Thursday, November 29, 2007

Now Wait a Second...

Much has recently been made over James Watson's comments regarding racial disparities in I.Q. testing. William Saletan, at Slate.com, has borne the brunt of this criticism, and continues to even after issuing an apology for not doing journalistic due diligence. Brad DeLong tells us to read Robert Farley:

Robert Farley of Lawyers, Guns, and Money on William Saletan, who may at last have come to a dim form of self-knowledge:

Lawyers, Guns and Money: Apology Not Accepted, Bill: Saletan:

I missed something I could have picked up from a simple glance at Wikipedia.

For the past five years, J. Philippe Rushton has been president of the Pioneer Fund, an organization dedicated to "the scientific study of heredity and human differences." During this time, the fund has awarded at least $70,000 to the New Century Foundation. To get a flavor of what New Century stands for, check out its publications on crime ("Everyone knows that blacks are dangerous") and heresy ("Unless whites shake off the teachings of racial orthodoxy they will cease to be a distinct people"). New Century publishes a magazine called American Renaissance, which preaches segregation. Rushton routinely speaks at its conferences.

I was negligent in failing to research and report this. I'm sorry. I owe you better than that.

"Hack" doesn't really begin to cover it. Saletan sallied forth with the argument that the evidence for inherent intellectual inequality between races was so compelling that liberals who questioned the science were equivalent to creationists. Now we find that, in addition to not understanding most of the science he was trying to talk about, he didn't even bother to do basic research into the compelling work he was citing.

More Bill:

I wanted to discuss whether egalitarianism could survive if this scenario, raised last month by James Watson, turned out to be true. I thought it was important to lay out the scenario's plausibility. In doing so, I short-circuited the conversation. Most of the reaction to what I wrote has been over whether the genetic hypothesis is true, with me as an expert witness.

I don't want this role. I'm not an expert.

Huh. So I guess that's why Bill devoted two columns to stressing how strong the science was and how reluctant to accept the truth liberals were, and one column to a few half-assed ruminations about the political implications. And I guess that's why he felt the need to write this missive to the liberal masses:

Evolution forced Christians to bend or break. They could insist on the Bible's literal truth and deny the facts, as Bryan did. Or they could seek a subtler account of creation and human dignity. Today, the dilemma is yours. You can try to reconcile evidence of racial differences with a more sophisticated understanding of equality and opportunity. Or you can fight the evidence and hope it doesn't break your faith.

I'm for reconciliation.

Yeah; I'm pretty strongly against reconciliation with someone who thought taunting liberals for not believing shoddy racist science was more important than doing basic journalistic research.

Seriously, what does somebody have to do to get fired from Slate?



But there is another possibility, and that possibility should be obvious. Rushton might be a vicious and horrible racist... and also correct about I.Q. I'm not a geneticist, cognitive scientist, sociologist, or in any other way qualified to comment on the truthfulness of Rushton's claims regarding the science. But he could be right. Just as many Christians accuse evolutionists of being virulently anti-God or anti-religion who were using evolutionary theory to further a more broadly general atheist agenda. And you know what? In some ways they are right. Many atheists do use evolution to further their own agendas, esp. among the current crop of atheists (e.g. Dennett, Hitchens, Dawkins), but that fact alone doesn't make their claims regarding the validity of evolutionary theory wrong.

I've read just enough on the subject to know that there is serious debate on the topic, mostly focusing on whether or not I.Q. testing is an appropriate measure for intellectual ability. But it wouldn't surprise me to learn that certain groups of people are genetically more predisposed to certain types of intellectual ability than others as a group, just as certain groups of people are genetically predisposed to certain types of physical or athletic ability than others as a group. This mustn't be a statement of value (and I don't intend it as such) since different genetic intellectual abilities may serve different purposes just as different genetic physical characteristics serve different purposes. Indeed, this is consistent with evolutionary theory.

But it isn't necessarily determinism -- Chinese people are, on average, shorter than Europeans, but that doesn't stop Yao Ming from being a great basketball player -- but if we can identify these differences it can help us understand how to generate an appropriate social policy which does the best service to the most number of people, while maintaining equal opportunities for all. If we ignore this evidence, then social equality will suffer since we may be trying to force people to adapt to roles for which they are not genetically built. It could be like trying to force square pegs into round holes, and that helps no one.

There is an awful lot of uncertainty surrounding the specifics of evolution, and even its underlying assumptions. The same is certainly true of group-based models of genetic cognitive ability. The truth is, we are merely starting to understand how the brain works, and what factors control what stages of development. But the discussion of the topic should be had on the merits, not through singling out individuals' despicable views for criticism without addressing the substance. Straw-man politics and ad hominems will get us nowhere.

Labels:

China Yields

From the WSJ:

WASHINGTON -- China moved to address a flash point in economic relations with the U.S., agreeing to end trade-distorting subsidies to Chinese manufacturers, a senior Bush administration official said.

"This outcome represents a victory for U.S. manufacturers and their workers," U.S. Trade Representative Susan Schwab said in a statement Thursday. She added that the settlement "also demonstrates that two great trading nations can work together to settle disputes to their mutual benefit."

Quite right. But there has got to be some sort of quid pro quo for this. Perhaps, in exchange, the U.S. will lessen pressure on China to let the RMB appreciate. Or, perhaps the U.S. has agreed to lower agriculture subsidies (I doubt it). Perhaps China is just looking for some positive P.R., but I kind of doubt they'll get it. Perhaps China is looking for some leverage in future negotiations. I'm not sure, but something is coming out of it.

But no matter what it is, it's a good thing. China's manufacturing industry is pretty well established at this point. Continuing to distort the markets through subsidies doesn't make long-term political sense, nor does it make economic sense.

Labels: ,

Mixed Economic News

The U.S. economy is really... weird right now. The underlying economic news is pretty great: the economy expanded 4.9% in the last quarter, which is the highest rate in four years. This 4.9% growth rate isn't sustainable -- indeed, it is nearly twice the maximum level of sustained growth as estimated by the Fed -- but it is still encouraging.

And yet. The housing "crisis" is worsening, and will continue to worsen, probably through 2008. Credit markets are still very tight, so the Fed will still feel pressure to loosen monetary policy. But there are still some inflationary concerns in the real economy despite deflationary concerns in the financial markets. It's possible, if unlikely, that we could hit stagflation.

So, things are weird. Unfortunately for the rest of the world, these concerns aren't limited to the U.S. It had been thought that, since growth rates have improved in parts of W. Europe (e.g. Germany), and since Japan is finally showing some signs of life, the rest of the world had decoupled from U.S. But that might not be the case. Megan McArdle sums up thusly:

Germany and Japan may be growing, but they're extremely dependent on exports, which means they won't serve as the markets that fuel growth in the rest of the world. That, for too long, has been America's job. Now that we're ready for retirement, it seems we forgot to train our replacement.

Labels: , , , ,

Saturday, November 17, 2007

Rap, explained in charts and graphs


Much more here.

Labels:

Friday, November 16, 2007

A Minor Mistake

China's economic rise has surely been impressive. The stats have shown remarkable growth over the past few decades. This growth was considered to be so exceptional as to be unsustainable. Now, it turns out, it might not have been true:

I recently doubted that the Chinese economy lives up to its reputation. Now the Financial Times says that the Asian Development Bank is backing me up:
In a little-noticed mid-summer announcement, the Asian Development Bank presented official survey results indicating China’s economy is smaller and poorer than established estimates say. The announcement cited the first authoritative measure of China’s size using purchasing power parity methods. The results tell us that when the World Bank announces its expected PPP data revisions later this year, China’s economy will turn out to be 40 per cent smaller than previously stated.

This more accurate picture of China clarifies why Beijing concentrates so heavily on domestic priorities such as growth, public investment, pollution control and poverty reduction. The number of people in China living below the World Bank’s dollar-a-day poverty line is 300m – three times larger than currently estimated.

How could an error of this magnitude happen?
Until recently, China had never participated in the careful price surveys needed to convert accurately its gross domestic product into PPP dollars.

The World Bank’s estimates based on summary data from the late 1980s probably overstated China’s PPP gross domestic product even then. Up to now, the bank has revised its estimate very little. In the meantime, China has repeatedly raised the prices of food, housing, healthcare and a range of other non-traded goods and services. These reforms should have lowered the PPP adjustment, but the bank left it basically unchanged.

The lesson: Steve Levitt's quip that "People lie, numbers don't" is once again way off - because all numbers are made by people.

Labels: , ,

U.S. Mobility

Many economists maintain that levels of income inequality aren't of great concern so long as there is a substantial amount of income mobility. In other words, so long as the all the gains from a growing economy are not going to only a few people, all the time, then the social economic situation isn't unjust. Arnold Kling rounds up several studies which have recently come out, examining the state of American income mobility, and the results are very positive:

A Wall Street Journal editorial reports,

The Treasury study examined a huge sample of 96,700 income tax returns from 1996 and 2005 for Americans over the age of 25. The study tracks what happened to these tax filers over this 10-year period. One of the notable, and reassuring, findings is that nearly 58% of filers who were in the poorest income group in 1996 had moved into a higher income category by 2005. Nearly 25% jumped into the middle or upper-middle income groups, and 5.3% made it all the way to the highest quintile.

Of those in the second lowest income quintile, nearly 50% moved into the middle quintile or higher, and only 17% moved down. This is a stunning show of upward mobility, meaning that more than half of all lower-income Americans in 1996 had moved up the income scale in only 10 years.


My metaphor for income distribution is an escalator, with new families and immigrants starting at the bottom and most people moving up. This new study appears to be consistent with the metaphor.

A commenter found the actual study. I did not read it carefully, but I don't see how looking at tax returns can be complete, because some people don't file (of course, many who file pay no taxes, but that is ok as long as their returns are included).

Meanwhile, another study was conducted by Julia Isaacs of the Brookings Institution, using the Panel Study for Income Dynamics, following families from the late 1960's through today.

Isaacs' study is called the Economic Mobility Project. It is covered in The Wall Street Journal. The Executive Summary says,


Median family income for adults who were children in the late 1960s and are now in their 30s or 40s increased 29 percent, from $55,600 for parents to $71,900 for their children, adjusting for inflation. Moreover, family sizes have shrunk over this same period (from 3.1 to 2.3 individuals between 1969 and 1998), so higher incomes are spread over fewer people.

...four out of five children whose parents were in the bottom fifth of the income distribution end up with higher incomes than their parents.

...Forty-two percent of children born to parents in the bottom fifth of the income distribution remain in the bottom, while 39 percent born to parents in the top fifth remain at the top.


An executive summary of Differences by Race says,

Between 1974 and 2004, white and black men in their 30s experienced a decline in income, with the largest decline among black men. However, median family incomes for both racial groups increased, because of large increases in women’s incomes. Income growth was particularly high for white women.

The lack of income growth for black men combined with low marriage rates in the black population has had a negative impact on trends in family income for black families.

...Overall, approximately two out of three blacks (63 percent) exceed their parents’ income after the data are adjusted for inflation, similar to the percentage for whites.

However, a majority of blacks born to middle-income parents grow up to have less income than their parents. Only 31 percent of black children born to parents in the middle of the income distribution have family income greater than their parents, compared to 68 percent of white children from the same income bracket.



The demographic effects are important: middle-class men have lost income as women have increasingly become substitutes for their labor. In other words, the supply curve shifted pretty far right during the latter-half of the 20th century, forcing down wages for some men who faced more wage competition. Overall, however, the trends was largely up, especially for households. It's also important to recognize, as the study does, that household size has decreased while household income has increased. If household size is controlled for, the income gains would be even higher. Similarly, the decreases in the size of black household income is probably largely explained by the decrease in the number of black households rather than institutional discrimination (I'm guessing that increased education premiums and skill-biased technological change have something to do with it also). Overall, the news is pretty remarkably positive.

Now, I might hear you say, the increases in household income have come because women are working, and therefore there are more total household hours engaged in market work. Therefore, the gains are artificial: it isn't that the economy is any better, but that more people are working more hours. But that would be to miss the point. To a large extent, home work and market work are substitutable, especially if part of the earnings from market work go to purchase labor-savings devices (e.g. new technologies which save labor time) and/or substitute laborers from household tasks (e.g. hiring a landscaper or a housecleaner). So, the extra income gains are real, and not artificial.

All in all, these studies could go a long way in rebutting the charge that America is a less egalitarian country than it used to be.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Preach It!

Annie Duke -- professional poker player, Columbia grad, and mother of four -- testified before Congress on the illegitimacy of anti-internet gaming laws in the U.S. She even brought John Locke and John Stuart Mill (and Thomas Jefferson and James Madison) into it! The manner in which the bill outlawing online gaming (it was snuck into a Ports Defense bill) is shady, and the philosophy underpinning prohibition is disingenuous. Somehow, this woman was able to illustrate all these point -- and more! -- in a few minutes before Congress. The video is fuzzy, but the arguments are clear.

The WTO ruled against the U.S. law, saying that it went against the U.S.'s requirements in the WTO charter. The WTO acknowledged the right of the U.S. to opt out of WTO requirements for moral reasons, but ruled that the U.S. was not doing so because it still permitted gambling on horse races and state lotteries to continue online. Hopefully, this matter may be resolved.

This Salon.com article provides further background, and is the source for Duke's video.

Labels: , , ,

Farm-Raised, Wingless Quail-tards

Dana Stevens points to a silver lining for those of us who are primarily affected by the Hollywood writer's strike in that we don't get our shot of Daily Show every day: the archives. The Daily Show is no online, in pretty much its entirety. 13,000 clips, searchable and sorted. There's one brilliant exchange from the day Cheney shot his friend in the face included in Stevens' article. It's a must-view.

Labels:

I am so smart, s m r t, i mean, s m a r t

I'm shocked to discover that I am on the same level as Julian Sanchez.

cash advance

Get a Cash Advance

Labels:

No. Really?

They are doing important and vibrant research at Cornell's hospitality school. They have now scientifically proven... the most obvious thing in the world: hotter waitresses get more tips.

Waitresses completed an on-line survey about their physical characteristics, self-perceived attractiveness and sexiness, and average tips. The waitresses’ self-rated physical attractiveness increased with their breast sizes and decreased with their ages, waist-to-hip ratios, and body sizes. Similar effects were observed on self-rated sexiness, with the exception of age, which varied with self-rated sexiness in a negative, quadratic relationship rather than a linear one. Moreover, the waitresses’ tips varied with age in a negative, quadratic relationship, increased with breast size, increased with having blond hair, and decreased with body size. These findings, which are discussed from an evolutionary perspective, make several contributions to the literature on female physical attractiveness. First, they replicate some previous findings regarding the determinants of female physical attractiveness using a larger, more diverse, and more ecologically valid set of stimuli than has been studied before. Second, they provide needed evidence that some of those determinants of female beauty affect interpersonal behaviors as well as attractiveness ratings. Finally, they indicate that some determinants of female physical attractiveness do not have the same effects on overt interpersonal behavior (such as tipping) that they have on attractiveness ratings. This later contribution highlights the need for more ecologically valid tests of evolutionary theories about the determinants and consequences of female beauty.
In other news, women are apparently discriminated against in coffee shops. How? By having to wait 20 seconds longer for their drinks. I have some questions about the reliability of the methodology, but whatever.

(ht: Marginal Revolution, for the hot waitress bit.)

Labels: ,

IR in Theory and Practice

Daniel Drezner jumps into a debate about the utility of International Relations Theory, particularly as it pertains to students getting policy M.A. degrees:

Patrick Thaddeus Jackson and Rob Farley have fired additional volleys on the utility of an M.A. in international relations.

Except that with this round, the debate is actually about something more fundamental -- the utility of international relations theory to policymaking.

These paragraphs suggest where Jackson is coming from:

[W]here it gets controversial is the relationship between scholarship and object. We have two ideal-typical positions on this: scholarship ought to improve practice, and scholarship can't possibly improve practice, at least not directly. Rob clearly prefers door #1; I prefer door #2. Rob's position is the classic Enlightenment hope for the sciences of society: place practice on a more rational basis, achieve better results, produce a world that looks more like the world we want to live in; I think that's both dangerous and a little naive -- dangerous because it puts a potential transcendental justification for coercion in the hands of would-be reformers (after all, if the experts told us that we can do this, and you disagree, then you're either stupid or obstinate, and in either way you're in the way so forcibly removing you starts to look like a good idea) and naive because it presumes that scholarly knowledge translates more or less simply to the actual world (and once again, if it doesn't, maybe we ought to use force to make the world look more like the model . . .).

I prefer option #2 -- scholarship can't possibly improve practice, at least not directly -- in part because people claiming to have Reason/God/Truth on their sides ("Jesus/Buddha/Muhammad/science likes my policy better!") have been responsible for most of the senseless death in human history, in part because systematic scholarly knowledge is by nature an abstraction (and sometimes a severe abstraction, in which the actual practice of anyone in particular disappears -- the sports analogy here would be to sabremetric analyses of baseball, and we've seen what happens when actual baseball teams try to directly implement strategies that look valid sabremetrically) and therefore not fit for any sort of direct translation into practice, and in part because scholarly knowledge is irreducibly perspectival and thus does not seem to me to be a good solid basis for decision-making (although it can certainly inform decision-making as one element among others).

Farley's response to this is here. My response is below the fold....

From this excerpt, I've concluded that Jackson is likely correct that he should not be teaching anyone in an M.A. program. I am more skeptical that this stricture should be applied to others.

The problem with Jackson's argument is that it sets up a false dichotomy. Neither ideal type holds, and most profs in policy schools are smart enough to know that. International relations theory provides some useful constructs through which one can interpret world politics. Now -- and this is important -- they are far from perfect. Most IR theories -- hell, most social science theories -- do a much better job at after-the-fact explanation than before-the-fact prediction. In teaching them, therefore, one has to be wary of having your students believe that what they are learning is some sort of gospel. [This, by the way, is one reason why an M.A. has value-added -- most M.A. students eventually realize that sometime there is no right answer to a question. B.A. students are more reluctant to believe that the Wizards of IR are not all-powerful.]

Why teach theory at all, then? Two quick answers. First. to paraphrase Churchill, IR theory is a lousy rotten way of understanding the world -- until you consider the alternatives. Policymakers who claim to disdain abstract theories just use implicit ones -- poorly chosen historical analogies, bad metaphors, you name it. Jackson's "intellectually isolationist" approach to teaching policy doesn't make the situation any better -- it just deprives would-be policymakers of a component in their analytical tool kit.

Second, good teachers don't just teach the strengths of a particular theoretical approach -- they also teach the weaknesses and blind spots of each approach. This is the "procedural liberalism" that Michael Berube is so fond of. As Farley puts it:

Why wouldn't it be better if the policymakers in question had some theoretical training, such that they could, on their own, evaluate elements of the claims that the scholars are making? This IS teaching students; it's teaching students to be better, more critical policymakers.
Teaching students theoretical concepts and how to critique them is a two-fer. Hopefully, it provides them with some useful knowledge about how the world works. More importantly, however, it should teach them how to judge for themselves about how the world works. That's the best way to get students to temper the idealism that scares the crap out of Jackson.

Oh, one last point -- Jackson's sabremetric metaphor is crap. The Boston Red Sox have been successful in the past half-decade because of a combination of sabremetric analysis, traditional scouting, and a larger budget to fill out the roster. Sabremetrics was not solely responsible -- but without it, there's no way they win two World Series either.

This is how IR scholarship should be viewed as well -- an insufficient but necessary base of knowledge from which one can craft effective policies.



first of all, the word is "sabermetrics," not "sabremetrics".

secondly, a better example of sabermetric success would surely be the Oakland A's, who are perennial contenders despite having a very small (relative) budget. Billy Beane operates almost purely on sabermetric knowledge.

thirdly, the most telling evidence that sabermetrics is successful is that... every team in baseball now uses these metrics. Some give them more relative weight than others, and some have big enough budgets to make some "mistake signings" and absorb the blow, but all teams use sabermetrics now, especially in drafting. The early adopters have had the most success. Now, the gains are marginal, but the consequences of ignoring sabermetrics would likely be disastrous.

Now, to the topic at hand: clearly Drezner is right. Jackson sets up a straw man within a false dichotomy, and of course has no trouble knocking it down. but IR Theory, like any other theory in any other discipline, has value in setting parameters for understanding actual situations. Some theories demonstrate some predictive power, and those theories are kept and (hopefully) refined. Others don't. And, to quote Keynes, as the facts change, good scholars (or policy-makers) should change their minds. Dogmatic defense of theory in spite of all evidence to the contrary is clearly counter-productive, but so is ignoring the theoretical debate altogether in favor of flying blindly.

It seems clear not that the Bush administration's misadventure in Iraq is not the fault of their application of a theory, but of applying the wrong theory. It was their ignorance of the broad theoretical discussion in favor of dogmatic approval of one theory -- neoconservatism as a model for the Middle East -- that cost them, not their knowledge.

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, November 10, 2007

He's Back!

Well, not really. But this vid of Dave Chapelle shooting the shit improv-style in London is pretty sweet.

Julian Sanchez Compares U.S. Politics to Dystopian Fiction

He does not like what he sees:

I can't be the only one who saw the creepily Mickey Mouse–ish masks worn by riot police in Tblisi and immediately started humming the theme from Brazil. But thinking about one of my favorite movies also brought to mind the following exchange from the film, which now seems disconcertingly familiar:

Jill: Doesn't it bother you the sort of things you do at Information Retrieval?

Sam: I suppose you'd rather have terrorists.


Now, that's some serious reductio creep for you: Our actual, "serious" political debates now resemble punchlines from dystopian satire. Awesome. Wake me when it's 2008.

Friday, November 9, 2007

The End of Fiscal Politics

Much of American politics today is centered on fiscal policy. The right wishes to shrink the size of the government and rebate many taxes. The left wishes to expand the size of the government and pay for it by raising many taxes. But in the near future, neither one may be possible, says Megan McArdle:

The budget problem isn't in 2041; the budget problem is now. Sometime after next year, the Social Security surplus will shrink, starting to put pressure on the budget. Democrats trying to implement spending plans will start to find their tax increases eaten, not by national health care, but by seniors. By 2011, the problem will be large. By 2017, money will be flowing from the general fund to social security. By 2025, the hole will be about as big as it's going to get. Around about 2015, social progressive plans will be DOA. Republican tax schemes will be DOA. The only thing we will talk about for the following 15 years is where to find the money to pay for Social Security and Medicare.

Elsewhere, and not in response, Bryan Caplan says, while discussing health care reform:

What is odd is that the biggest obstacles to redistribution are the Democrats' favorite programs, Medicare and Social Security. Those programs are going to soak up all of the tax increases the Democrats can dream up, and then some. Having spent the last six years denying that there is a problem, they are going to spend Hillary Clinton's first term watching these non-problems drain tens of billions of dollars from the Treasury, leaving them very little room to maneuver on redistributionary spending.


They are both right, but the bigger problem is surely Medicare, and there is no easy answer. Social Security will work itself out in time, as the Boomers die off and/or the economy expands enough to compensate them. At worst, it's a one-generation problem, and not an especially crippling one. If we must, we can simply raise the eligibility age by a couple of years, and the problem disappears.

Medicare/caid, however, is the bastard gift that keeps on giving. If health care costs continue to inflate at something close to current rates, we will be forced to start rationing care along a steeper health-to-income gradient. In other words, the inequality which already exists in access to care between poor and rich will broaden. Those who can pay for care will get it; those who can't, won't. The only other answer is to ration care by government mandate, perhaps coupled with price controls, and nobody wants that.

This problem isn't unique to America. Japan has had a fiscal crunch for some time now, mostly due to the burden that the elderly there are placing on the rest of society. Much of western Europe has some sort of similar problem. Basically, social democracies are largely susceptible to demographic and economic changes. If the demand for social services increases (due to an aging population, say) or price inflation is high, then the system crumbles on top of itself.

Economic realities may reduce political bickering in the next decade, but surely not for positive reasons. The future will be a test for politicians: play the game honestly, and accept the economic hardships and inflexibility which are coming, or try to cheat the system (by inflating the current, for example, or instituting price controls) and suffer extremely dire consequences.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

Fact of the Day

- % of Walmart employees who get health insurance through Walmart: 47.4

- % of Walmart employees who get health insurance from some source: 90*

- % of Starbucks employees who get health insurance through Starbucks: 42

as a side note, Starbucks spends more on employee health insurance than it does on coffee.

* ~ 43% of Walmart employees receive health insurance from their spouse's employer or from the government.

Labels: , , ,

Who Was Milton Friedman?

Back in February, Paul Krugman asked the question. Now, Edward Nelson and Anna Schwartz (one of Friedman's co-authors, and a distinguished scholar in her own right) have answered. Both are worth reading in full, but I think Nelson & Schwartz get the better of it.

Labels:

Another Bush Achievement

Turkey's threatened incursions into Iraqi Kurdistan had me nervous a few weeks ago. Now, Bush has achieved a modest victory on that front, after engaging in some of that good 'ole diplomacy of which he is usually not capable:

Fortunately for both sides, yesterday's White House encounter produced a solution that allowed both sides to step back from the brink. Bush not only declared the Kurdistan Workers' Party (or PKK), "an enemy of Turkey, a free Iraq and the United States," but also committed to providing actionable intelligence to Ankara on the whereabouts of PKK positions. Officially, Bush publicly stuck to the line that Iraq's territory should not be violated. In practice, though, the United States would cooperate "in order to chase down people who murder people," Bush pledged. Essentially, that appears to be a green light for the Turks to carry out limited raids into Iraqi territory with the blessing of the United States. And, crucially, it also allows Erdogan to call off a full-scale land invasion—though he stressed that that option remained on the table if raids proved unsuccessful.

"Finally, we have a plan of action," says one senior Turkish official not authorized to speak on the record. "We are tired of promises with no action."

Getting to this agreement was the result of weeks of intense behind-the-scenes diplomacy by the administration.
(ht: Daniel Drezner)

Labels: , , ,

Remember, Remember

Alright, so I'm not a Ron Paul supporter (although, if Giuliani gets the GOP nomination, I really hope he runs as an independent), but this is pretty cool:



And it worked: Paul raised $4.3mn bucks yesterday.

Labels: , ,

Sunday, November 4, 2007

The Return of Price Controls

Daniel Gross notices that price controls have gotten more popular recently, even in non "anti-market" states like Russia, China, and Argentina. Gross' conclusion:

Price controls, food subsidies, greater state control of the economy, a governor named Romney running for president. It seems like 1967, not 2007. And of course, price controls create powerful disincentives for people and companies to invest in the sort of production capacity that could, in time, create the sort of competition that would help bring prices under control. This isn't a good time to invest in a cattle farm in Argentina, a cheese plant in Russia, or a gasoline refinery in China. If the price controls continue much longer, these economies could see the revival of another distressing factor that defined socialist economies in the 20th century: rationing.
Price controls are always enacted by desperate politicians trying to save their own skin. They are never enacted for economic reasons. For very short periods of time, they can (sort of) work, but this success is always very short-lived. Politicians don't care, because they are usually out of office by the time things get really screwed up. But citizens should care very much, because they always have to live with the aftermath.

It's a shame that these lessons will have to be re-learned. But it appears that that's what's going to happen.

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, November 3, 2007

One Positive Achievement by Bush

Bush's blunderings are always noted, but he has does a few things right, especially in the area of non-proliferation. During Bush's tenure, and because of his actions, Libya has abandoned its nuke program, Pakistan has deposed A.Q. Khan and closed off his weapons running operations, and N. Korea is disabling its program beginning tomorrow. These are real accomplishments, and not to be forgotten.

Labels: ,

Uh Oh

I was really hoping this wouldn't happen:

Gen. Pervez Musharraf suspended Pakistan's constitution and deployed troops in the capital Saturday, declaring that rising Islamic extremism had forced him to take emergency measures that included replacing the nation's chief justice and blacking out the independent media that refused to support him.

Authorities began rounding up opposition politicians despite calls from Washington and other Western allies not to take authoritarian measures.

The U.S. called for Musharraf to restore democracy. However, the Pentagon said the emergency declaration does not affect U.S. military support for Pakistan and its efforts in the war on terrorism. Britain said it was deeply concerned.

Two of our biggest allies in the Middle East -- Turkey and Pakistan -- are becoming less and less reliable.

Labels: