn't get it either:

So the potential for bad things to happen after the troops leave -- which I've heard few opponents of the war deny -- is neither here nor there given the obvious inability of the American military to create a strong Iraqi state ex nihilo.
But it's very much "here". It's the most important point: will Iraqis be better off under a U.S. occupation, or worse off? It seems almost insane to say "better off," since any security, infrastructure, economy, etc. which does exist in Iraq is all there because of the U.S. presence. If we leave, so does the money we pump into their economy. If we leave, so does the security we provide (which obviously isn't perfect, but it's a lot better than none at all). If we leave, the constant sabotage attacks on infrastructure (oil pipelines, schools, etc.) will continue, with no one there to rebuild, or prevent the attacks. If we leave Iraq completely falls apart.

Some people, like Andrew Sullivan, seems to think that this would be a good thing; he thinks that, once the dust settles, there will be de facto partition, which may become codified by eventual peace negotiations. So he's basically arguing in favor of ethnic cleansing (which is what partition really is). But just as likely, the Shiite will just domineer the Sunni, take all the land and oil, and the fighting won't stop. Or, even if some sort of real partition occurs, there will be fighting over boundaries, and territories, and oil fields. Then, who's to say that they won't continue to fight, even after the establishment of multiple states?

People who argue for withdrawal do so because things aren't getting substantively better in Iraq. But they also aren't getting substantively worse; at least, not when compared to the alternative. At this point, that's probably as good as we can hope for.

Labels:

Vacation blogging

I completely disagree with Good Klein when he says this:

Luckily, there are alternate ways to test my hypothesis that people actually wouldappreciate more vacation. A major presidential candidate, possibly a Democratic nominee, could make a proposal for enforce three weeks paid vacation a major issue in the campaign. If this turned out to be popular, well, then we'd know it was popular, and accorded with the nation's preferences.
First of all, this wouldn't be a true test at all. If phrased in that way, very few people could follow the line of logic to its natural conclusion. Therefore, very few people would say that they opposed this mandate. After all, who doesn't want more vacation?

But that's not the appropriate question. The appropriate question is whether people want more vacation time more than they want more income. There is a pretty clear trade-off here. It's not just the productivity or dis-employment effects which Klein (sort of) discusses later in the post. It's just that mandating an extra week of paid vacation for all the country's full-time workers will have effects elsewhere; most likely, it will come at the expense of salary growth. Or, other benefits (e.g. health insurance, pension plans) will be less generous. Unemployment isn't the only concern here. In fact, it is well down the list.

Of course, this says nothing at all about the philosophical question; to whit: Who is Klein to arbitrarily say that an employer must grant three weeks of paid vacation to everyone, even if the majority of public opinion is on his side? I mean, yeah... it would be nice to have more vacation. But it would also be nice to have more money. To the extent that there is a trade-off between the two, and it seems impossible that there isn't, Klein's decision to mandate one at the expense of the other for purely normative reasons (i.e. he personally wants more vacation, and is willing to sacrifice some salary to that end) is patently absurd. It is not the job of government to legislate preferences. Or, at least, it shouldn't be.

If this truly was something that was important to people, then labor unions would be pushing hard for the expansion of vacation time. Instead, they lobby for higher wages, more lucrative retirement plans, and more expansive health insurance. Those are the priorities, and forcing more vacation time on to people works against those ends. The fact that this isn't already a political issue, at all, should be enough of an experiment for Klein.

Labels:

Ha Ha

The excellent new Moreover blog isn't buying what Patrick Reardon is selling:

THE Chicago Tribune's Patrick Reardon comes out as a book-sniffer.

Here he is on the smell of a 1900 copy of Theodore Roosevelt's "Oliver Cromwell"

[I]t brings forth images of mansion foyers where tweed coats and thick furs used to hang amid a profusion of well-polished mahogany furniture.

And on "The Banquet Bug", a Chinese novel by Geling Yan:

There was an almost metallic bite to the way the pages smelled.

He concludes, a touch desperately:

I suspect many readers enjoy the olfactory experience of reading.

Well, actually, no, I'd never given it a thought. But I'll try it as soon as I've finish sucking on this DVD.

My only contribution? I don't much care what a book smells like, unless that smell is strong and perfumed.

Monday, July 16, 2007

Quote of the Day

Virginia Postrel says that "science is not enough":

Scientists have gotten way too fond of invoking their authority to claim that "science" dictates their preferred policy solutions and claiming that any disagreement constitutes an attack on science. But, even assuming that scientists agree on the facts, science can only tell us something about the state of the world. It cannot tell us what policy is the best to adopt. Scientists' preferences are not "science." You cannot go from an "is" (science) to an "ought" (policy). Social science, particularly economics, can tell you something about the likely tradeoffs (hence some of my frustrations at Aspen). But it can't tell you which tradeoffs to make.
She's right, of course, and nearly no one would disagree with the sentiment if presented in this way. But a lot of people, particularly in the area of climate change, think that scientific consensus is especially meaningful when it comes to normative policy-making. Unfortunately, a lot of scientists make this mistake. So yeah, Krugman can rant and rail about income inequality, and the need to tax the hell out of the rich to make up for it; yeah, Stern can go ballistic on climate change, and exactly how much the rich countries of the world *should* be willing to pay for fixing climate change; but these things don't exist in a vacuum. Realizing the prescriptions of these social scientists involves real costs for real people. It is at this point that normative arguments become most important. Scientists often forget this (or purposefully neglect it). So their arguments become more convincing to the (less educated) layperson, but don't stand up so well scrutiny.

Labels: ,

Half-Withdrawal?

I agree with Ross Douthat when he says that "drawing down" American troops from Iraq -- but still leaving a substantial force there to "combat al-Qaeda" or whatever -- may be the most politically feasible outcome, but would be disastrous nonetheless.

I don't know what to do about Iraq (obviously). But it seems to me that you can either look at the ongoing, low-grade civil war as something we have a moral and strategic obligation to prevent from spiraling out of control, in which case we need to follow Petraeus's lead and be prepared to continue the surge for months and years to come, regardless of the absence of a political settlement (and with the long-term hope that the violence will gradually diminish, and that Iraq circa 2015 will look like, say, Bosnia today); or you can argue that the cost of occupation to American national security outweighs our moral and strategic interests in preventing a greater bloodbath than we have now, in which case we ought to focus on getting out completely. (Or pulling back to Kurdistan, though I'm more skeptical than Andrew is about that option; his suggestion that "the Turks and the Kurds can become an arc of hope" for the region sounds an awful lot like like the frequent pre-Iraq War suggestion that "Iraq's Sunni and Shi'a can become an arc of hope" for a divided Middle East.) In other words, I swing back and forth between supporting Bill Kristol and supporting a hasty-as-possible withdrawal. But I suspect we'll get the worst of both worlds instead: A continued U.S. presence and continued U.S. casualties, and a steadily-worsening civil war that we're helpless to prevent.
I don't ever support Bill Kristol on anything, but I believe that Douthat is right: if we pull out entirely, we're not talking civil war anymore; we're talking genocide. If we keep a moderate-but-not-decisive level of troops in Iraq, we're accomplishing nothing, but doing so at a fairly great cost. If we maintain large troop levels, the situation will not improve quickly, but marginal gains may be made which could add up over time, and full-on genocide-as-proxy-war averted. The international community has done this in the former Yugoslavia, with a pretty good result. Maybe we can get something resembling Bosnia in a decade or so. That outcome isn't assured, but we can be pretty certain what will happen if we leave: another Rwanda, but with modern weaponry and funding from Iran, Syria, and Saudi Arabia. That seems unacceptable to me.

Labels:

I've Been Waiting for This

Finally... a reality-based take on the economic costs of "fixing" climate change, and, thus, the political infeasibility of doing anything significant any time soon. It's literally this simple: people want a cause, and climate change fits nicely because everyone is to blame, and everyone can contribute in some small way to lessen the effect (by putting in flourescent light bulbs or planting trees). But real, actual, meaningful changes -- the sort that will have any noticeable effect on climate change -- wouldn't get 10% of the vote in a referendum. People want a cause, but they also want that cause to come free-of-charge, or mostly so. But this stuff is all about trade-offs, and I don't know anybody who would sacrifice as much of their own economic well-being as would be required to "fix" the problem. People have a need to DO SOMETHING NOW about big problems; they don't have a need to truly examine the costs of solutions, or the true effects of their piddling actions. One square of toilet paper isn't going to save us. It will take massive economic sacrifices. Our legislators realize this, which is why nobody talks in specifics on this issue. This is why Kyoto got rejected (and hasn't been lived up to by a single one of its signatories).

The Stern Report estimated that at least 1% of world economic output would have to be sacrificed each year for about 100 years in order to combat climate change in a meaningful way. Doesn't sound like much? If, from 1870 to 1990, the U.S. had a 1% lower growth rate, we would be about as wealthy as Mexico today. That's a lot of economic growth being sacrificed over the next 3-4 generations.

Not only that, but that assumes that every country in the world is willing to get on board. Of course that isn't going to happen, so the richer West will have to shoulder even more of the burden to get the same amount of change. There's no point in sacrificing 1% of economic output if the rest of the world doesn't, and climage change continues unabated.

"Fixing" climate change has very real costs. Costs which nobody is willing to bear.

Labels: ,

Liberals Against Withdrawal

Andrew Sullivan quotes some readers saying some silly things, and then says a few himself:

Another reader writes:

Nice piece by the anti-war liberal who rightly is concerned at the moral implications of withdrawal. But he had a more cogent point when he noted there was a reason Saddam was so brutal – that he had to be to keep a lid on all the centuries of brewing tension. And that’s the problem with staying…we can only bring peace to a unified Iraq by imposing draconian measures on the country, a la Saddam, or by picking a new Saddam and sticking around long enough for him to do so. I don't think it would be moral to do so. Nor do we have the stomach for it. I fear the only outcome that offers a prayer of bringing the violence to a relatively quick end is to partition the country - Kurd, Shia and Sunni - and stick around long enough for each group to get out of the other's territory.

Soft-partition via withdrawal. It may be the best we can do. And it could be leveraged against Iran's leadership.



This is not an accurate representation of reality. The fact is that Sunni and Shia in Iraq got along pretty well under Saddam, despite the targeting of Shia by the dictator. Intermarriage rates were high, and intermingling was common, which is why there were so many mixed neighborhoods in Iraqi cities (some of which have since been ethnically cleansed). The notion of "centuries of brewing tension" is a myth. There had been some incidents of sectarian conflicts across the centuries, just as there has been between Protestants and Catholics, but a primordialist reading of recent events is not productive. This violence was not inevitable.

The probability of sectarian violence went up dramatically under Paul Bremer's leadership. His decision, as head of Coalition Provisional Authority, to disband the state-run industries and de-Baathify the police and military had several adverse effects:

1. It destroyed an already-decimated economy. The U.S. targeting the Iraqi infrastructure during the Persian Gulf War, destroying some 90% of Iraq's power-generating and distribution systems. The sanctions which followed made it impossible for the country to rebuild. What little economic activity remained was dominated by the state-run oil company. The dissolution of state-run companies by Bremer put a large portion of the country out of work almost overnight.

2. This poor economic situation was coupled with a power vacuum; Brewer dissolved the Iraqi police force and military during de-Baathification, and the U.S. did not bring in enough troops to ensure security. This situation, along with the economic degradation, led to an enormous boost in crime rates, hooliganism, and looting, from almost the first moment of U.S. invasion until now. This crime was sometimes done along sectarian lines, or at least was viewed as such. The situation hasn't improved since; most estimates of Iraqi unemployment are in the 70% range. But early on the crime was manifest as looting and theft; eventually, it migrated to ethnic cleansing and suicide-bombing, but that wasn't always the case. People had to be pushed to that end... it wasn't their first reaction.

3. Sectarian nationalists used these incidents, along with high unemployment levels and general economic dissatisfaction, to mobilize members of their respective groups. This was especially noticeable in the Sunni boycott of elections in 2005. Sunnis, as the minority, felt like they would not be able to influence the government, so they decided to not participate in the proceedings. It became a self-fulfilling prophecy, as the Shiite government began passing pro-Shiite policies. Sunnis began to look outside the government (and the U.S. forces, who they rightly viewed as siding with the Shiite government at their expense) for security. (Remember when it was called a "Sunni insurgency"?)

4. Militia leaders could promise salaries to ex-soldiers and police officers who couldn't find employment elsewhere. These men already had training and access to some weaponry. The looting and hooliganism became more organized and targeted, and violence levels subsequently increased.

5. This culminated in the Feb. 2006 bombing of the al-Askari mosque in Samarra. At that point, sectarian nationalists had all the ammo they needed to mobilize the citizenry, and the all-out civil war ensued.

Looking at the violence as stemming from centuries-old disputes neglects the lesson on offer here: economic degradation + lack of security = violence. It's similar to the demonization of the Jews by Hitler in Nazi Germany, or the demonization of Hutus in Rwanda, or the demonization of Croats by Milosevic in Serbia, etc. They all used economic degradation to incite and mobilize their consituents against some other ethnic/religious group, and a lack of security or authority made it possible. But the story isn't in theancient ethnic/religious tensions (even if some actually do exist); the story is in the specific socioeconomic and cultural situations, unique in each case.

After all, if it were all about ancient ethnic hatreds, then why aren't Sunni and Shiite fighting anywhere else but Iraq?

Partition solves none of these problems, and may encourage more as Sunni/Shiite/Kurds begin fighting each other over territory and oil fields. In other words, partition may lead to more violence; not less. It solves none of the underlying issues, and may contribute more divisiveness to the situation.

Labels:

Restoring Habeas Corpus

The move is on. Call your senators, and impress upon them the need to reinforce the Great Writ, which dates back to the 13th century in England. It has been neglected in this country for far too long.

(ht: Andrew Sullivan)

Labels:

Examining NAFTA

Brad DeLong -- one of the architects of NAFTA -- had his belief shaken. He acknowledges the real benefits that had occurred because of NAFTA, but expected much bigger effects. Tyler Cowen points him to a new paper which might re-embolden his faith. The bottom line:

The more globalized parts of Mexico -- most of all the north -- have done extremely well since NAFTA passed. The biggest problems remain in the least globalized parts, most of all the south and big chunks of the interior.
So measuring Mexico in the aggregate will leave a NAFTA-believer disappointed. But properly weighting the measurement shows something very different: NAFTA has been a huge success. And all without a giant sucking sound or even one poisoned strawberry.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, July 11, 2007

Soccer Blogging

Nobody here cares, but the U.S. men's U-20 World Cup team is through to quarter-finals after a contentious match with Uruguay. The first 2/3 of the match was sloppily-played by the U.S., as the back surrendered too many free kicks and corners. The loss of Altidore to injury at the start of the 2nd half left the U.S. attack impotent for much of the game. Uruguay had a 1-0 lead until Freddy Adu's corner set up an Uruguayan own goal (although it surely would've been put in by Akpan if Cardaccio had let it go) in the 87th minute. In extra time, Michael Bradley, who had been mostly non-existent offensively to that point, finished another Adu corner service in the 107th minute for the winner.

It's the U-20s, not the true World Cup, but it's still impressive that the U.S. has dominated Poland, stunned and eliminated Brazil, and now defeated Uruguay to make their way to the quarter-finals.

Next up is Austria on the 14th, a game that the U.S. can win.

Labels:

Giuliani Gets Swift-Boated

I wonder how he likes it.

Labels:

Why Iraq Is Getting Worse

Unemployment is at 70%. Success, however you're measuring that, cannot be achieved in Iraq when the majority of the populace is out of work. If you improve the economic situation in country, come up with a viable revenue-sharing program for the oil industry which is acceptable to Sunni, Shi'ite, and Kurd politicians, improve the employment situation... then you'll start to see some sort of stability in the country. Then you'll see the security situation improve. Then you'll see the suicide-murders decrease. Then you'll see a viable government emerge.

But until the economic situation improves, until viable economic institutions are in place, no peace is achievable.

ht: Andrew Sullivan

Labels:

Big Business for Universal Health Care?

Matthew Yglesias links to a BusinessWeek article which highlights wait times for American health care consumers. Of course, this argument is often used against universal health care systems in Canada and the U.K. by those who support privatized health care systems. To me, this isn't really a substantive point: in Canada and the U.K., wait times are common for specialized and elective care, while basic doctor visits are quicker. It's commonly said that hip surgeries in Canada require about a 9 month wait time, and if you are old enough in the U.K. you are simply ineligible for one. In the U.S., you might have to book a doctor's visit a few weeks in advance, but you get emergency care and elective procedures much more quickly. There is a trade-off there, and the U.K./Canadian systems are weighted to one end while the U.S. system is weighted to the other.

But the larger point was missed by both BusinessWeek and Yglesias: those in favor of a universal health care system could find an ally in Big Business. After all, a universal system would remove the high costs of health care provision currently being paid for by businesses. It requires a huge, expensive human resources bureaucracy, as well as opportunity costs of negotiating with insurance companies, form-filling, etc. A case might be made that the efficiency gains in the business sector from removing the burden of providing health insurance for their employees might mitigate some of the costs of nationalizing the insurance industry. I've never seen an empirical approximation of this effect; it may be small. But it's certainly a political tool which could be used by those in favor of universal insurance. If Big Business gets on board with universal coverage, then it's hard to imagine that it won't succeed politically. Why proponents of universal coverage haven't latched on to this is beyond me; perhaps those on the left are simply uncomfortable with building a coalition with Big Business, even though it is a rational alliance.

Labels:

Dick Cheney on D.C. Madam's List?

So says one rumor.

Just came in from Coffee at the Caribou Coffee at 16th and L in DC.

Ran into one of my old cronies.

DC Madam talk is all the conversation in DC.

Brace Yourself.

I was just told Dick Cheney, while CEO of Halliburton, used her services regularly, they are trying to spin up a message to explain that members of his staff, in his offices, used this service to entertain foreign clients.

Apparently several of his ex-staff at Halliburton are already being besieged by calls.

Make of it what you will. I think I would be happier knowing the Dick can dance like a John.

I would also like to make this note, as an Executive who has been trained in how to stay within the law of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act.

I was specifically instructed by our corporate lawyers never to pay for such services of clients, it is always found to be a violation of the FCPA.

Does this mean, the WH spin, which we will see coming out in the Next 24 hours will be:

Dick Cheney did not use an Escort Service...instead he committed violations of the FCPA and ordered others to do so?
Interesting Times.
Interesting times indeed.

Labels:

China's Environmental Problem

Marginal Revolution points us to a great article in the Washington Monthly about China's environmental problem. Pollution has been rampant, and the government can't control it on its own. So what is it doing? Empowering NGOs and individuals to do a lot of the work for them. It's a strategy that must work, or else China is in trouble.

P.S. On bad days, 25% of smog in L.A. originates from China. Didn't know that.

Labels: ,

Know Your Rights

At least 15 students were beaten up and arrested for protesting the continued imprisonment of 8 other students, who have held since May. This is a pretty common occurrence in Iran today, and this is why we should not bomb them (no matter what Podhoretz or Giuliani says). You see, these pro-democracy, pro-liberalization movements will continue to pick up steam in Iran, especially if the government continues to beat and arrest students who are demanding their rights. The economic situation in Iran is pretty bad because of Ahmadinejad's mis-management, and the people are becoming aware of it.

Yes, Ahmadinejad still calls for the destruction of Israel. Yes, he is still intent on developing nuclear power, most likely for weapons. But his people are turning on him, and this will continue as the economic situation deteriorates and pro-democracy movements gain ground. If we bomb Iran, or engage them militarily in any way, nationalism will surge in Iran and the people will rally around Ahmadinejad (think of the pro-Bush, pro-America, anti-Taliban sentiment in the U.S. after 9/11 as compared to the fractious political scene on 9/10, when no one knew or cared who the Taliban was, and more people disliked Bush than liked him).

Now, if Iran actually does threaten the U.S., then we should be prepared to act military in response. But to act preemptively would be disastrous. Anyway, Iran can't threaten the U.S. directly, and Israel has 200 nukes and the largest military (by far) in the MidEast. There is no threat from Iran, and if we encourage pro-democratic movements there with money and verbal support, we can do some good. If we invade or bomb the place, we will set back the cause of democracy and liberty in Iran for a generation or more.

The pro-liberty, pro-democracy, anti-war, anti-Mullah movement is alive and well, and will only grow. Unless we invade and turn the country against us.

Labels:

Hill vs. Bill

On matters of trade policy, the two Clintons couldn't be much further apart.

Of course, Bill's presidency helped create one of the most successful economic periods in our nation's history. So, perhaps Hill should just smile, wink, and say, "Remember the '90s?" instead of embracing economic nationalism. The U.S. needs to show tomorrow's power players -- Brazil, China, India, Russia -- that we are interested in them today. These are the countries which will become the most significant in the future, replacing the W. European dinosaurs. We need them on our side, or at least willing to talk to us.

Plus, tariff taxes are just bad policy. Unfortunately, they may also be good politics.

(ht: Great Mankiw)

Labels: ,

Tuesday, July 10, 2007

Giuliani hires Podhoretz

Rudy Giuliani must be opposed at all costs. He has just hired Norman Podhoretz, the man who wants to unilaterally bomb a country -- Iran -- which has not provoked us to war.

The man who said of the Iraq war: "an amazing success." He waves his fist and declaims, "There were WMD, and they were shipped to Syria. ... This picture of a country in total chaos with no security is false. It has been a triumph. It couldn't have gone better." He wants more wars, and fast. He is "certain" Bush will bomb Iran, and "thank God" for that.

Yes. He said that Iraq "couldn't have gone better". It was bad enough that Giuliani enthusiastically supports torture in violation of domestic and international law, saying things like:
"I would tell the people who had to do the interrogation to use every method they can think of" when asked if he would support the use of waterboarding, a technique perfected by the Khmer Rouge, and used by the Imperial Japanese and Waffen SS in WWII. That was bad enough to disqualify him from holding any public office.

But now his senior foreign policy advisor is a man who is clearly deluded about the situation on the ground in Iraq, is clearly deluded about the situation in Iraq pre-war, and wants to start bombing more countries for no particular reason. This clearly eliminates Giuliani as a viable voting option for anyone who cares about liberty, justice, the rule of law, or the international interests of the United States. Which should include everyone.

At this point, Romney seems like the best of a lot of bad options on the GOP side.

Update: Apparently, a lot of Catholics agree that Giuliani must be opposed. (ht: Andrew Sullivan)

Labels: , , , ,

The Cost of Freedom Fries

Andrew Sullivan points us to Free Exchange, the economics blog of The Economist, where we learn of a paper recently published by the Centre for Economic Policy Research in which the costs of anti-gallic sentiment in America following France's decision to not support the U.S. war effort in Iraq.

It seems that market forces have not yet stopped American businessmen indulging the Francophobia that swept the nation in the run-up to the invasion of Iraq. Between February 2002 and March 2003, the percentage of Americans who had a favourable view of France fell from 83% (it’s hard to remember it was ever so high) to just 35%. By 2005, that aversion to all things gallic was costing France about $5 billion-worth of exports, the two authors calculate. It was not just American shoppers boycotting French wine (down by 13% over six months in 2003) and holidays. The bulk of the fall was in inputs (industrial machinery etc.) not consumer goods. France rarely dominates these markets, leaving American businessmen freer to buy elsewhere. In consumer goods, however, France is either the Oscar-winning supplier (champagne) or it’s so anonymous that no one knows they’re buying from France in the first place.
It's easy to scoff, but I don't think it's really that big of a deal for France. After all, we're now spending $10bn./month in Iraq, and $2bn./month in Afghanistan, so $5 billion over the course of two or three years is getting off pretty cheaply; it surely would have been much more expensive for them if they'd given us support on par with, say, the U.K., which started out budgeting ~ £3bn./year for the war in 2003, and is now at £7.5bn. for this year. And France's total exports are ~ $500bn./year, so a loss of $5bn over a few years isn't that big of a deal. A far greater worry is their loss of domination over the wine industry.

Labels: ,

More on the HRC/Obama China Tariff...

... which I first blogged about here. Matthew Yglesias reads Brad DeLong and wonders:

Now where I tend to lose the plot is this. If mainstream economists like Brad think it's a bad idea to use threats of tariffs to push China into changing its exchange-rate policies, how come the economics mainstream seems to have so few complaints about the fact that it's completely normal for US trade negotiators to use exactly this sort of leverage to try to get other countries to change the intellectual properties policies or to privatize their water systems or what have you? Why is the threat to shoot ourselves in the foot okay when made on behalf of pharmaceutical companies and movie studios, but not when made on behalf of import-competing manufacturers? Often when I see this argument made, I feel like the point is -- aha! hypocrites! you should support our China bill after all! -- but I really do think Brad's right, this is a bad bill. But by the same token, the people who complain about this sort of thing ought to complain about the other sort of thing as well.
There are a couple answers to this:

1. Most in the "economics mainstream" -- i.e. the orthodox theories and those who espouse them -- do oppose using these tactics in bilateral or multilateral trade negotiations. It's "normal" for US trade negotiators to use these tactics, but not because economists approve of it. It's common for US trade negotiators to use these tactics because their job isn't to enact good economic policies; it is to extract concessions from other countries so that trade agreements will be more politically feasible. But usually, we would never put tariffs on another country unless they are violation of WTO rules.

2. The US trade negotiators have different rule sets when negotiating with, say, Chile than they do when negotiating with China. We can easily do without having Chile as a trading partner, and we have the upper-hand in any negotiations with them because they need access to our markets much more than we need access to theirs. So we can browbeat them into doing just about whatever we want them to do by threatening tariffs or other punitive punishments. With China it's not so easy. We do rely on China much more than other countries. Not only do they provide a lot of our consumption, but they also hold a lot of our debt. Because of that, and past military tensions, we view them as a threat to our hegemony (or, at least, some people do). So, threats of tariffs are made, despite the fact that it would hurt us more than China (but they still will hurt China). And, unlike Chile, China isn't going to do whatever we want whenever we want it, so we've got to act like we've got a big stick. We don't have the same sort of leverage against China that we have with Chile.

Also, we do threaten tariffs and other punitive punishments against China for violating intellectual property laws (e.g. pirated software and movies). And part of the reason why Doha has failed so far is because of the US's insistence on the inclusion of intellectual property reform in the developing world. Most economists disagree with that line of logic, although the patent system and intellectual property laws are a wholly separate beast from import-competing manufacturing. After all, in the former cases, Chinese producers aren't producing a product at lower cost than American producers can; they're just free-riding on American innovation without paying anything at all for it. In some cases, they are stealing our products outright. It's a difficult and complex issue, and not easily comparable to standard international trade logic.

Labels: , , ,

Another Meme Put to Rest

A common conservative argument against looser immigration or amnesty for workers already here is that they are prone to crime and violence. It's an appealing argument, but it has no basis in reality. In fact, the opposite is true:

In fact, immigrants have much lower institutionalization (incarceration) rates than the native born - on the order of one-fifth the rate of natives. More recently arrived immigrants have the lowest relative incarceration rates, and this difference increased from 1980 to 2000. We examine whether the improvement in immigrants' relative incarceration rates over the last three decades is linked to increased deportation, immigrant self-selection, or deterrence. Our evidence suggests that deportation does not drive the results. Rather, the process of migration selects individuals who either have lower criminal propensities or are more responsive to deterrent effects than the average native.

We should be welcoming these people, and helping them attain some sort of legal status. Not demonizing them, and trying to throw them all out.

Labels:

Heads-Up

Baseball Prospectus is free this week. Anyone who cares at all about baseball should peruse the site and consider subscribing. It's simply the best baseball resource available.

Russell Kirk: "Contemptuous Conservative"

Alan Wolfe reviews a new Russell Kirk anthology for TNR, and he doesn't like what he sees. The penultimate graf:

George W. Bush once called himself a compassionate conservative. Russell Kirk is a contemptuous conservative. Kirk is contemptuous of people, or at least those whose very existence prevents gentlemen aristocrats from sitting in front of the fire reading Aristotle while their slaves, or their wives, prepared their dinner. He is contemptuous of ideas, or of those ideas with which he disagrees, and prefers caricaturing them to arguing with them. He is contemptuous of the world in which he lived, always exaggerating the bad and having nary a word to say about the good. He is contemptuous of the truth, mangling his facts and distorting the history of the country he claims to love. His is not the conservatism of the country club; Kirk is no northeastern aristocrat determined to protect the exclusivity of his turf. His is the conservatism of George Babbitt, not Irving Babbitt: provincial, resentful, bigoted. If you collected all the grumblings in a small-town drugstore by men convinced that somehow the world had passed them by, and then added a few literary and historical references, you would have The Essential Russell Kirk.

Labels:

The Return of John McClain

Right, so I'm a big Die Hard fan, and I just got about to watching the fourth installment. I'm not as infatuated with it as many seem to be; by my reckoning it's the third best Die Hard, ahead of "2," but behind "3" and "1," in that order. The (obvious) repeated use of "Fortunate Son" was irritating, because the movie didn't have point, shouldn't've had a point, and that song means nothing without context. So it came across as a worthless cheap shot.

Elsewhere... I thought it was interesting that McClain's sidekick this time around was Macboy, and yet all the hyper-cool hacking equipment were all PCs, from the laptops to the PDAs.

All in all, tho, it was alright. I'd've preferred some more special-effects-violence, but apparently the makers wanted it to stay PG-13. Oh well.

Monday, July 9, 2007

An Important Resource

Scott Lemiuex points Matthew Iglesias to Marty Lederman, who has compiled an archive of Balkinization's posts: "The Anti-Torture Memos: Balkinization Posts on Torture, Interrogation, Detention, War Powers, Executive Authority, DOJ and OLC." There are a lot of them, because the Bush administration has so often abused their authority and broken domestic and international laws. If anyone is still trying to argue that point, just point them here. The debate is over; there is no counter-argument to be made.

Labels:

HRC & Obama: Death to China!

No, no, no! Please, no more of this!

Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama, the frontrunners for the Democratic presidential nomination, have agreed to co-sponsor legislation that would levy punitive duties on Chinese goods to cajole Beijing into revaluing its currency, according to aides.
Okay, the economic logic of this is absurd. Presumably, Sens Clinton and Obama are concerned about job loss in American industrial sectors, and China makes an easy political target. It makes political sense to express concern: Pennsylvania and Ohio are swing states, and Michigan is also up for grabs. Some good ole' fashioned populism could help their campaigns, especially in a general election.

But the economics is just silly. First of all, unemployment levels have remained very low in the U.S. In fact, they've been surprisingly low. Our median wages continue to increase, while consumption inequality has remained mostly constant. The things we mainly import from China are products of unskilled labor industries which don't exist in America any more (e.g. shoes, clothes, toys), so any significant employment gains are unlikely.

Not only that, but the U.S. has a pretty severe trade deficit with China. Which means that we import more from them than we export. If China raises the value of its currency, then our imports become more expensive. So... our trade deficit will increase, or else our imports will go down. If our imports from China go down, then our standards of living go down. In either case, inflation increases with the price level, and the FED has to further raise interest rates (or, at least not lower them) to keep inflation in check. This causes business investment to decrease, which causes future economic growth to recede, and also lowers domestic employment. Meanwhile, the incidence of the tariff tax would be regressive, as low-income people are the ones most reliant on cheap imports. The poor Walmart shopper would be hurt the most.

If China is devaluing their currency, then they are effectively subsidizing American consumption of the goods they produce. In other words, China is transferring money from themselves to us. They are giving us money for nothing. We should be thanking them... not threatening them.

So what would these tariffs accomplish? They would raise the costs of living of American consumers, eliminate the surplus gains we are getting from trade with China, and eliminate the surplus gains we are getting from China's devalued currency. Not only that, but it would jeopardize political relations with China, which will become more and more important over the coming years. It's a bad policy, in every way.

So no surprise that a few presidential hopefuls would be proposing it.

UPDATE: Brad DeLong, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Treasury under Pres. Clinton, and strong Democratic supporter, doesn't like the policy proposal either:

Of course, then the candidates will be attacking US consumers (who will pay higher prices for imports), workers in the construction industry, US borrowers (who will then pay higher interest rates to domestic and foreign creditors), and US homeowners (who will see the higher interest rates push down housing prices and reduce their equity). The net short-run effect is surely a minus--it's not as though we desperately need to swap construction jobs for manufacturing jobs right now, and we surely don't need a more-rapid decline in housing prices right now.
But then he says something interesting:

In the long run of three to five years, yes: The renminbi needs to become worth a lot more (primarily for China's sake). Pressure on China to adopt better policies is helpful (provided we don't shoot ourselves in the foot). But this strikes me as a classic threat to shoot ourselves in the foot: it is not a good policy move on either Obama's or Rodham Clinton's part.
If the RMB needs to appreciate for China's sake, then that supports my original point: a rise in the value of the yuan will be detrimental for American consumer in the short or long run. If you want to make the case that appreciation of the yuan would benefit Chinese, then be my guest. But if you want to argue that appreciation of the yuan would benefit Americans... then you've got a lot of evidence and theory to overcome.

Labels: , ,