Friday, August 31, 2007

Stop It, Klein


Ezra Klein is not making sense again. He posts this graph, and then says that this is Bush's fault. His commenters are even worse. One of them even says that conservatives would try to defend Bush by blaming these figures on illegal immigration. I responded in the comments:

Well, you could blame it on immigration, but you'd be wrong. It'd be better to say, simply, that there was a recession during those six years, which is why everyone was worse off. The recession had literally nothing to do with anything that George Bush did, since it began in 2001, before any of his policies took effect. Indeed, it may have already begun before he took office.

During recessions, pretty much everybody does badly. But recessions are harder on less educated, less skilled workers. On average, blacks have less education than whites in this country. So blacks did worse than whites, who are more educated as a group.

Plus, Clinton's welfare reform package -- which was passed on 1996 -- had a five-year limit for welfare coverage. 2001 is five years after 1996, so welfare benefits decreased or disappeared for a lot of people. And blacks as a group are more dependent on welfare programs than whites. Again... this had nothing at all to do with anything that George Bush did.

*Everything* isn't George W. Bush's fault. Or, if you think it is, you've got to do better than innuendo. What, precisely, did George W. Bush do to specifically make black people poorer?



Labels: ,

Wha???

Apparently, Iyad Allawi's bid to once again become the Prime Minister of Iraq has received a surprising endorsement... from the Baath Party. Yes, that Baath Party. As in, the one that Saddam Hussein belonged to when Allawi attempted to assassinate Saddam.

I'm missing something.

Labels:

Memo to Bono

Gregory Clark -- author of the notable A Farewell to Alms -- says that all the humanitarian efforts to eliminate poverty in Africa are destined to fail. A short, interesting read.

Labels: , , ,

Overcoming Bias

Question: If you believe that Michael Vick should be going to prison, then do you also think that every carnivore or hunter should also be locked up?

Question: If not, then what is the distinction (other than the presence, in one of the cases, of an arbitrary law)?

Question: Why do we have laws prohibiting "animal cruelty"? Do we believe that animals possess some inalienable rights? If so, what are they?

Question: If animals possess rights, then how can eating meat/killing animals be legal? If they do not, then why is Vick going to prison and losing millions of dollars?

UPDATE: Matthew Yglesias and Scott Lemieux are discussing the same. First Lemieux:

There are, I think, some colorable substantive distinctions; in particular, Vick's actions (not just the dogfighting but the additional torture-killing of the dogs) represents a sadism for its own sake that factory farming doesn't, and hence it's reasonable for the law to treat them differently. But is this distinction enough to justify significant federal jail time for Vick in a country where factory farming is not only legal but subsidized? Seems like a hard case to make. Can eaters of mass-produced meat (or, even more so, people who see nothing wrong with mass-produced meat) justify intense outrage at Vick? It's hard to rationally justify, I think. A little humility is on order for those of us with bad faith eating practices.
Then Yglesias:

Which is just to say that Michael Vick has violated some laws against animal cruelty. To observe that other kinds of cruel treatment of animals related to the industrial food process should be subjected to more stringent regulation isn't a reason for Vick to be let off the hook. That in the absence of such regulation, a lot of people who think there should be stricter ones find it difficult to live up to our own ethical ideas arguably just strengthens the case for regulation. I'm not, in general, a big believer in the idea that not living in accordance with hypothetical regulatory frameworks while still believing such frameworks should be constructed (supporting a carbon tax or a cap-and-trade scheme while still having a large carbon footprint, for example) constitutes hypocrisy in a meaningful way.
But the argument isn't really about hypocrisy, per se. After all, the vast majority of the country doesn't care at all that animals are harmed in the making of their meat. They don't think it's wrong. And, if asked whether their children should be punitively punished for pulling the wings off of flies or blowing up frogs with M-60s, they'd probably say that they don't care much about that either. Most people don't care that many dogs are executed in humane shelters because there are no homes for them. So the question is... why are there laws against dog fighting but not dog killing? Why is cock fighting prohibited but shooting a B.B. gun at sparrows is allowed? There are a few obvious answers:

1. Dog fighting is especially gruesome, and therefore "cruel".

2. Gambling is involved.

#1 only has any validity if you take for granted that animals inherently hold negative rights, or that humans have positive rights towards them, which preclude us from encouraging or allowing violence against animals. Obviously, most people do not believe this. #2 is partially compelling, but Vick isn't really in trouble for gambling. And obviously, most people would not consign their friends and neighbors to prison for participating in an illicit poker game.

So I think that Lemieux is mostly correct, but I wouldn't phrase it in terms of hypocrisy; I'd instead phrase as an example of bias. Many of has have or have had dogs, and all of us have spent some significant time around them. Many of us have attachments to them which are best described as "personal". So many of us cognitively ascribe some sort of negative rights to dogs without intending to (some people, of course, obviously do intend to), because of personal experiences with dogs that we don't have with, say, cows. This is why many people are revolted by certain culinary practices of other cultures (e.g. Chinese eating cats, etc.). But that doesn't make it rational.

Labels:

The State of American Opportunity

A new study (free link here) by Wojciech Kupczuk, Emmanuel Saez, and Jae Song says that social mobility has been stable since the 1950s (specifically, that mobility for men has decreased, but mobility for women has increased, and the two are relatively self-canceling in the aggregate; a causal relationship was not tested.). I haven't read the whole thing because I don't have NBER clearance and I haven't seen an ungated link, but here's the abstract:

This paper uses Social Security Administration longitudinal earnings micro data since 1937 to analyze the evolution of inequality and mobility in the United States. Earnings inequality follows a U-shape pattern, decreasing sharply up to 1953 and increasing steadily afterwards. We find that short-term and long-term (rank based) mobility among all workers has been quite stable since 1950 (after a temporary surge during World War II). Therefore, the pattern of annual earnings inequality is very close to the pattern of inequality of longer term earnings. Mobility at the top has also been very stable and has not mitigated the dramatic increase in annual earnings concentration since the 1970s. However, the stability in long-term earnings mobility among all workers masks substantial heterogeneity across demographic groups. The decrease in the gender earnings gap and the substantial increase in upward mobility over a career for women is the driving force behind the relative stability of overall mobility measures which mask declines in mobility among men. In contrast, overall inequality and mobility patterns are not significantly influenced by the changing size and structure of immigration nor by changes in the black/white earnings gaps.
It's interesting to note that immigration doesn't affect mobility (so those damn dirty Mexicans aren't stealing all our good jobs after all). Kopczuk and Saez published an earlier study showing that wealth inequality (as measured by estate tax returns) is unchanged since World War II, and Saez co-authored (with Thomas Piketty) the biggest study on income inequality (as measured by income tax returns) in the United States, concluding that income inequality has risen dramatically since 1973, and continues to rise.

What does all this mean? Saez would probably say that progressive taxation and inheritance taxes have kept wealth inequality consistent, and that is a good thing. But he would say that income inequality has been rising, and that is a bad thing. He would say that this increase in income inequality has not been matched by increased social mobility, and that is a bad thing.

I would say that progressive taxation, inheritance taxes, and a more open economy (caused by increased education, technological advance, and greater egalitarianism in labor markets -- esp. w/r/t women and minorities -- as well as greater investment opportunities in financial markets for middle and lower classes, and more common retirement plans) have kept wealth inequality consistent, and that is a good thing. I would say that measured income inequality is increased, but that the measurements aren't always measuring the appropriate things, so some studies aren't painting an appropriate picture of reality, and that I care rather less about income inequality than about absolute gains in real wages across society and social mobility, so the inequality studies are a mixed bag. I would say that the fact that mobility has remained unchanged since 1950 is a good thing, and that we seem to be assimilating immigrants and minorities into the economy is a good thing, but with a caveat: male mobility has decreased, and this could be cause for concern.

This part of the abstract is also very interesting: "Mobility at the top has also been very stable...". I'd taken it as something of a given that mobility at the top of the distribution was higher than in other slices of the distribution. I thought that for obvious reasons:

1. Depending on how you define it, "the top" of the income distribution is a pretty small sample, and superstar theories, lucky breaks, and creative destruction should play a much heavier role there. For example, the Youtube guys made a bunch of money when they sold out to Google, but relatively little money in the year before and year after. So, for one year (and, presumably, only one year), they fit in to the top of the distribution. A similar story might be told of athletes who make a lot of money over their careers, but almost all of it is in a handful of years. Or singers who have a multi-platinum album one year, but don't release anything in the next.

2. CEO compensation is often centered around stock option packages, which are usually exercised all at once. True, these guys make decent salaries in every year, but only the year with exercised options should propel most of them into the top 1% (or so) of the distribution.

Now, the study doesn't say that mobility for the top of the distribution is at the same levels as the rest of the population; only that it has been stable relative to itself. But I would've assumed that the composition of the top of the income distribution would have become more volatile over the past five decades, as technology provided more opportunities to get rich quickly, and as CEO compensation changed. Also, incomes for athletes and entertainers increased a lot in those five decades (and inequality, especially, increased within those occupations). Dr. Galbraith's "five counties" study -- in which almost all of the increase in inequality disappears when controlled for Silicon Valley, Microsoft, and investment bankers in Manhattan -- was evidence in support of my intuition. According to this study, however, I'm wrong.

Tyler Cowen says this:

It should be noted that Saez is the leading measurer of income inequality and also a critic of such inequality. In his view a constant level of mobility means that no force is offsetting ongoing inequality. I believe he would likely read his own paper as support for a left-wing view of the world and as support for concern with income inequality. He would not read his work as reason to dismiss the mobility issue. My view differs, as I worry about mobility -- can a hard-working person get ahead? -- but I do not worry about inequality per se, nor do I require of mobility that it overturn a particular level of inequality.
I'm waiting for commentary from Megan McArdle. I'm sure it will be forthcoming.

Labels: ,

Thursday, August 30, 2007

The Absurdity of U.S. Farm Subsidies


Matthew Yglesias clips this image from NRO's Corner. This is a map of Manhattan, with the red dots representing a recipient of federal farm subsidies. The larger dots represent a recipient of more than $250,000/year. As Yglesias drily notes, "Given that this is clearly a map of Manhattan, one can safely assume that that these people are not struggling family farmers. It's a neat illustration of an out-of-whack system."

The Republicans and Democrats are equally complicit in this, which amounts to a transfer -- through taxation -- from the poorer to the richer. Even worse, this policy kills the U.S.'s credibility in trade negotiations with emerging countries, especially those in South America and Africa. The double standard the U.S. insists on maintaining has derailed Doha, costs Americans billions of dollars a year, condemns millions of people in developing countries to extreme poverty, and allows the U.S. agriculture industries to take rents by eliminating competition from foreign countries. It's a horrible policy, and should be eliminated.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

Antigua Defeats U.S. in WTO Battle

Antigua was unhappy because the U.S. banned offshore online gambling, which provided a lot of revenue for the island. The U.S. claimed that it was absurd for Antigua to take this dispute to the WTO, since regulating gambling comes under the jurisdiction of the U.S. government, not the WTO. The U.S. case makes intuitive sense, but it seems to violate WTO rules to which the U.S. agreed, so Antigua won the case. Now the U.S. has to either ban ALL online gaming -- including horse-bettering and lottery programs which are currently legal -- or allow Antiguan online casinos access to U.S. customers, or pay billions in restitution. Traditionally, this restitution comes in the form of punitive tariffs. But Antigua is too small to inflict any noticeable damage to the U.S., so Antigua asked for permission from the WTO to violate U.S. intellectual property, presumably through piracy of movies, music, technology, or something else. So far as I know, the WTO hasn't issued a final ruling on that point.

It's an interesting case, because it directly challenges the authority of U.S. lawmakers to pass laws in the age of the internet. It also could effect online casinos based in Malta and other countries which have been harmed by the U.S.'s online gambling ban. It also has ramifications for the expansion of intellectual property protections in the Doha negotiations, for which the U.S. is pushing hard.

Dani Rodrik has some commentary here.

Labels: , , ,

George W. Bush: Emperor of America in Iraq?

Matthew Yglesias points us to Mark Kleiman who send us over to Hullabaloo, where Bidby posts an article written by Philip Atkinson and published by Family Security Matters, in which it is argued that George W. Bush should unleash hellfire on Iraq, dropping nukes on the country until they all surrender or are killed, annexing the country, forcing out all the Arabs and moving Americans in, and then declaring himself President-for-Life, ruling from Baghdad. This is to be done Julius Caesar style.

Family Security Matters -- which has Barbara Comstock, Monica Crowley, Frank Gaffney, Laura Ingraham, and James Woolsey on its board -- seems to be an off-shoot of Gaffney's Center for Security Policy. They've been spending a lot of time scrubbing their site of this and other articles, but Hullabaloo has the full text. Apparently, this isn't a joke.

Labels:

Monday, August 27, 2007

U.N. Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad Doesn't Like the Job Pres. Bush Has Done

Esp., Ambassador Khalilzah doesn't like the decision to institute Paul Brewer as Supreme Commander of Iraq in 2003. Condi and Powell didn't like it either. They esp. don't like the fact that none of them were told of the decision until it had been announced. Brad DeLong points us to the NY Times:

Zalmay Khalilzad... has fared better than most of the Bush brigade. As a Beirut-educated, Farsi-speaking Sunni Muslim, he actually has a clue about the Islamic world.... In his shepherding of Hamid Karzai to power in Kabul, his forging of Sunni cooperation now bearing fruit in Iraq’s Anbar Province, and in his recent prodding of the U.N. to a fuller Iraqi role....

I was intrigued to find Zal looking back in anguish. President Bush now alludes to “the mistakes that have been made,” but is unspecific. There’s such an array, everyone has a favorite: a nonexistent casus belli, skimpy troop levels, the end of the Iraqi army, aberrant planning.

Khalilzad’s anguish centers on May 6, 2003. That’s the day he expected Bush to announce his return to Iraq to convene a grand assembly — something like an Afghan loya jirga — that would fast-forward a provisional Iraqi government. Instead, the appointment of L. Paul Bremer III to head a Coalition Provisional Authority was announced. Khalilzad, incredulous, went elsewhere. In the place of an Afghan-American Muslim on a mission to empower Iraqis, we got the former ambassador to the Netherlands for a one-year proconsul gig. “We had cleared both announcements, with Bremer to run things and me to convene the loya jirga, both as presidential envoys,” Khalilzad told me. “We were just playing with a few final words. Then the game plan suddenly changed: we would run the country ourselves.... Powell and Condi were incredulous. Powell called me and asked: ‘What happened?’ And I said, ‘You’re secretary of state and you’re asking me what happened!’ ”

Powell confirmed his astonishment. “The plan was for Zal to go back,” he said. “He was the one guy who knew this place better than anyone. I thought this was part of the deal with Bremer. But with no discussion, no debate, things changed. I was stunned.”

The volte-face came at a Bush- Bremer lunch that day where Bremer made a unity of command argument to the Decider. “I put it very directly to the president: you can’t have two presidential envoys running around Iraq,” Bremer told me....

Khalilzad[:]... "We could have had an interim Iraqi government. I argued, based on Afghanistan, that with forces, diplomacy and money, nothing can happen anyway without your support.”

Powell agrees. “Everything was Bremer, the suit, the boots, the whole nine yards.” It was a mistake not to move “more rapidly to putting an Iraqi face on it.”

Khalilzad and Powell are right.... This was the sledgehammer approach. And chosen over lunch. “Unfortunately, yes, the way that decision was taken was typical,” Powell said. “Done! No full deliberations. And you suddenly discover, gee, maybe that wasn’t so great, we should have thought about it a little longer”...



Oops. Guess we should've talked to the experts before changing major aspects of our post-invasion strategy over a lunch meeting. Since most of the worst policy decisions in Iraq occurred under Bremer's watch, Bush's decision to trust his gut in this regard was one of the worst decisions in the history of the American presidency.

Labels:

Saturday, August 25, 2007

The New Mafia

The Cosa Nostra has been replaced.

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

Microcredit Meets Generation Y

A great story of a tech start-up designed to foster microcredit exchanges between rich first-worlders and poorer third-worlders. Good luck to the company, called Kiva. Some clips:

In their office in San Francisco's Mission District, Matt and Jessica Flannery and Premal Shah work with the fervor and techno savvy of an Internet startup aiming for an IPO. But they aren't chasing the cash for themselves.

They're doing it for Esther Egbulu in Nigeria, a mother of six who wants an $800 loan to stock her shop with frozen chickens and turkey, or 31-year-old Choeun Sonin, who's requesting $1,000 to purchase a motorcycle taxi — just two of 15,000 entrepreneurs from 36 countries that their company, Kiva, has already helped. Kiva, which means "unity" in Swahili, is a lending organization with a twist: Anyone with a bit of money and an Internet connection can step forward as a microlender to assist struggling third-world entrepreneurs get out of poverty.

After logging in, you can scroll through profiles of entrepreneurs, descriptions of their businesses, and the loan amounts they're requesting. Once you've decided who you want to lend to, you choose how much to lend, starting at as little as $25. (Individual lenders can fund an entire loan, but most of Kiva's loans are funded by multiple lenders.)

Funds are distributed to entrepreneurs through local non-profit microfinance partners in specific countries.

Eighty percent of the lenders come from the U.S., 10% from Canada, and the remainder from the rest of the world.

Kiva says entrepreneurs pay back their loans an incredible 99% of the time — a default rate unheard of at traditional financial institutions. (The Kiva team expects the rate to increase to 5% as more borrowers complete the loan cycle.) And according to Premal, most lenders reinvest their money in other entrepreneurs after a loan is paid back. Kiva's operational costs are covered by donations from lenders. The company does not take a commission from the loans facilitated on the site.

Labels:

Chavez's Growing Inequality Gap

By at least one measure, things aren't looking so good in Caracas:

Despite Chavez's "revolution for the poor" the Gini coefficient has increased from 0.44 in 2000 to 0.48 in 2005.
A commenter there piles on:

Part of it has to do that after soon nine years of chávez´s “socialist government” gas is sold at less than 12 US cents per gallon, less that its direct cost of distribution and with this about 10% of GDP is transferred from those who have nothing to those who buy gasoline. Annual gasoline subsidies amount to US$ 3.000 per car.
(ht: Marginal Revolution)

Labels: , ,

WHO Health Care Measures Are Wrong

Eat your heart out, Michael Moore:

So what's wrong with the WHO and Commonwealth Fund studies? Let me count the ways.

The WHO judged a country's quality of health on life expectancy. But that's a lousy measure of a health-care system. Many things that cause premature death have nothing do with medical care. We have far more fatal transportation accidents than other countries. That's not a health-care problem.

Similarly, our homicide rate is 10 times higher than in the U.K., eight times higher than in France, and five times greater than in Canada.

When you adjust for these "fatal injury" rates, U.S. life expectancy is actually higher than in nearly every other industrialized nation.

Diet and lack of exercise also bring down average life expectancy.

Another reason the U.S. didn't score high in the WHO rankings is that we are less socialistic than other nations. What has that got to do with the quality of health care? For the authors of the study, it's crucial. The WHO judged countries not on the absolute quality of health care, but on how "fairly" health care of any quality is "distributed." The problem here is obvious. By that criterion, a country with high-quality care overall but "unequal distribution" would rank below a country with lower quality care but equal distribution.

It's when this so-called "fairness," a highly subjective standard, is factored in that the U.S. scores go south.

The U.S. ranking is influenced heavily by the number of people -- 45 million -- without medical insurance. As I reported in previous columns, our government aggravates that problem by making insurance artificially expensive with, for example, mandates for coverage that many people would not choose and forbidding us to buy policies from companies in another state.

Even with these interventions, the 45 million figure is misleading. Thirty-seven percent of that group live in households making more than $50,000 a year, says the U.S. Census Bureau. Nineteen percent are in households making more than $75,000 a year; 20 percent are not citizens, and 33 percent are eligible for existing government programs but are not enrolled.

For all its problems, the U.S. ranks at the top for quality of care and innovation, including development of life-saving drugs. It "falters" only when the criterion is proximity to socialized medicine.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

Chavez Consolidates Control

This was inevitable, but it's still sad.

Labels:

Denis Leary & Lenny Clarke Blast Mel Gibson

It was a year ago. "Call Jeffrey Katzenberg and ask him for a job when you get out."

Motherf*cking Snakes on a Motherf*cking Plane!

It's real.

Obama Wants to Ease Cuban Embargo

About time. The utter ridiculousness of the Cuban embargo is apparent to anyone without an axe to grind.

Even better, the U.S. must improve its relations with S. America. We'll have opportunities as Chavez and Morales run their economies into the ground and consolidate more and more political authority, as Brazil straightens itself out and rises as an important international economy, and as the Cuban regime collapses or reforms. We need to start extending olive branches now; not to the leaders of these countries, who don't suffer much from embargoes anyway, but to the citizenry. Cuban-Americans who travel back to Cuba and/or repatriate some of their incomes can be the best P.R. tool we could imagine. It's a resource which should not be neglected.

Update: Thomas Barnett concurs.

Labels: , ,

Monday, August 20, 2007

Do Americans Get Enough Vacation?

It's become sort of a hot topic, tangentially discussed in Moore's Sicko, and explored at length in the liberal blogosphere. Good Klein has made it a sort of mini-mission to steer policy towards guaranteeing workers some vacation time (he correctly notes that America is the only advanced country in the world without some level of federally-mandated vacation time). Matthew Yglesias has gone on record saying that this will have an adverse effect on economic growth and productivity, and will most likely suppress wages. That's the standard economic argument from theory, and I've seen no convincing evidence to contradict it.

So here comes "Kathy G.," guest-blogging while Klein is on, ahem, vacation. She's got two posts on the topic. The first cites a study that shows that Americans' leisure time has increased since the 1960s. Obviously, leisure time isn't the same as vacation time, but it supports the notion that if given the choice between higher wages -- which creates opportunities for more leisure time in short bursts through outsourcing of domestic tasks -- and lower wages but more long-form vacation time, Americans tend to prefer the former. She cites all the reasons why the study is methodologically sound (large samples across time, controls for demographic changes, the use of time diaries instead of surveys, etc.), but then says that she simply doesn't believe it, and cites a few reasons why (the best: people who agree to do time diaries aren't random observations and present a bias of self-selection).

Another important part of the study shows that higher-wage Americans have less leisure than lower-wage Americans. This would seem to indicate that, when given the option to work more (and make more money) or to work less (and accept lower wages but more leisure time), Americans overwhelmingly choose to work more.

But in her next post on the topic, she does a curious thing: she contradicts the above assertion by saying that we don't know if people would trade wages for more vacation time because we haven't asked them. This is strange because she acknowledged the troubles of using survey data in the previous post. Also, because the example she gives of people not being asked seems to contradict her premise. She cites Arlie Hochschild's Time Blind, a book which tells the story of a company which offered a generous time-off policy. But the employees, motivated by the opportunity to advance (and thus make more money) if they worked more and took less time off, chose to forego available vacation time. This seems like a pretty straightforward example of Americans being given a choice: more money, or more vacation. In this case they chose the extra cash. (Kathy G. implies that employees worked more because their fellow employees worked more. I have no doubt that this is true, but nobody said there wasn't a trade-off involved. Indeed, that's sort of the whole point.)

I haven't seen a broad study on the topic, but my intuition is that a similar story could be told about many companies. But instead of focusing on this point, Ms. G. comes to a strange conclusion: employees need union-lite workers' advocacy groups to (apparently) poll workers and (apparently) use that data -- which presumably would show that workers would prefer vacation time to extra money -- to influence national labor policy. Right.

But unfortunately, according to Ms. G., neither employers, unions, or any moderate political platforms are interested in this. So we need to overhaul the government by electing a progressive Democratic president (presumably Edwards), a larger Democratic majority in the House, and a Democratic Senate with more than 60 votes. This will enable us to crack the influence of unions and create new workers' advocacy groups to pressure employers for more vacation time for workers.

Despite the fact that there is no, y'know, evidence that this is something that workers actually even want, and some pretty strong evidence to the contrary. Yeesh.

It's a weird couple of posts.

Thursday, August 16, 2007

The Inanity of the U.S./China Trade Debate

Philip Levy hits the nail on the head. The upshot:
Congress is demanding the right policy for the wrong reasons and warning that they’ll hurt American consumers unless they get their way. Regular Americans are scared of the Sino-shrimp. And the Chinese are threatening to do what Congress wants, unless Congress relents. This has all the makings of a classic summer farce. If only global macroeconomic stability didn’t depend on it.
arg.

(ht: Greg Mankiw)

Labels: , ,

Ezra Klein Is Not Making Sense

Unfortunately for him, Good Klein sometimes gets too caught up in hyperbole. He is a smart and (usually) reasonable man, but he has written a horrible blog post:

Before America invaded Iraq, George Packer wrote an article for The New York Times Magazine on the liberal hawks that sought to categorize the pro- and anti-war arguments. Given that you often hear war supporters say that the doves opposed this war for the wrong reasons, it's interesting to see what Packer considered the arguments of the two sides:
For War

1. Saddam is cruel and dangerous.
2. Saddam has used weapons of mass destruction and has never stopped trying to develop them.
3. Iraqis are suffering under tyranny and sanctions.
4. Democracy would benefit Iraqis.
5. A democratic Iraq could drain influence from repressive Saudi Arabia.
6. A democratic Iraq could unlock the Israeli-Palestinian stalemate.
7. A democratic Iraq could begin to liberalize the Arab world.
8. Al Qaeda will be at war with us regardless of what we do in Iraq.

Against War

1. Containment has worked for 10 years, and inspections could still work.
2. We shouldn't start wars without immediate provocation and international support.
3. We could inflict terrible casualties, and so could Saddam.
4. A regional war could break out, and anti-Americanism could build to a more dangerous level.
5. Democracy can't be imposed on a country like Iraq.
6. Bush's political aims are unknown, and his record is not reassuring.
7. America's will and capacity for nation building are too limited.
8. War in Iraq will distract from the war on terrorism and swell Al Qaeda's ranks.

So far as I can tell, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 on the pro-war case proved to be entirely wrong. The remaining rationales were that Saddam is a tyrant -- true, but not nearly reason enough to go to war -- and that Iraqis were suffering under sanctions. Our sanctions.

Meanwhile, literally every element of the anti-war case has been proven correct, save for four, which has proven accurate in a low-grade way as Iran has sought to increase its control over its destabilized neighbor.

These were the two cases. They existed -- both of them -- before the conflict. They had, as Packer details, high profile adherents. The anti-war case was internally coherent, rigorous, and in the final analysis, utterly correct. Not accidentally correct, but accurate in its particulars and predictions. No wonder those who got it wrong are so anxious to argue that nobody truly got it right.

A few problems with this. First, numbers 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, & 8 of the pro-war case are not "entirely false". As example, take #2: "Saddam has used weapons of mass destruction and has never stopped trying to develop them." Obviously, this is not entirely false, since Saddam had used weapons of mass destruction on his own citizens and on Kuwaitis. This is not a point of debate. In addition, there is still strong evidence that Saddam was still pursuing WMD (from his own nuclear scientists, who handed over centrifuges to U.S. troops) and other conventional weapons which he was not permitted to have according to U.N. resolutions (e.g. attempting to purchase cruise missiles off the shelf from A.Q. Khan in Pakistan). Saddam had routinely thrown out or harassed U.N. weapons inspectors. This second point might be debatable, but it's certainly not "entirely false".

#4 hasn't proven to be "entirely false" either, since there has never been democracy in Iraq. The system of government put in place by the Iraqi constitution is consociational, not at all a true democracy. Consociational arrangements can sometimes work (although the point is arguable), but it can also exacerbate pre-existing ethnic/sectarian divisions. In this case, it seems to have done so, and a more democratic system (like single-member districting, for example, which could force representatives to gain approval from segments of all ethnic/sectarian groups, thus fostering a moderate government) may have led to a better result.

Anyway, I don't think that anyone could debate that a functioning democracy which includes strong and lawful institutions would benefit Iraqis. The fact that this state of affairs hasn't occurred yet doesn't disprove this idea. This same rationale rebuts Klein's criticism of #s 5, 6, & 7. They could all be true in an alternate world where Iraq has a functioning, democratic, stable government. But since that prerequisite doesn't exist, you can't disprove the hypothesis.

As to #8... I have no idea what Klein is talking about. Does he have any reason to believe that if we had never invaded Iraq that al-Qaeda would've just rolled over and left us alone in perpetuity? I've never heard anyone even attempt to make that case, much less prove it. It's a ridiculous assumption on the face, and Klein doesn't even bother presenting a single piece of evidence in support. Or even an intellectual argument without evidence. Perhaps he has something well-thought in mind, but he doesn't mention it, and I've not seen or heard it.

Finally, this was not the entire pro-war case. Packer was a moderate supporter of the war in the run-up, but he is certainly not an apologist for neoconservatism. And he left out a central point: Saddam's direct support and approval of international terrorism, gangsterism, war crimes, and direct acts of war against the U.S.

To the first point: Saddam sheltered Ramzi Yousef, the bomber of the WTC in 1993. Yousef entered the U.S. on an Iraqi visa to conduct that attack, and was given safe haven in Iraq (with Saddam's direct knowledge) after the fact. His uncle, who advised him in planning that attack and gave him funding for that end, is Khalid Shaikh Mohammed: mastermind of the 9/11 attacks. This point, also, is not under debate. But Saddam's direct ties to terrorism don't end there, since al-Zarqawi, the late leader of al-Qaeda in Iraq and former lieutenant to bin Laden, was granted entrance to Iraq after the U.S. intervention in Afghanistan (where he had previously operated) but before the U.S. invasion of Iraq. In other words, even if Saddam were not affiliated with al-Qaeda before 9/11, he most certainly was after that event. His public cheering of the 9/11 attacks immediately after the fact is likewise despiscable.

To the second: Saddam attempted to assassinate a former President of the United States -- George H.W. Bush -- in April 1993. This alone was justification for Saddam's removal.

To the third: Saddam's war crimes and genocidal attempts are well documented, and I won't rehash them here.

To the fourth: Saddam fired on U.S. airplanes patrolling the Iraqi no-fly zone nearly every day for nearly a decade. This prompted the Clinton administration to engage in many small-scale interventions and retaliations, and to eventually conclude that regime-change in Iraq through American intervention was necessary and inevitable.

Also, yes... Iraqis were suffering under sanctions. But these were not "our sanctions". They were sanctions agreed upon by the U.N., and levied by that body. They were, in other words, the result of the sort of non-interventionary diplomacy that Mr. Klein supposedly prefers. And that resulted in an estimated 1 million+ Iraqis dead from lack of proper food, water, and medical supplies; the corrupted Oil-for-Food program, and the continuing presence of Saddam and brutalization of his people.

Now, Klein says that "literally every element of the anti-war case has been proven correct." This is patently false. For example, anti-war claim #1: I guess it depends on what Mr. Klein means when he says that containment "worked". If he means that it prevented Saddam from expressly invading another country *again*, then I suppose he is correct. But by nearly any other metric, the policy of "containment-via-sanctions-and-continuous-military-patrols" failed miserably.

As I mentioned before, #2 is likewise invalid. The U.S. had been directly provoked by Saddam, when he attempted to assassinate a former president, when he fired upon U.S. military planes patrolling no-fly zones on a daily basis, and when he harbored international terrorists who directly attacked the United States. All of these are clear incitements to war. And as to the "international support" argument: some 40-odd countries contributed troops to our cause. Others offered monetary support, and others offered verbal support. There was substantial international support for intervention. I don't know what the official standard is for the exact appropriate level of international support, or which countries get the most-heavily weighted vote in the matter. But to say that this war was unilateral is simply untrue.

#3, I guess, is true. Casualties were inevitable. But casualties were also inevitable if we didn't intervene. After all, Saddam wasn't known for his kindness to his fellow Iraqis. Neither were his sadistic sons, who were slated to obtain absolute power after Saddam died. Indeed, Saddam had to reign them in. It's probably true that if we hadn't invaded Iraq that civilian casualties would be lower. But the same would have been true if al-Zarqawi -- who single-handedly escalated the sectarian violence to its most obscene levels, and whose barbarities were even shunned by bin Laden -- were not in the country, and of course he was permitted to enter by Saddam's government. So who has done the most damage? The answer isn't so obvious.

#4 is demonstrably false, at least to this point in time.

#5 is unfalsifiable at this point, and may still be unproven in time. In any case, the argument stings of xenophobia. As in, "those savages couldn't manage a democracy. Too uncivilized."

I suppose that #6 is arguable. I think Pres. Bush's policy aims were obvious -- i.e. to remake the MidEast in such a way as to attack international terrorism and promote global stability. To that end, he became the first U.S. president to call for a Palestinian state, and he worked to bring Arab/Muslim allies into the the fold (e.g. Pakistan, Turkey, Bahrain, U.A.B., etc.). In addition, Libya was persuaded to give up its nuclear program, and rallied the international community in opposition to Iran's efforts to develop one. These are no small movements, but they've been almost universally ignored.

#7 is probably true, but that's as much of an indictment against anti-war proponents as it is against the decision to invade Iraq.

#8 is a question of semantics. After all, al-Qaeda's largest presence in the world now is in Iraq. The largest incidences of global terrorism all occur in Iraq. After the invasion of Afghanistan during which most of the senior al-Qaeda leaders fled, what were we to do? Just let them run to Pakistan? To Iraq? To Syria? To Saudi Arabia? Major terrorist operations exist and existed in all of those places. If we withdraw, then we are refusing to fight terrorism where it is most endemic. Anyway, the same rationale presented in #8 would preclude invading Afghanistan.

I'm sorry for the length of this, but Klein's sort of shoddy thinking demands a full rebuttal.

Labels:

Wednesday, August 15, 2007

Fighting Terrorism By Legalizing Drugs

Daniel Drezner is pointed by Mark Thoma to the Financial Times, where Willem Buiter explains how we can fight terrorism by legalizing drugs:

A pragmatic argument against criminalising drugs is that criminalisation creates vast rents and encourages criminal entrepreneurs to use violence, intimidation, bribery, extortion and corruption to extract these rents. Another pragmatic argument is that it is pointless to waste resources fighting a war that cannot be won. The losing war on drugs wastes resources that could be used to fight terrorism and other crimes.

Another important argument for legalising, in particular, all cultivation of poppy and of coca (and their illegal derivatives) is that this would take away a vital source of income and political support for terrorist move- ments, including the Taliban and al-Qaeda in Afghanistan, and Colombia’s Revolutionary Armed Forces (Farc) and various paramilitary groups.

The United Nations estimates that opium production in Afghanistan grew to more than 6,000 metric tonnes last year with a value exceeding $3bn. It is the origin of more than 90 per cent of the world’s illegally consumed opiates.

A significant portion of the profits flows to the Taliban, who act as middlemen in the opium business. They combine extortion and threats of violence towards the poppy farmers with the sale of protection to these same farmers against those who would destroy their livelihood, mainly the Nato allies and the Afghan central government.

Following legalisation, the allies in Afghanistan could further undermine the financial strength of the Taliban and al-Qaeda by buying up the entire poppy harvest. If a sufficient premium over the prevailing market price were offered, the Taliban/al-Qaeda middle-man could be cut out altogether, and thus would lose his tax base. Winning the hearts and minds of poppy growers and coca growers is a lot easier when you are not seen as intent on destroying their livelihood.

Of course, there are plenty of other reasons to legalize drugs, and Buiter acknowledges some of those as well:

The principle-based argument for legalisation is that behaviour that harms others ought to be criminalised, not behaviour that hurts only the person engaged in it. It is not the government’s job to protect adults of sound mind from the predictable consequences of their actions.

If the public is ill-informed about the consequences of drug taking, there is an educational role for the state. Children should be protected from drugs, as they are from tobacco and alcohol. So should the mentally ill and mentally incapacitated. Parents should be paternalistic, but when it comes to mentally competent grown-ups the state should not be. It is not the responsibility of the state to ensure our “happiness” – whatever that is. That is the road to a Brave New World.

He could have mentioned, but didn't, the extreme social ills of drug-centered gang and mob violence, the burden of imprisoning so many people for committing victimless "crimes," and the resources saved by ending the imprisonment of those people, as well as slashing the government bureaucracy dedicated to hunting and arresting those who illegally peddle drugs. Plus the revenue which could be had by legalizing and taxing the drugs. Plus the social health benefits caused by government testing and regulation, thus preventing unsafe drugs from hitting the street. Etc.

It's a great article. Obviously, the case for legalization is much stronger than simply as a mechanism of combating terrorism, but that argument is persuasive enough on its face to open up the debate in broader contexts than has been previously done.

Labels: , ,

The Giuliani Doctrine

Matthew Yglesias destroys Rudy's recent essay in Foreign Affairs. It's worth reading the whole post, but here's the upshot:

The result of this policy is going to be an endless series of wars, a bankrupt country accounting for way more than fifty percent of world defense expenditures, fewer and fewer countries willing to cooperate with us on key priorities and, perhaps worst of all, more and more nuclear proliferation as countries decide its not safe to live in a world where the Rudy-led USA is the big kid on the block.
I don't think he's over-stating the case. After all, Giuliani's chief foreign policy advisor is Norman Podhoretz -- who is already on record as saying that the Iraq War "couldn't have gone better," and who wants to unilaterally bomb Iran -- and Giuliani has been the most hawkish of the the GOP candidates in the debates.

Giuliani must be opposed. At all costs.

Labels: , ,

Jane Galt joins The Atlantic

Effective later this month. Link here. The title "Asymmetrical Information" will remain. This is good for The Atlantic, who now has the best stable of bloggers around, by far (Yglesias, Sullivan, Douthat, Fallows, Armbinder are all aces). Bad news for The Economist, and esp. it's anonymous "Free Exchange" blog.

Labels: ,

Bonobo Blogging

Brad DeLong Is Scaring Me

First he says this:

Central Banking in Practice

So, today the monetary base in the North Atlantic economies is 7% higher than it was yesterday--an annualized growth rate of 2100% per year.

This is indeed a significant liquidity event...

That's scary enough. But then he comes with this:

The Fed Is Buying Mortgage-Backed Securities? Hoisted from Comments

PSP: Hoisted from Comments http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2007/08/central-banking.html#comment-79038528:

Fri morning's N.Y. Times online edition:

The E.C.B. injected another 61 billion euros ($84 billion) into the banking system, after providing 95 billion euros the day before. The Federal Reserve today added $19 billion to the system through the purchase of mortgage-backed securities, then $16 billion in three-day repurchase agreements. The Fed also added money on Thursday.

I thought the Fed only bought and sold Federal debt. This says it is intervening directly in the mortgage-backed securities market. Is this as unusual as I think it is?

Yes.



I'm getting freaked out. But then the kind professor provides some reassurance:

John Berry of Bloomberg says what's what about the Federal Reserve:

The amount of cash the Federal Reserve injected into the U.S. banking system on Aug. 9 and 10, and its importance, have been widely misunderstood. Each day banks are open, the people working at the New York Federal Reserve Bank's ninth floor Open Market Desk do the same thing: supply enough money to the U.S. banking system to keep the overnight lending rate close to the Fed's 5.25 percent target. Aug. 9 and 10 were different only in degree, and in the attention the Fed called to the action in a statement issued on the latter day.

There was no hint of an interest rate cut -- nor is there likely to be unless conditions in world financial markets worsen considerably and threaten continued economic growth in the U.S.... The desk added $24 billion on Thursday and $38 billion on Friday. However, just stating those figures tends to exaggerate their importance. For instance, as recently as Aug. 2, $17 billion had been added and everyone yawned. Furthermore, by the end of the yesterday essentially all the additional liquidity injected to calm markets had been withdrawn....

Routinely, a substantial amount of cash is added each Thursday for a 14-day period. Half of last Thursday's injection was of that type. The other $12 billion was left in the banking system just overnight, that is, the New York Fed returned the securities on Friday and took back the cash.... The lending rate jumped around, ranging from zero to just over 6 percent, as the desk found it necessary to step in three times, adding $19 billion at 8:25 a.m., another $16 billion at 10:55 a.m. and finally $3 billion at 1:50 p.m., according to the New York Fed. All that $38 billion was returned to the Fed yesterday.

With markets under far less pressure, that money was replaced by new agreements of just $2 billion, much less than the usual daily total....

Ahhh.... that's better. Everything's gonna be alright.

(isn't it?)

Labels:

More Bad News for Michael Vick

I kid you not:

Embattled NFL quarterback Michael Vick, facing federal charges related to his alleged participation in dogfighting, has been hit with a "$63,000,000,000 billion dollar" lawsuit filed by a South Carolina inmate who alleges the Atlanta Falcons star stole his pit bulls and sold them on eBay to buy "missiles from Iran," FOX News has learned.

Riches alleges that Vick stole two white mixed pit bull dogs from his home in Holiday, Fla., and used them for dogfighting operations in Richmond, Va. The complaint goes on to allege that Vick sold the dogs on eBay and “used the proceeds to purchase missiles from the Iran government.”

The complaint also alleges that Vick would need those missiles because he pledged allegiance to Al Qaeda in February of this year.

“Michael Vick has to stop physically hurting my feelings and dashing my hopes,” Riches writes in the complaint.

Riches wants $63 billion dollars “backed by gold and silver “ delivered to the front gates to the Williamsburg Federal Correctional facility in South Carolina. Riches is an inmate at the facility serving out a wire fraud conviction.

Labels: