Monday, June 25, 2007

Does GDP Matter?

Stanford economist Bob Hall says "not really":

When I raised this question with Bob Hall, a top-notch economist at Stanford University (who also serves as chairman of the NBER Business Cycle Dating Committee), he wrote back in an email:
Our command over resources in the world is measured by our real income, not real GDP. Improved terms of trade--cheaper imports--raises our real income even if it does not affect productivity or output. This is the difference between the GDP deflator, which does not respond to import prices, and the consumption deflator, which falls when imports cheapen. Real income is national income divided by the consumption deflator.

And what I asked him what the goal of economic policy should be, his response:

We should maximize the present value of real income
...

Now, I understand the logic, and I intend to write a piece exploring this perspective for BW (which certainly puts a different spin on the cover). But boy, after 18 years at BW writing about real GDP growth and domestic productivity growth as the appropriate benchmarks for economic policy, I'm left scratching my head a bit.

Comments?

Update: Bob's comment on reading the item: "It's just as important to give US consumers access to cheap foreign goods as it is to make real GDP bigger."
Tyler Cowen says that we should forget this sentiment; I'm not exactly sure why, and he doesn't expound. (Maybe it's because when we try to forget something, we actually reinforce it, and Dr. Cowen wants us all to learn a lesson.)

Labels:

An Assault on the Pigou Club

I'm in favor of carbon taxes. I also realize that they are politically infeasible. So does Robert Reich, who proposes an alternate solution to the energy Hydra Head (climate change, exporting money to despots, exposure to potential supply shocks, etc.), and it isn't cap-and-trade:

The best idea I've heard is described as a carbon auction. Companies would have to bid for the right to pollute. And, most ingeniously, the money raised in the auction would be shared equally by all citizens in the form of yearly dividend checks -- just like the residents of Alaska now get yearly dividends for their share of the state's oil revenues.

I mean, it's our atmosphere, right? Think of a national park or a national forest. No company is simply allowed to take what they want from it, free of charge. Why should the atmosphere be any different? In a carbon auction, companies would have to bid against other companies for a portion of the atmosphere they intend to use -- within overall limits that reduce pollution levels.

Get it? It's a win-win. The auction market itself determines who can pollute and by how much. And since companies will inevitably want to reduce their bidding costs, they'll search for new technologies that cut their emissions. And even if companies pass on increased costs to their customers, we'll still be better off because we'll get dividend checks and cleaner air.

Message to presidential candidates: American voters will buy this one. And it's good policy.

Reich is certainly right: a carbon auction is more politically feasible than a Pigouvian carbon tax. But it's also less effective. The overall aim -- to reduce emissions -- is the same, but the Pigouvian tax attacks demand, while the carbon auction takes aim at supply. In order to have the same effect, carbon auctions would have to have a prohibitively high "reserve" (minimum price), and/or the number of available carbon permits would have to be limited in some way, thus mirroring the cap-and-trade system which Reich opposes.

Reich maintains that this system would foster technological improvements in order to reduce their costs. This would be true if the energy industry was competitive, with little or no barriers to entry. In fact, however, the energy industry most closely resembles an oligopoly, with incredibly high fixed costs and many other barriers to entry. As American deregulation has shown, treating the energy industry as if it were a competitive industry can have disastrous results.

The carbon tax may be less politically feasible, but it would certainly have a greater effect. It is regressive, but making it revenue-neutral by combining it with a big expansion of the EITC could off-set most of those negative effects. A carbon auction might be more feasible; it might even be second-best, but it can't be better than that. And, as Matthew Yglesias is wont to say, all progressive policies seem impossible at first; changing the political dynamic is a process. But that doesn't mean that we should stop trying, or automatically settle for the easiest option.

(ht: Greg Mankiw, who doesn't seem impressed with Reich's logic)

Labels: , ,

An Unsensible Immigration Proposal

Jane Galt (er, Megan McArdle) tries to pull a fast one:

My preferred immigration plan would be to massively increase the number of visas, set a very minimal bar to meet--not a terrorist, not a criminal, not carrying a hideous contagious disease--and then auction off various tranches of visas, classed not by type but by length of stay. Let the visas be transferrable. Then let immigrant communities do enforcement for you, as illegal immigrants suddenly threaten to erode the price of their valuable asset: the right to stay in-country.
This sort of libertarian thinking is why I'm not a libertarian; Just because some immigrants -- those who are capable of winning visas via auction -- have a market advantage over other immigrants -- those who aren't able to obtain visas -- does not necessarily mean that they will "do law enforcement for you". In fact, there is little reason to believe that they will. People do not enjoy ratting out other people, even if they know someone else is doing something illegal, unless their own liberty or safety is at risk. Most people don't call the cops when a fellow driver is speeding, or even if they are swerving and appear to be intoxicated. Most people don't call the cops if they find that one of their friends uses illegal drugs.

Not only that, but these sorts of "markets" often beget other (illegal) markets. So if this sort of policy was enacted, I would expect an increase in markets for fake documentation, or communities which clandestinely shelter illegal immigrants. Legal immigrants will often have incentives to disguise illegal immigrants: ethnic identity, familial ties, economic incentives, etc. This sort of thinking belies the (classical) liberal fallacy w/r/t ethnic tensions (which, of course, is really what the immigration hullabaloo is mostly about): markets do not cure all ails. The current immigrant quagmire represents a political market failure, with external effects that affect hundreds of millions of people across two entire continents.

The answer, I would expect the libertarians at Overcoming Bias to say, is for citizens (esp. on the right wing) to move beyond the racial/ethnic dimension of the debate, and encourage truly open labor mobility (if they are in favor of free markets) or truly/mostly closed labor mobility (if they are nationalists). Lip-service to free markets from "conservatives" isn't enough, and neither are scare tactics from ethnic entrepreneurs (i.e. nationalists). True dedication to free markets would entail fully open borders (except to known violent criminals or those carrying contagious diseases).

Ms. Galt (er, McArdle) does have a great point about the immigration debate in another post:

I find the argument that the problem with immigrants is illegal immigration pretty uncompelling. First of all, it's almost (not always) made by people who don't want to let those people (or equivalent numbers of their more law abiding compatriots) in legally, and react against any proposal to do so with exactly the vehemence that they complain about the illegal entry of illegal immigrants. The people making that argument may not be trying to be disingenuous, but ultimately, this is a pointless distraction: their real problem is that they don't want that many immigrants here, regardless of whether they entered legally or not.

...

It is far from clear to me that being an illegal alien is a morally wrong, as opposed to legally wrong, act. It might even be a morally required act, if, say, your income is getting medical care and food for children back in Mexico who would otherwise died. But regardless of your opinion on the matter, you can't simply say "But they're illegal"; given that there is dispute about the moral status of our immigration laws, you first have to prove to your interlocutor's satisfaction that the law ought to exist. None of the people I've talked to who say that their problem is not the immigrants themselves, but their legal status, has even tried to prove that our immigration restrictions are just and right--which is strange, because those people generally want to make them even more draconian.
In other, somewhat related, news... Jane Galt/Megan McArdle has just been deleted from Wikipedia. Apparently, she isn't notable enough.

Labels:

Tuesday, June 19, 2007

12 (faux) Principles of (Political) Economics

YouNotSneaky might be snarky, but he/she is mostly right:

1. The answer to most questions in economics is usually “It depends”.
2. People respond to incentives, but incentives are determined in their own head and who knows what goes on in there.
3. But on average, masses of people respond in fairly predictable ways and these predictable ways, embodied in the so-called “Econ 101” thinking, are pretty useful guides. They are not absolutes however.
4. “On one hand … on the other hand” is about as good as you can do in a complicated world.
5. All economic models boil down to two (occasionally three) curves on a blackboard that cross. If it’s more than that or if you can't draw it that way, then your model stinks.
6. First Fundamental Theorem of Economics: Where the two curves cross, it’s important.
7. Game theory accidentally teaches us that outcomes are very sensitive to the structure of interaction. Small changes in the rules of the game can produce vastly different outcomes.
8. A logical, aesthetically compelling, story is important, even if the assumptions are crazy. Check it with math.
9. Anyone who makes exaggerated claims about their pet theories, ideas, or solutions, be they mainstream or heterodox, either doesn’t know what they’re talking about, hasn’t done their homework or is trying to sell you something. “Our results SUGGEST…” is a good indicator that a person has thought hard about their subject. At least as far as these things go. A thorough method combined with some humility should invite more attention than extraordinary claims of genius. Scientific progress takes place at the margin.
10. When an economic idea about how things work pops into your head, your very next question should be “why is that wrong?”. It’s useful to simulate competition among ideas in your brains so that only the truly good ones survive. Success, however, is not guaranteed.
13. “I don’t know” is often the best answer that can be given.
It's hard to disagree with any of these, but 1, 2, 4, 9, & 13 ring truest to me.

ht: Ezra Klein

Labels:

A Sensible Immigration Proposal

Virgina Postrel points Daniel Drezner to Jonathan Rauch at the National Journal, who has a sensible immigration proposal:

[T]he Senate bill was worse than it needed to be. On the legal side of the immigration equation, there are easy trade-ups to be had. In fact, even a National Journal columnist with no apparent qualifications could write a better bill.

And what might that look like? Glad you asked.

  • First, raise the number of legal immigrants by about 50 percent, to about 1.8 million a year. That meets the economy's demonstrated demand for workers.
  • Second, provide pathways to permanence. Bring in these 1.8 million people on temporary visas, say for three to five years, with the promise of permanent legal residency (a green card) if they stay out of trouble, pose no security risk, and work or get a college degree.
  • Third, don't micromanage who gets in. Allocate visas using a simple three-way formula that gives about equal weight to family, work, and education: 600,000 family visas for close relatives of citizens and green-card holders; 600,000 work visas for people who are sponsored by an employer and have less than a bachelor's degree; 600,000 education visas for people who hold a bachelor's degree or higher, with first call going to those who also have employer sponsorships or family ties.
  • There is no chance, at the moment, that this plan will be adopted. But there is some chance that making the case for it might help clarify what the country should be shopping for in an immigration reform measure.

    The most basic decision any immigration bill needs to make is this: How many immigrants does the country need and want? Bizarrely, this was the one question that the debate over the Senate bill did not seem to concern itself with. Even finding estimates for total immigration under the Senate reform proved dauntingly difficult until the Congressional Budget Office published some projections last week.



    I would be in favor of such a plan, if it included some sort of provision -- whether amnesty, or some sort of earned legal status -- for the 12-20 million undocumented immigrants already in the country.

    Labels:

    Thomas P.M. Barnett Video

    "Peretz Is Batshit Crazy...

    ... TNR produces a lot of good stuff. Such are the ironies of life."

    Eric Alterman examines Marty Peretz's tenure at The New Republic from his perch at The American Prospect. It's possible that there is some jealousy involved -- TAP has seemingly always wanted to be TNR -- but it's hard to argue any of Alterman's key points: Peretz is an ideological idiot, and TNR has lost lots of its cachet under his leadership. It's an informative article.

    Monday, June 18, 2007

    World's Worst Currencies

    Chavez made the list, despite having bragged "we're going to end monetary instability in Venezuela." Chavez's reaction? Imprisoning those who violate price controls, introducing a 12.5 cent coin, and arbitrarily removing three zeros from the bolivar. The result? The official bolivar/dollar exchange rate is roughly half the black market rate. Chavez hasn't quite reached Mugabe-like levels of economic mismanagement, but he's on the same path.

    Iran didn't make Foreign Policy's round-up, but they are similarly in trouble:

    Some 60 economists this week wrote to Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadi-Nejad criticising his government for putting “short-term welfare above long-term sustainable development”.

    Almost half way through his first four-year term, the letter underlines the acute dilemmas faced by the president in delivering short-term welfare promises as he manoeuvres to bolster political support.

    The government’s indecision over two major issues – the price of petrol and bank lending rates – is a particular source of confusion.

    More than three weeks after the lapse of the original date for petrol rationing – designed to curb a $5bn (€3.75bn, £2.5bn) bill for importing 35m of the 75m litres Iran consumes daily – the government is still groping its way around any decision it fears might be unpopular. Officials have this week made differing statements over when and how rationing – which was to begin tomorrow – will start....

    Private bankers wrote to the economy minister last week demanding a freeze on loan rates to “make survival of private banks possible”.

    But even with inflation officially at 13.6 per cent last year, Mr Ahmadi-Nejad is battling with the central bank over his insistence on a 12 per cent lending rate, down from the current 14 per cent in state-owned and 17 per cent in private banks. The Guardian Council, a constitution watchdog, is due to rule this week on a compromise.

    “What the government describes as economic policies do not match any professionally-known theories, but are rather populist political policies,” said Mohammad Tabibian, former deputy head of the Management and Planning Organisation, a cross-governmental co-ordination body....

    Many observers doubt official figures of 14 per cent inflation and 12 per cent unemployment. One economist told the FT that inflation was above 20 per cent, while unemployment was 25 per cent among university graduates.



    There's no need to go to war with Iran; at this rate, they will crumble the same way the Soviet Union crumbled: through economic mismanagement coupled with fickle oil markets.

    ht: Daniel Drezner

    Labels: , ,

    Small World

    I just found out tonight that a childhood acquaintance has become a stand-up comic. Daniel Tosh and I had a similar up-bringing: preacher's kid, home schooled, and his family went to my father's church for a few years when I was pretty young. I don't remember much about him, except that he could make much better paper airplanes than me.

    I'm watching his stand-up special on Comedy Central right now, and it's actually pretty good. Biting, acerbic, intelligent.

    Small world.

    Saturday, June 16, 2007

    Wait... What?

    Dani Rodrik is much smarter than I am, so I must be missing something. He says that the Doha round should fail, because it claims to be focussed on "development" but really isn't. He then cites this as evidence:

    Not only are the global welfare effects quite small, low-income African countries emerge as losers in most of the models. The reasons are essentially twofold. First, low-income countries will lose some of their preferential market access to rich countries as the latter reduce their tariffs to other, less poor countries. Second, removal of agricultural subsidies will raise the world price of agricultural commodities, imposing a net burden on the poorest nations of the world, who tend to be food importers. Here is the distribution of gains (and losses) according to the leading models:

    image

    Keep this picture in mind next time you hear someone decry what a catastrophe it would be for Doha to fail.

    One of us isn't looking at the graph properly. The graph I'm looking at shows the majority of gains going to "low income" and "middle income" countries, with smaller gains for "high income" countries. Indeed, the only losers seems to be low-income countries in Africa and not low-income countries overall. Everyone not in Africa is better off, including the billions in Asia and Latin America who are still incredibly poor.

    This isn't too surprising to me. Developing countries in Asia, Latin America, and Eastern Europe all have much more political clout than developing countries in Africa, and the G-20 Developing Countries demands a reduction in agricultural subsidies in the U.S., E.U., and Japan. In other words, they want more market penetration for their farmers in the big markets, and first-world ag subsidies essentially limits (or outright prevents) that.

    But Africa, unlike Latin America, isn't a net exporter of agriculture; it's a net importer. So E.U. ag supports not only subsidize E.U. farmers, they also subsidize African consumers. By eliminating the supports, food costs for Africa will increase, and much of Africa exports nearly nothing except natural resources (oil, diamonds, minerals, etc.) to the first-world, they aren't getting anything in return.

    But that doesn't mean that liberalization of world agriculture markets isn't a good idea in balance. Agricultural products are highly substitutable, which is why the huge first-world subsidies exist in the first place. Africa will become less reliant on European ag products, but this will necessarily lead to development of their ag capabilities (possibly with an increase in FDI flows from the first-world to Africa, or through increase foreign aid), or purchases from other parts of the developing world who have a comparative advantage in agriculture. True, in the short run Africa might be worse off (while the rest of the developing world is better off), but in the long run this is a necessary step for the enrichment of the developing world.

    UPDATE: Okay, I'm not crazy. In the comments section of Rodrik's post, "Justin" says:

    I agree with Vyborny's conclusion that the best deal would be to completely open up markets for developing nations - no duties, no quotas. In fact, in an ideal world, this would be the goal that all countries would be working towards. It can even be reasonably argued that the U.S. should unilaterally open its borders to complete and total free trade. What better statement could the U.S. make about its commitment to fight world poverty, while at the same time reaping the benefits of increased international trade?

    I do take issues with other portions of Vyborny's report, however. The most flagrant is exemplified by this quote:

    "The models are not intended to predict how the world or country level economies will evolve in the future, but rather to estimate the specific role of trade policy changes apart from other changes in the economy"

    It is incomprehensible to me how anyone could even ATTEMPT to calculate the impacts of trade policy without considering other economic changes that might occur, let alone justifiy the results of such calculations. Perhaps I am just being obtuse...

    And then Ms. Vyborny, author of the essay in question, chimes in:

    As commenter Justin noted, the models found that if the U.S. and other rich countries offered a "development package" of complete duty-free quota-free access for the poorest turned the Doha losses into wins for all the African countries - making a true Doha Development Round still very much worth pursuing.

    Labels: , ,

    Brad DeLong Doesn't Agree with Krugman Either

    Brad DeLong, who very rarely disagrees with Paul Krugman on anything, disagrees with Paul Krugman on his latest inequality column:

    Paul Krugman writes about the link between expanding trade--especially between the U.S. and China--and rising income and wealth inequality within the United States. I find myself skeptical. Yes, China is exporting a lot of goods that it produces using low-skill labor. But if those goods were to be produced here in the United States, they would be produced with higher-skil labor and with lots of capital. The key question is how has the shift in economic activity created by expanding trade affected the demand for different kinds of labor and capital here in the United States. We have had:
    • A shrinkage in export and import-competing manufacturing.
    • A tremendous expansion in construction.
    • An expansion in consumer services.

    I don't see how those shifts significantly reduce the demand for factor of production "labor" and enhance the demand for factor of production "capital." Construction employs lots of capital--but so does tradeable manufacturing. I want to see Leontief input-output matrices for the U.S. before I upweight trade and downweight education, collapsing unions, migration, changing norms, monetary policy, and other factors as more likely to be responsible for the lion's share of the increase in U.S. inequality over the past generation and a half.

    And "outsourcing": outsourcing seems at least as likely to me to equalize the U.S. income distribution as to give it a further inequality boost. Consider what kinds of jobs are likely to be outsourced.

    Right. Plus, as I mentioned before, this goes against the changes in inequality that shows up in the Piketty-Saez data: namely, that nearly all the increased inequality is benefiting the top 1% of the population; they aren't really affected by a loss of American manufacturing jobs (unless they are all CEOs of corporations with subsidiaries in China, I guess).

    Labels: ,

    Diamond Engagement Rings Suck

    So says Meghan O'Rourke:

    For those who aren't bothered by the finer points of gender equity, an engagement ring clearly makes a claim about the status of a woman's sexual currency. It's a big, shiny NO TRESPASSING sign, stating that the woman wearing it has been bought and paid for, while her beau is out there sign-free and all too easily trespassable, until the wedding. (There might be an equitable case for pregnancy rings, since bearing children is inherently unequal—but that's its own can of worms.) In fact, many ads, including a recent series by Tiffany, imply that giving a ring results in a woman's sexual debt—as these parodies brilliantly capture.
    I think the wedding industry is horrific. I can't comprehend the amount of time, money, and emotional that many couples invest into their wedding days. And almost every married couple I've talked to has admitted that the day itself really wasn't very fun at all; too much stress, too little sleep, too many hands to shake and obscure friends/relatives to acknowledge and please. The whole thing seems like a sham marketing campaign.

    That said, it seems pretty crazy to argue that a social requirement for a man to pay two months salary on a gift for his future wife is somehow skewed against the woman. I mean, she gets the ring, but what does the guy get? Yeah, there's an outward recognition that she is engaged to be married, but I'm not sure why that's so pernicious. After all, she is engaged to be married. And I'm sure that plenty of guys would rather spend the two months' salary on, say, a down-payment on a house or something.

    But the brides-to-be wouldn't have that. They need a huge rock to show off to their friends. They want the symbol, because it shows that someone values them pretty highly. At this point, it seems more common than not for the prospective bride to pick out her own ring, so the thing is hardly even a gift any more. It's an obligation, to which the future husband is a slave. It's just part of the deal. But I don't see what the guys gets in return. As O'Rourke says, virginity used to be a prerequisite for women who wanted to be married, and the ring was sort of a guarantee against it. Now, not so much. So the tradition of giving engagement rings seems to be skewed against the man, not that woman. I'm not so sure that feminists should complain too loudly about this, or they may get what they wish for: nothing.

    Thursday, June 14, 2007

    Paul Krugman Says Globalization Leads to Higher Income Inequality After All

    This is a big difference from the mantra in the 1990s and early-00s. And he blames China:

    At the same time, the rise of China has prevented, for the time being, a development that I and others expected to mitigate the effects of trade on income distribution: up-skilling by the developing country exporters. “As newly industrializing countries grow,” I wrote in 1995, “their comparative advantage may shift away from products of very low skill intensity.” And that’s exactly what happened – for the countries that were the major exporters of manufactured goods to the OECD then. As John Romalis has shown, the exports of the original group of Asian newly-industrialising economies have shifted dramatically away from labour-intensive toward skill-intensive products.

    But along has come China, which is far more labour-abundant now than the NIEs were then. A simple indicator is relative wage rates: in 1990, according to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, the original four Asian NIEs had hourly compensation costs that were 25% of the US level. Now the BLS estimates that China’s labour costs are only 3% of US levels.

    In 1995 I also believed that the effects of trade on inequality would eventually hit a limit, because at a certain point advanced economies would run out of labour-intensive industries to lose – more formally, that we’d reach a point of complete specialisation, beyond which further growth in trade would have no further effects on wages. What has happened instead is that the limit keeps being pushed out, as trade creates “new” labour-intensive industries through the fragmentation of production.

    Strangely, however, this contradicts some of his earlier premises. Namely, that increased income inequality is almost all concentrated in the top 1% of of Americans, and the further up the ladder you go, the further the gains in income shares are held. So, if China has increased the college wage premium at the expense of lower-skilled workers, we should expect the income gains to be spread more broadly across those in the distribution who have attained higher levels of education. But they haven't been; the gains in wage shares have gone almost entirely to the very top of the income distribution.

    The data, especially the Piketty-Saez data that Krugman loves to cite, is more consistent with Rosen's "superstar" theories, or (especially) with the the "income shifting" arguments of Slemrod and others, or with the data that shows that changes in the tax code led wealthy Americans to work more, or that changes in the tax code changed the predominant method of CEO compensation from wages to stock options. If China is truly significant, it's importance is seemingly being crowded out by other factors. Either that, or the Piketty-Saez data isn't providing a true representation of inequality.

    Labels: ,

    Wednesday, June 13, 2007

    Why Reagan Didn't Defeat the Soviets

    Tyler Cowen points us to Yegor Gaidar, who instructs us that Reagan didn't defeat the Soviets through his tough talk and mental discipline alone. In fact, it turns out, Reagan didn't defeat the Soviets at all; the Saudis did.

    The timeline of the collapse of the Soviet Union can be traced to September 13, 1985. On this date, Sheikh Ahmed Zaki Yamani, the minister of oil of Saudi Arabia, declared that the monarchy had decided to alter its oil policy radically. The Saudis stopped protecting oil prices, and Saudi Arabia quickly regained its share in the world market. During the next six months, oil production in Saudi Arabia increased fourfold, while oil prices collapsed by approximately the same amount in real terms.

    As a result, the Soviet Union lost approximately $20 billion per year, money without which the country simply could not survive. The Soviet leadership was confronted with a difficult decision on how to adjust. There were three options--or a combination of three options--available to the Soviet leadership.

    First, dissolve the Eastern European empire and effectively stop barter trade in oil and gas with the Socialist bloc countries, and start charging hard currency for the hydrocarbons. This choice, however, involved convincing the Soviet leadership in 1985 to negate completely the results of World War II. In reality, the leader who proposed this idea at the CPSU Central Committee meeting at that time risked losing his position as general secretary.

    Second, drastically reduce Soviet food imports by $20 billion, the amount the Soviet Union lost when oil prices collapsed. But in practical terms, this option meant the introduction of food rationing at rates similar to those used during World War II. The Soviet leadership understood the consequences: the Soviet system would not survive for even one month. This idea was never seriously discussed.

    Third, implement radical cuts in the military-industrial complex. With this option, however, the Soviet leadership risked serious conflict with regional and industrial elites, since a large number of Soviet cities depended solely on the military-industrial complex. This choice was also never seriously considered.

    Unable to realize any of the above solutions, the Soviet leadership decided to adopt a policy of effectively disregarding the problem in hopes that it would somehow wither away. Instead of implementing actual reforms, the Soviet Union started to borrow money from abroad while its international credit rating was still strong. It borrowed heavily from 1985 to 1988, but in 1989 the Soviet economy stalled completely...

    The money was suddenly gone. The Soviet Union tried to create a consortium of 300 banks to provide a large loan for the Soviet Union in 1989, but was informed that only five of them would participate and, as a result, the loan would be twenty times smaller than needed. The Soviet Union then received a final warning from the Deutsche Bank and from its international partners that the funds would never come from commercial sources. Instead, if the Soviet Union urgently needed the money, it would have to start negotiations directly with Western governments about so-called politically motivated credits.

    In 1985 the idea that the Soviet Union would begin bargaining for money in exchange for political concessions would have sounded absolutely preposterous to the Soviet leadership. In 1989 it became a reality, and Gorbachev understood the need for at least $100 billion from the West to prop up the oil-dependent Soviet economy.



    Guess we can finally put that meme to bed.

    Labels: ,

    Another Chink in the Armor, pt. 2

    More rulings against Bush's detainee policy:

    A divided panel from a conservative federal appeals court delivered a harsh rebuke to the Bush administration's anti-terrorism strategy Monday, ruling that U.S. residents cannot be locked up indefinitely as "enemy combatants" without being charged.

    The three-judge panel of the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the government should charge Ali al-Marri, a legal U.S. resident and the only suspected enemy combatant on American soil, or release him from military custody.

    The federal Military Commissions Act doesn't strip al-Marri of his constitutional right to challenge his accusers in court, the judges found in Monday's 2-1 decision.

    "Put simply, the Constitution does not allow the President to order the military to seize civilians residing within the United States and then detain them indefinitely without criminal process, and this is so even if he calls them 'enemy combatants,'" the court said.

    Labels:

    Saturday, June 9, 2007

    More on Torture

    Thankfully, Andrew Sullivan just won't let up:

    The report by the the lead investigator for the Council of Europe, Dick Marty, into the secret interrogation and torture sites operated by the CIA these past few years makes for extremely grim reading. For decades, the KGB deployed the classic Gestapo techniques on prisoners; now, under the Bush administration, it is the United States that has adopted the same methods:

    Ventilation holes in the cells released bursts of hot or freezing air, with temperature used as a form of extreme pressure to wear down prisoners, the investigators found. Prisoners were also subjected to water-boarding, a form of simulated drowning, and relentless blasts of music and sound, from rap to cackling laughter and screams, the report says.

    The report, which runs more than 100 pages, says the prisons were operated exclusively by Americans in Poland and Romania from 2003 to 2006. It relies heavily on testimony from C.I.A. agents...

    According to the report, suspects were often held for months with no contact except with masked, silent guards who would push meals of cheese, potatoes and bread through hatches.

    The defense of the Verschaerfte Vernehmung (which are all war crimes under international law and were subject to the death penalty fifty years ago) is the Giuliani defense:

    "Here's my question. Was the guy a terrorist? 'Cause if he's a terrorist, then I figure he got what was coming to him."

    Of course, there is no due process to determine who is or who is not a terrorist, and thereby subject to torture. Many detainees aren't even captured by U.S. soldiers or agents. Only 19 percent of the captives in Gitmo, for example, were actually captured by U.S. forces. Americans' system of justice has been outsourced to Pakistani bounty-hunters. And then the Gestapo-process takes over. But, hey, if they're terrorists, they get what's coming to them, no? That's exactly the system of justice and warfare the Founders had in mind, isn't it?

    This alone disqualifies Giuliani from being president. And it is instructive that only 19% of all Gitmo detainees were actually captured by the U.S. Do we really trust Pakistanis, Afghans, and Iraqis to get the story straight about who is a terrorist and who is just a political/tribal/sectarian enemy? The ticking-time-bomb scenario has (literally) never occurred at any point in human history, and it never will occur. Even if it did, using it as justification for widespread and systematic torture is disgustingly misleading. Life isn't 24, after all.

    President Bush's detainee policy is a national disgrace, and history won't forgive us. It cannot be allowed to continue under the new administration.

    Labels:

    The Trouble with Patents

    Matthew Yglesias channels Tim Lee. Both of them are dead-on, and this isn't a small problem:

    My friend Tim Lee makes the case against software patents in The New York Times. An old Bill Gates memo makes for a good framing device:

    Microsoft sang a very different tune in 1991. In a memo to his senior executives, Bill Gates wrote, “If people had understood how patents would be granted when most of today’s ideas were invented, and had taken out patents, the industry would be at a complete standstill today.” Mr. Gates worried that “some large company will patent some obvious thing” and use the patent to “take as much of our profits as they want.”

    Mr. Gates wrote his 1991 memo shortly after the courts began allowing patents on software in the 1980s. At the time Microsoft was a growing company challenging entrenched incumbents like I.B.M. and Novell. It had only eight patents to its name. Recognizing the threat to his company, Mr. Gates initiated an aggressive patenting program. Today Microsoft holds more than 6,000 patents.

    It’s not surprising that Microsoft — now an entrenched incumbent — has had a change of heart. But Mr. Gates was right in 1991: patents are bad for the software industry. Nothing illustrates that better than the conflict between Verizon and Vonage.

    Read the whole thing. I guess I'm not thrilled with the word choice around "bad for the software industry." Patents are bad for the development of new software. If you define "software industry" as "incumbent for profit software firms" it may be good for the "industry." The thing to keep in mind with any sort of IP protection is that strong IP creates, on the one hand, an incentive for innovation but at the same time it also creates a barrier to innovation. In the case of software patents, the balance tips overwhelmingly in the direction of creating barriers — indeed, the main incentive it creates is merely for the innovative production of patents rather than of actual products.

    The problem is fairly severe, especially since the U.S. demands very strong IP protections from every trade agreement it enters. In this case, innovation and incentive do seem to be trade-offs: more of one will reduce the other (although the proliferation of open-source technology might be an argument against the idea). Perhaps there's a Laffer curve of the appropriate level of patent protection which will maximize innovation. But, as always, figuring out exactly where we are on that curve is impossible.

    Also keep in mind that almost all of the arguments for or against patent protection for software applies to the prescription drug industry. The big difference is that the software industry has MUCH lower fixed costs than the drug trade.

    Labels: ,

    How Much Is the Internet Worth?

    Tyler Cowen comments on several empirical studies. First:

    Our analysis indicates that the increased product variety of online bookstores enhanced consumer welfare by $731 million to $1.03 billion in the year 2000, which is between seven to ten times as large as the consumer welfare gain from increased competition and lower prices in this market. There may also be large welfare gains in other SKU-intensive consumer goods such as music, movies, consumer electronics, and computer software and hardware.

    Here is the paper, the pointer is indirect through Tim Harford. Do read my previous post -- relevant for the wage stagnation debate -- on how much the Internet is worth.

    $1 billion in enhanced consumer welfare, merely from book sales. Imagine how much greater it is for online music sales, or clothing sales. The previous post:

    For some goods, the main cost of buying the product is not the price but rather the time it takes to use them. Only about 0.2% of consumer spending in the U.S., for example, went for Internet access in 2004 yet time use data indicates that people spend around 10% of their entire leisure time going online....we calculate that consumer surplus from the Internet may be around 2% of full-income, or several thousand dollars per user. This is an order of magnitude larger than what one obtains from a back-of-the-envelope calculation using data from expenditures.

    Here is the paper. I call it a good start, but let us not forget the Internet also brings price closer to marginal cost in many markets. Your on-line searching has external benefits for others. Or how about another paper: "What is the iPod worth?" TiVo? The more we are changing the use of our time, the less we can trust real income statistics.


    Those external effects cannot be ignored, but they are difficult to quantify, as are the benefits from moving markets closer to perfect competition. Still, this sort of empirical work is a necessary counterpoint to those who wish to tax the internet, a movement which appears to be picking up steam. When it happens -- I'm just assuming it eventually will -- it will take consumer benefit from individuals to fund programs which likely won't provide nearly as much consumer benefit, so society will incur deadweight loss. Not only that, but it could be regressive, since poorer people often use the internet to buy discounted goods, for cheap/free entertainment, or for purposes of education. Richer people can afford to use non-internet means for all of those, and are often willing to pay a price premium in exchange for quicker delivery (i.e. shopping in a retail store rather than waiting for internet delivery). It seems likely that, no matter the scheme, method of collection, or programs financed with the revenue, internet taxes will be highly inefficient.

    Labels: ,

    Cuban Health Care

    Michael Moore's latest travesty of truth -- Sicko -- premiered at Cannes and will receive a full release soon. After watching it, many people will be convinced that the Cuban health care system is better than America's. The NY Times says that it ain't so, especially if you are a commoner:

    “Actually there are three systems,” Dr. Cordova said, because Cuba has two: one is for party officials and foreigners like those Mr. Moore brought to Havana. “It is as good as this one here, with all the resources, the best doctors, the best medicines, and nobody pays a cent,” he said.

    But for the 11 million ordinary Cubans, hospitals are often ill equipped and patients “have to bring their own food, soap, sheets — they have to bring everything.” And up to 20,000 Cuban doctors may be working in Venezuela, creating a shortage in Cuba.

    Elsewhere, British magazine The Prospect has an eyewitness account:

    Healthcare and education are supposed to be the redeeming graces of the regime, but this is questionable. There are a large number of doctors, but, according to most Cubans I know, many have left the country and the health system is in a ragged state—apart from those hospitals reserved for foreigners—and people often have to pay a bribe to get treated. Michael Moore, the American film director, who has recently been praising the system should take note of the real life stories beneath the statistics. I went into a couple of hospitals for locals on my latest visit. In the first, my friend told me not to say a word in case my accent was noticed, as foreigners are not allowed in these places. I was appalled by the hygiene and amazed at the antiquity of the building and some of the equipment. I was told that the vast majority of Cuban hospitals, apart from two in Havana, were built before the revolution. Which revolution, I wondered; this one seemed to date from the 1900s.
    And Jane Galt disputes the notion that Cuban infant mortality rates are lower than those in the U.S. as well, and reminds us that there are three kinds of lies: lies, damn lies, and statistics.

    Very interesting article on Cuban v. American infant mortality shows one of the trickiest aspects of using statistics: making sure you're not comparing apples to oranges.

    The reason this is so difficult is that often statistics which sound like they're the same thing actually aren't. For example, comparing rape statistics. Most of us think of rape as being forcible intercourse with an unwilling victim. However, there are studies that have included such things as statutory rape (which may be appalling, but isn't what we're trying to get at, which is the rate at which people are sexually assaulted), "rapes" in which the victim never struggled or said no, but merely reported later that she was uncomfortable, or other definitional expansions that make it hard to establish valid comparisons with other studies that focused on forcible intercourse.

    In this case, the article points out that while Cuba seems to have a lower infant mortality rate than America, this appears to be because extremely low-weight births for which American doctors perform heroic intervention (and thus get recorded as a live birth in America, followed by a death a few hours later), get reported as stillbirths in Cuba. So it's very important, when you see a statistic, to ask yourself if the two numbers are really comparing the same thing.

    Labels: , ,

    Thursday, June 7, 2007

    Is Tony Snow an Idiot or a Liar?

    It's a serious question:

    Tony Snow: "there is a carbon cap system in place in Europe; we are doing a better job of reducing emissions here."

    First of all, neither the U.S. nor Europe are reducing their carbon emissions. In fact, none of the countries which signed the Kyoto Treaty have done so. But Europe is trying to reduce the rate of growth of emissions, with some (very modest) success, while the U.S. is literally doing nothing at all.

    Think what you will about the science of climate change and the politics which surrounds it, but this statement by Snow is patently false, and he has to know it. He should not be speaking for the leader of the government of the United States.

    Labels:

    Wednesday, June 6, 2007

    Restoring Habeas Corpus

    I can't believe this is even necessary in the United States, but it deserves all of our support:

    Senators Leahy and Specter have introduced the Habeas Corpus Restoration Act (S. 185). The legislation restores habeas rights to foreign nationals who are detained as enemy combatants or who are awaiting determination of their combatant status. It's a critical piece of legislation to undo the most egregious wrong of the Military Commissions Act. The bill is going to be marked up in the Judiciary Committee tomorrow.

    Senator Leahy is asking for our help in garnering support for the legislation:

    Many of you may recall the hasty passage of the Military Commissions Act in the weeks leading up to last year's election, a bill that set new rules for trying detainees, in particular those currently being held at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba.

    The passage of this bill was a profound mistake, and its elimination of habeas corpus review was its worst error. Righting this wrong is one of my top priorities, and on the first day of this Congress I joined with Senator Arlen Specter to introduce the Habeas Corpus Restoration Act (S. 185). This bipartisan bill already has 17 cosponsors, but it faces a crucial vote in the Judiciary Committee this Thursday so we need your help.

    Please e-mail your home-state Senators today and urge them to protect our fundamental liberties by supporting the Habeas Corpus Restoration Act!



    This has become necessary.

    UPDATE: Andrew Sullivan reminds us that Edmund Burke is on our side:

    My opposition to suspending habeas corpus, to the military commissions farce, and to torture has had many label me a liberal. Well, if Burke was a liberal, then count me in:

    The Letter to the Sheriffs of Bristol is a simple document – the transmission to two law-enforcement officers of his constituency of an act that the government of Lord North Burke has put to Parliament. The act suspended the great writ of habeas corpus - not for the good burghers of Bristol, of course, but only for a group of murderous insurrectionists who then stood in open and bloody revolt against their lawful sovereign. And the act went further, namely, it provided that these miserable wretches, whose insolence and defiance now extended to the seas, could be labeled enemy combatants pirates at the King’s discretion, and thus robbed of the right to be tried in courts. They would be dealt with in a summary fashion by the King’s military. And the act also provided that these miscreants could be transported across the ocean to England and held there to await their summary disposition – a step which justified the suspension of habeas corpus, since otherwise an English court might demand an accounting for their brutal treatment and incarceration. And there was no doubt as to the brutality of that treatment – these wicked enemies were left rotting in ship hulks and were succumbing to pestilence and malnutrition by the hundreds already.

    Burke was not a man to be taken in by such demonization, least of all by the likes of Lord North, and he registered his sharpest opposition to what was being done.

    Labels: ,

    Matthew Yglesias Wants to Boycott

    Why? Because of this:

    Megan Stack's recounting of her life in Saudi Arabia is a reminder that for all the ink that's been wasted on bringing liberalism to the Muslim world by bombing Muslim country or yelling really loudly at Iran, there are much more obvious things that could be done:

    The rules are different here. The same U.S. government that heightened public outrage against the Taliban by decrying the mistreatment of Afghan women prizes the oil-slicked Saudi friendship and even offers wan praise for Saudi elections in which women are banned from voting. All U.S. fast-food franchises operating here, not just Starbucks, make women stand in separate lines. U.S.-owned hotels don't let women check in without a letter from a company vouching for her ability to pay; women checking into hotels alone have long been regarded as prostitutes.

    People could organize a boycott in the US and Europe against Western fast food franchises that enforce this kind of gender apartheid abroad. The Saudi market's not that big, in the scheme of things, it would be relatively easy to put companies in a position where it's not financially worth it for them to keep operating Saudi franchises under those conditions. Maybe the Saudi regime would let them operate differently. Maybe they'd agree to pay the price of isolation and activists would need to move on to the next economic sector. It does, however, seem to me that the Saudi elite prizes maintaining some degree of integration with the cultural and commercial mainstream and wouldn't want to see Western brands all withdraw from their country.


    Obviously, this is silly and impractical for all sorts of reasons. Firstly, most Americans couldn't care less that Saudi Arabian women have to stand in a different line at a McDonalds, so it will be difficult to organize any sort of meaningful boycott protest. So the potential domestic economic damage for American fast food companies would be slight, if not negligible, so the incentive to give up foreign economic gain would also be slight.

    Secondly, this social problem in Saudi Arabia isn't a product of McDonalds' segregated wait lines. That is a symptom of a much, much bigger disease, and forcing American corporations out won't fix anything. But it could increase further animosity between the United States and the Muslim world, who are just a bit sensitive to American intervention into their social structures. That we don't need.

    Thomas Friedman has a lot of faults, but recognizing that each country will assimilate the Lexus/Olive tree dichotomy in their own way isn't one of them. Forcing every country to accept some sort of American construct as a prerequisite for us doing business with them is not only impossible, it's counter-productive. That's not to say that we shouldn't encourage greater rights for women in the Mid-East. Of course we should. But the way to do that isn't to force McDonalds to leave the region.

    Labels:

    How China Benefits the U.S.

    That topic is the cover story in this month's issue of The Atlantic (subscribers, go here; i haven't found a non-gated copy yet, but there is an accompanying web-only slide show, with sound, here). James Fallows, who has been embedded in China for a good few months now, does us the honor. I haven't read it yet, but Fallows is a savvy observer of globalization, international markets, and interconnectedness. He discusses the article a bit on his blog. I'm looking forward to getting around to the article itself. I'll probably discuss it more later. Almost everything Fallows writes is dead-on; I expect that this will be a great piece.

    Elsewhere, Tyler Cowen points us to the Washington Post, which disputes the notion that China's rising production is to blame for our increased oil prices. Well, not exactly, but kinda:

    China's oil imports have increased dramatically during the past five years; the country now imports 3.5 million barrels a day, compared with U.S. daily imports of 12.2 million barrels. But it's far less obvious that Americans are really paying a price for this.

    If you've been to the mall lately, you've probably noticed that China is making scads of plastic. As the world's second-largest plastic producer, it is furiously turning oil and petrochemicals into everything from lobster souvenirs to sneaker soles. By embedding oil in products, China is, in effect, importing oil on behalf of U.S. consumers -- as much as 1 million barrels per day.

    While China's demand for energy is driving up oil prices worldwide, its cheap goods are having the opposite effect on the cost of living in the United States. A recent analysis by the U.N. World Economic and Social Survey suggests that Chinese pressure on oil imports may have raised U.S. inflation by 0.23 percent from 2001 to 2005, but cheap imports of Chinese goods decreased U.S. inflation over that same period by 0.28 percent. For the moment, the net winners are U.S. consumers.

    The importance of China -- as an ally, not an enemy -- is a common theme among geopolitical strategists like Thomas Barnett. The emergence from the Gap to the Core of China (and India) is going to be the story of the 21st century, and that is a good thing.

    Labels: ,

    Income Inequality

    Robert Samuelson has a pretty sane column on income inequality. Which is no mean feat, considering all the hysteria being propagated by both the right and left wings of American politics. the truth is, measured income inequality has increased fairly dramatically when you are looking at income tax returns. It has increased less when looking at consumption measures, estate tax returns, and other measures. But it's nearly impossible to argue that income inequality hasn't increased at all in recent decades (although Alan Reynolds makes the case, and many of his arguments have not yet been done away with).

    But the relevant question for policymakers is "why has income inequality increased?" And there is no clear answer to that question. Most likely, it's a combination of factors: the rise in globalization and economic restructuring which comes with it, a higher college wage premium (and even greater increase for post-grad degrees), superstar economics, booming stock markets, dramatic restructuring of the tax code since the early 1980s, demographic/composition changes (such an increase in immigration of poor, unskilled laborers), and other factors.

    Politicians will take the populist line during campaigns, and will cite inequality statistics to try to garner support for universal health care, increased minimum wages, and all manner of other policies which are completely unrelated to the topic. But it's important to remember that the truth is much more nuanced than they will ever say. There is fierce debate amongst economists as to the extent and causes of economic inequality, and even more on how to mitigate it (or if we even should). When the views of the experts are spread so far apart, don't expect politicians to be passing along anything close to the real Truth.

    Labels: ,

    Trouble in Kurdistan

    Some troubling news from the northern edge of Iraq. Apparently, Turkey has sent troops into into Iraqi Kurdistan. Supposedly, this is in retaliation for Kurdish guerrillas who have been active in Turkey for some time. The U.S. has encouraged Turkey to back down, but it doesn't appear that Turkey is listening.

    Of course, the devil is in the details. Turkey's hatred of the Kurds has only been eclipsed by Saddam's genocidal loathing.

    To some extent, the U.S. is caught in the middle. Turkey is a NATO member, and the U.S. views their cooperation on the war on terror as essential. At the same time, the U.S. has long given verbal support to the Kurds in Iraq. The stability of Iraqi Kurdistan is absolutely essential for any positive outcome in Iraq, and most scenarios of American troop withdrawal includes a deposit of a relatively large force in Iraqi Kurdistan to ensure that stability. Iraqi Kurdistan has been one of the few bright spots in Iraq over the past few years. It will interesting to see how this situation develops.

    I'm sure Christopher Hitchens will have something to say about this.

    Labels:

    Tuesday, June 5, 2007

    Bernanke Expects Growth to Rebound

    Hard to argue with the logic. Unemployment is still very low, inflation isn't a huge concern, the financial markets are doing great (too good?), and growth is still positive, if a bit under trend levels. First quarter GDP growth was ~0.6%, which is a bit below the 3.0-3.5% trend rate, but not a whole lot. And some of that drop was because of companies selling off inventories rather than producing new goods. As companies look to re-stock, production should increase again.

    Bernanke also made it sound like the FED won't lower the funds rate from 5.25%, which sent the financial markets down today. It was easy to see coming... inflation still hasn't been whittled down to the levels that the FED is comfortable with, possibly because of rising trade deficits. But, overall, the economy looks pretty sound, if just a touch sluggish.

    Labels:

    Monday, June 4, 2007

    Deep Thoughts

    A collection of memorable quotes from V. Putin.

    Labels:

    Another Chink in the Armor

    Bush's detainee policy takes another hit:

    In back-to-back arraignments for Salim Ahmed Hamdan of Yemen and Canadian Omar Khadr the U.S. military's cases against the alleged al-Qaida figures dissolved because, the two judges said, the government had failed to establish jurisdiction.

    The Gitmo detainee policy has been a black eye for this country for far too long. It's time to shut it down.

    Labels:

    JFK Terror Plot

    Apparently, not such a big deal after all. Which comes as no surprise.

    U.S. Troops Only Control 1/3 of Baghdad

    So says the military.

    The New York Times reported earlier on Monday that, according to an internal military assessment and local commanders, U.S. and Iraqi troops controlled 146 of Baghdad's 457 neighborhoods.

    The New York Times said that, according to the one-page military assessment of the crackdown, troops had either not begun operations or still faced resistance in the capital's remaining 311 neighborhoods.

    Frankly, I'm not entirely sure what to make of this. Some of the 311 neighborhoods which aren't "controlled" by the U.S. or Iraqi militaries haven't even had any operations yet. How many? The article doesn't say, even tho that seems like a pretty important piece of information. If the military hasn't begun operations in, say, 300 of the 311 neighborhoods, then this seems kind of like good news, since the rate of success among the neighborhoods which have been subject to military operations would be pretty high. But if operations are forth-coming in only 30 of the neighborhoods, and all the rest of those neighborhoods have rebuffed operations, then it's exceedingly bad news.

    Not only that, but I don't know exactly what "control" means. How many of New York City's neighborhoods are "under control" in this way? I suspect the answer is "zero". Of these 311 remaining neighborhoods, how many are actively violent? All of them? Half of them? These are all important pieces of information, necessary for properly appreciating the situation in Baghdad. Unfortunately, the article gives us none of this context, so we're left only with the "1/3" number but not capacity for appreciating it.

    Labels:

    Friday, June 1, 2007

    Bush Planned and Approved Torture

    The Bush admin. can no longer plead ignorance, or claim that torture cases were isolated incidents done by renegade soldiers. They planned it, they approved it, and they stole their methods from the USSR. Despicable.

    Many of the controversial interrogation tactics used against terror suspects in Iraq, Afghanistan and Guantanamo were modeled on techniques the U.S. feared that the Communists themselves might use against captured American troops during the Cold War, according to a little-noticed, highly classified Pentagon report released several days ago. Originally developed as training for elite special forces at Fort Bragg under the "Survival, Evasion, Resistance and Escape" program, otherwise known as SERE, tactics such as sleep deprivation, isolation, sexual humiliation, nudity, exposure to extremes of cold and stress positions were part of a carefully monitored survival training program for personnel at risk of capture by Soviet or Chinese forces, all carried out under the supervision of military psychologists.

    The report, completed last August but only declassified and made public on May 18, suggests that the abusive techniques stemmed from a much more formal process than the Defense Department has previously acknowledged. By 2002 the Pentagon was looking for an interrogation paradigm to use on what it had designated as "unlawful combatants" captured in the "war on terror." These individuals, many taken prisoner in Afghanistan, were initially brought to the U.S. detention facility at Guantanamo, although others were subsequently hidden away in CIA secret prisons or turned over to U.S.-allied governments known to practice torture. That same year, the commander of the detention facility at Guantanamo began using the abusive "counter resistance" techniques adopted from SERE on prisoners at the base, and according to the Pentagon report SERE military psychologists were on hand to help.

    In response to fallout over the well-documented cases of prisoner abuse — which included prolonged isolation, sensory deprivation (visual and auditory), forced removal of clothing, exploiting prisoners phobias (notably fear of dogs), and threats against family members — the Pentagon began scaling back the use of SERE tactics in 2002 and eventually banned them altogether. The Army Field Manual, which serves as a primary guide for U.S. military interrogation, now specifically rules out the use of a variety of SERE-founded techniques including water-boarding, a form of simulated drowning, as well as the use of dogs.

    Labels: