Tuesday, January 29, 2008

A Post-Abortion America

Ross Douthat tries to imagine the possibility... and the necessary trade-offs:

Designing abortion restrictions for contemporary America would require compromises on the part of pro-lifers, obviously – not only on rape and incest but also probably on the availability and distribution of the morning-after pill. But more than that, it would almost certainly require large-scale (and expensive) experimentation with the American welfare state, to address the needs of the hundreds of thousands of pregnant women each year who would suddenly no longer have the option of aborting their unborn - and the hundreds of thousands of children who would come into the world as a result.

What exact form this sort of experimentation would take I'm not sure; it's a thorny enough subject to make a topic for a long essay or even a book. But over the short term, there's no question that it would require conservatives to temporarily table many of their longstanding policy goals - from cutting illegitimacy rates to reducing welfare dependency to limiting the size of government – in the name of the pro-life cause. ...

Over the long run, my assumption is that a ban on abortion, by changing the incentives of sexual behavior and family formation, would actually end up reducing out-of-wedlock births, welfare spending, and all the rest of it, and that a short-term investment in a pro-life welfare state (and an acceptance of the short term spike in illegitimacy, dependency and government spending that would presumably accompany it) would prove a boon to conservatism in the end. But that's a long-term hope, not a short-term plan - and even if that assumption weren’t borne out, I still think that a higher illegitimacy rate and a more expensive and intrusive welfare state would be a small price to pay for a country where every human being enjoyed the protection of the laws.
In 2003, Americans aborted 854,122 potential babies. Pro-lifers quickly contend that this is an astonishingly large number, and they'd be right. But there's another side to that coin: that's 850k more people that we, as a country, would have to support every single year. The old "adoption is always an option" mantra doesn't seem to cover it. Even if we didn't further enrich benefits for poorer Americans, the pressure put on welfare programs, Medicaid, food stamp programs, education budgets, and everything else would be astounding. Plus, if these children are unwanted and there aren't enough folks willing to adopt, then are we going to go back to a massive government-run orphanage system? Are we going to allow gay couples to adopt?

A truly heartless conservative would say "if you get knocked up, it's your problem, and you've gotta deal with it without help from the state." I can hear these arguments coming already, especially if an abortion ban was matched by an increase in taxes to pay for more welfare spending. But in reality, this will never happen in our society, nor should it. The first time some kid gets abandoned, or is found starving in a heatless room, taxes are going right up to pay for programs to make sure that doesn't happen.

I am also unwilling to simply accept on the face Douthat's assertion that "Over the long run, my assumption is that a ban on abortion, by changing the incentives of sexual behavior and family formation, would actually end up reducing out-of-wedlock births, welfare spending, and all the rest of it". This, to me, is not an obviously correct presumption. After all, there are already a lot of disincentives to being sexually active. Nobody wants to have an abortion and go through the emotional and financial trouble involved. Nobody wants to get an STD. We have Sex Ed classes and free condoms. And yet, we're still aborting 850k kids per year. Additionally, if we replace access to abortion with an increased welfare bureaucracy and/or state-run child care and orphanages, then why should people change their behavior? If they get pregnant, the state is just going to pay for much of the cost anyway.

But even if we didn't increase federal outlays, and thereby forced people to bear most of the cost themselves, then we've opened a whole ton of other issues. Will we permit men who knock up their girlfriends out of wedlock to get off scot-free, or will we make them pay child support? Will mothers who can't support their children get them taken away by DCFS, or will we let them rot away? Even if one answers by saying that there should be no government involvement in the matter, will it really lower the rates of pregnancy? I honestly see no convincing reason to think so.

The Conservatives' Case for Obama

Andrew Sullivan lays it out nicely here:

It's a long year and, mercifully, I don't have to address all the many good points you've made in the past week or so by email about the weirdness of a conservative supporting Obama. Right now, I'm considering who should get the Democratic nomination. It seems to me that a conservative who picks Obama over Clinton or Edwards in that context doesn't betray any great principles.

But in the general? Isn't he a leftist? A socialist even? Derb's splutter is not unreasonable as splutters go.

A preliminary comment. Compared to what? It seems to me that any Republican cavilling at Obama's incremental liberalism who has not exploded in rage during the last seven years has no standing to debate this question.

No conservative who has not gone nuclear at the Bush administration's Medicare bill, or its doubling of federal education spending, or its adding $32 trillion to unfunded liabilities, or its long record of nanny-state initiatives, or its trampling of states rights in education, drug laws, marriage laws, and on and on ... has much of a leg to stand on when complaining - now - about big government liberalism. In many ways, it's much worse coming from the Republicans, because Bush and his cronies have legitimized left-liberalism in ways that even Clinton could not (and did not).

Of course, I have exploded in rage at the GOP. But part of that explosion is a hope that they are collectively punished for trashing the brand and the principles of conservatism. If the fall comes around and there is a vast difference between the spending plans of the Democratic and the Republican nominee, I'll happily revisit this question. But I should add that, while I've never met a tax cut I didn't like, I've never subscribed to the idea that indefinite government debt is a conservative principle. And sometimes, as Reagan showed, that means raising taxes. Clinton's tax hike did not kill the economy. Something similar won't either. And the notion that a bankrupt government in a post-industrial economy needs to maintain the same economic policies as the 1980s is arguable. If you didn't catch Chris Caldwell's typically sharp essay on Sunday, check it out.

I have further thoughts - on foreign policy, climate change and identity politics - but I'll save them for later posts. But let's be clear here: Compared to Bush, Obama is a conservative. He is promising nothing like the expansion of government or debt that Bush pushed through in eight years. Nothing like. That doesn't mean I like the idea of even bigger government. It does mean that a little historical context helps.



I'm not a big states' rights guy, but other than that I pretty much agree. Sullivan's Atlantic cover article from a few months back is also pretty good, although some of his arguments fail the further he stretches them out.

Labels:

FISA Me Once, Shame on Me...

The Cato Institute is begging us to ask whether or not they actually believe in liberty and small government. They've allowed their legal VP to opine in the WSJ that the president ought to have legal authority to wiretap just about anything, everything, and anyone that he pleases so long as he mentions "terrorism" or "national security" while he's doing it. I won't link to the original piece, as it is too disgusting, but Julian Sanchez's detailed take-down is a must-read for anybody interested in the issue.

As Stephen Colbert, riffing on Patrick Henry, once said: "Give me liberty... or do whatever it takes to make sure I don't die."

Labels:

False Populists


Matthew Yglesias questions the meaning of a sentence from Bush's State of the Union address from last night:

Here's a random note from last night. Bush, talking about a free trade pact with Colombia, said "If we fail to pass this agreement, we will embolden the purveyors of false populism in our hemisphere." The purveyors of false populism are, I guess, Hugo Chavez and other murky conspirators. But why is it false populism? Chavez is a real populist. Maybe you think he's a populist peddling fake solutions to Latin America's problems, but he's certainly not a secret pro-business neoliberal.

Or, perhaps Bush was referring to the fact that, despite Chavez's rhetoric, income inequality has increased during his tenure as Glorified National Leader and Great President. The economic disparities in Venezuela are nicely captured by the above photo, of Caracas. Similar stories may be told of Brazil (11th most unequal country in the world), Bolivia (6th most unequal), and just about every other country in Latin America, many of which are led by "real populists".

For the record, the U.S. was right at the global weighted average. List here.

Labels: , , ,

What Is This 'Decoupling' of Which You Speak?

Dani Rodrik notices that businessmen in emerging economies are relatively nonplussed about the possibility of a U.S. recession:

But if you talk to businessmen (alas they were all men) from India, Russia, China, Turkey or the Gulf States, you would hardly know that we have just experienced a credit market freeze-out in the West. They are all ho-hum about it. Yeah, we could shave a point or two off our growth estimates, they say, if the U.S. goes into a deep recession, but it's no big deal--and can you pass the wine please. Indians are saying we don't rely that much on exports anyhow; the Chinese are relying on their growing middle class; and others have their own stories.

Is this the famous "decoupling" at work? Will this be the beginning of a new era of the world economy, with several key developing countries, the BRICs and the N-11 (using the faddish terms that attach to them), gaining real ascendancy over their Western counterparts?

Probably not. But something interesting is going on.

Meanwhile, the world's financial markets -- from the relatively deep and rich (EuroZone) to the relatively shallow and unsure (Asia) -- have not reacted very well to trouble in the U.S. markets and the possibility of recession:

Decoupling holds that European and Asian economies, especially emerging ones, have broadened and deepened to the point that they no longer depend on the United States for growth, leaving them insulated from a severe slowdown there, even a fully fledged recession. Faith in the concept has generated strong outperformance for stocks outside the United States - until now.

As opinion began to solidify after the start of the year that a recession, or something close to it, was likely in the United States, stock prices accelerated their declines, with the selling intensifying early last week. Contrary to what the decouplers would have expected, the losses were greater outside the United States, with the worst experienced in emerging markets and developed economies like Germany and Japan. ...

Decoupling was all the rage early last year when international financial markets all but ignored the increasing turmoil in the U.S. economy and stock market. Investment advisers point out, however, that the segments of the U.S. economy that were showing wear and tear then were those to which the rest of the world would never be heavily exposed. That is no longer true, they say, and markets are responding accordingly.

"Decoupling is yesterday's story," Stuart Schweitzer, a global strategist at JP Morgan Private Bank, said. "Last year, when the U.S. slowdown was driven almost entirely by housing, it made sense that the rest of the world kept right on going. Housing is a domestic story, plain and simple.

"The nature of the slowdown has changed in two key respects. The credit crunch that began in midsummer is not just a U.S. phenomenon; the rise in risk aversion is global and will have an impact on credit terms and availability everywhere. And we're finally seeing evidence that the U.S. job market is losing steam and consumer spending is slowing."

The fact of the matter is that many markets, particularly financial markets, are most integrated than they have ever been. This is good for spreading risk around, and it helps produce more efficient investment outcomes. And, if some developing country gets into trouble, it is both easier for them to get back on their feet and for investors in that country to not go bankrupt in the fall-out.

But this whole system still revolves around the U.S. It may be true that the world somewhat less dependent on the U.S. than they were in the 1990s (although this is arguable), but it is not true that the world isn't still dependent on the U.S. At this point, "decoupling" is something of a myth. In the future, it will probably become reality, but not in the sense that most people mean it. It won't mean that individual economies will be less susceptible to major movements in major companies; rather, it will likely that the relative importance of the U.S. over all others declines somewhat. The absolute importance of the U.S. will remain for a long, long time.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, January 28, 2008

John Maynard Keynes' Sex Diaries

Bill Blacker Than Barack?

So says Andrew Young, Clinton friend and former ambassador to the U.N.:

This week, while making the remarkable accusation that the Obama camp was responsible for raising the race issue, Mr. Clinton mentioned Andrew Young as someone who would bear that out. It was an extremely unfortunate reference.

Here’s what Mr. Young, who is black and a former ambassador to the United Nations, had to say last month in an interview posted online: “Bill is every bit as black as Barack. He’s probably gone with more black women than Barack.”

He then went on to make disgusting comments about the way that Bill and Hillary Clinton defended themselves years ago against the fallout from the former president’s womanizing. That’s coming from the Clinton camp!

Wow. Just... wow.

Labels: ,

The Incompetence of the C.I.A.

Following 9/11, Bush instructed the C.I.A. to develop an interrogation program. The trouble?

But the program that developed within the Central Intelligence Agency after 9/11 has left the intelligence community playing a fateful role. Surprising as it may be, the CIA has never really been in the interrogation business. After 9/11, it turned its back on its own limited history of interrogations and never consulted those in the U.S. with solid experience in that difficult art. Even in the seven years since it has built an interrogation capability mostly from scratch, the agency has never applied the best practices in behavioral science to improve its regimen. The result has been to privilege brutality out of ignorance, which, according to many experts and insiders interviewed, means that interrogation practices that produce faulty information are now at the very heart of the U.S. efforts against a mysterious and still-unfamiliar enemy.

In short, despite innumerable statements from the Bush administration about the value of the CIA’s interrogation program, U.S. interrogators are still mostly in the dark—in the dark not only about al-Qaeda, but about how to effectively elicit vital national-security information from the detainees in its custody.

Those with intimate knowledge of the program say that in many cases, U.S. interrogators haven’t even been able to learn the basics about many of those they hold or have held, to say nothing of whatever crucial information they possess. "How do you separate the sheep from the wool? There’s no fingerprints, no DNA," said a former senior intelligence official who helped set up the CIA’s interrogation program, and who would not speak for attribution. "You don’t know if you have Osama bin Laden or Joe Shit the rag-man."

Worse than a crime, to paraphrase Tallyrand, interrogation by the CIA has been—and remains—a blunder.

But it didn't have to be this way:

Despite having nearly no off-the-shelf experience, the CIA was tasked by President Bush to come up with a robust interrogation program for the most important al-Qaeda captives. So the agency turned to its partners for assistance in designing its interrogation regimen: Israel, Egypt, Saudi Arabia—all countries cited by the State Department for using torture—among others. Additionally, as Mark Benjamin has reported for Salon, two psychologists named Bruce Jessen and James Mitchell, who worked as contractors for CIA, helped the agency "reverse-engineer" the military and CIA training on resisting torture for use on detainees. Suddenly, waterboarding, an illegal practice of simulating or in some cases inducing drowning, became an American-administered practice.

Interestingly, one place that the CIA didn’t look for help was the place where interrogations have been performed, lawfully, for decades: the Federal Bureau of Investigation. "In terms of actual interrogations, when you have a suspect in custody, the FBI does that hundreds of times a day, 365 days a year, for 90 years," said Mike Rolince, who spent over three years as Special Agent in Charge of counterterrorism at the FBI’s Washington field office before retiring in October 2005. "The FBI brought serious credibility and a track record to the table. That said, the U.S. government decided to go about [interrogations] in a different way. The results speak for themselves. I don’t think we need to be where we are."

The entire article, by Spencer Ackerman, is well worth reading. The incompetence and mendacity of Bush in this area is a national shame, and all of future history will scorn us.

Labels: ,

"The Greatest Betrayal"

And what is this betrayal? Well, according to the N.Y. chapter of N.O.W., the "greatest betrayal" came when Teddy Kennedy endorsed Obama over Clinton. And the ladies are upset:

“Women have just experienced the ultimate betrayal. Senator Kennedy’s endorsement of Hillary Clinton’s opponent in the Democratic presidential primary campaign has really hit women hard. Women have forgiven Kennedy, stuck up for him, stood by him, hushed the fact that he was late in his support of Title IX, the ERA, the Family Leave and Medical Act to name a few. Women have buried their anger that his support for the compromises in No Child Left Behind and the Medicare bogus drug benefit brought us the passage of these flawed bills. We have thanked him for his ardent support of many civil rights bills, BUT women are always waiting in the wings.

“And now the greatest betrayal! ...

“This latest move by Kennedy, is so telling about the status of and respect for women’s rights, women’s voices, women’s equality, women’s authority and our ability – indeed, our obligation - to promote and earn and deserve and elect, unabashedly, a President that is the first woman after centuries of men who ‘know what’s best for us.’”
Wow.

UPDATE: Slate.com's XX blog is similarly miffed:

So, that's it—an endorsement of any candidate but Hillary is a betrayal of the feminist cause? I suppose the more sophisticated version is that interest groups expect the politicians they support to support them blindly in their time of need. This is their time of need, the NY NOW chapter argues, ergo, Kennedy should be with them. But that assumes that the feminist time of need equates with electing Hillary. Would most women, or even most feminists, agree with that? I just can't. And what does this narrow-cast way of evaluating a candidate really have to recommend it? I can't think of anything on that score, either. Can some other women's group please speak up to say that if Kennedy has good reason to think that Obama would be the best president for the country, and a damn fine president for women, then supporting him is A-OK with them?


(ht: Andrew Sullivan)

Labels: ,

Sunday, January 27, 2008

Another Glimpse into Chavez's Fantasy World

Hugo Chavez says that Latin American countries should pull their currency reserves from the U.S., and has established a brand new bank to house the relocated cash.

Because, you know, Latin America never has currency crises or anything, and Chavez has never manipulated his own currency in order to combat runaway inflation due to his misguided price controls.

Nope. The U.S. is an unsafe, unprofitable place for investors, which is probably why the U.S. receives more FDI than any other country in the world every year.

Labels: , , ,

Reevaluating Huntington's 'Clash'

An interesting article looking back at Samuel Huntington's famous thesis that the post-Cold War world would not finally be dominated by moderating, liberal globalizing forces, but by a "clash of civilizations". The conclusion:

More ominously perhaps, there ran through Huntington’s pages an anxiety about the will and the coherence of the West — openly stated at times, made by allusions throughout. The ramparts of the West are not carefully monitored and defended, Huntington feared. Islam will remain Islam, he worried, but it is “dubious” whether the West will remain true to itself and its mission. Clearly, commerce has not delivered us out of history’s passions, the World Wide Web has not cast aside blood and kin and faith. It is no fault of Samuel Huntington’s that we have not heeded his darker, and possibly truer, vision.
Even if all this is true, there are still some problems with Huntington's narrative: even if Muslim countries have unified under the banner of Islam (and this is certainly disputable, given the fractures within the Muslim world), that is but one of Huntington's eight civilizations. In most of the rest of the world, especially East Asia, Eastern Europe, and Africa, the trend is still towards integration and moderation. The spirit of globalization may have tempered some since 9/11, but it is still strong. Some of its principles may have been reformed, but the underlying realities haven't changed much. The view that the rules have significantly changed is indicative of a Western-centric (or Islam-centric) worldview, and ignores the situation in much of the rest of the world.

Labels: ,

Libertarianism as Anti-Conservatism

Will Wilkinson dismantles some typical groupthink from conservatives:

Benjamin Storey & Jenna Silber Storey: “The moral vacuity of dogmatic libertarianism is poisonous to public life.” Translation:

Libertarianism is dangerous because it discourages juvenile romantic attachment to higher things — meaningful things – like Honor, Virtue, and the indescribable joy of sacrificing one’s life to the service of the American Volksreich. All libertarians care about is superficial shit like not starving, living a long time, and being creative and happy. Blah blah blah. But, really, what’s the point of living to 200 if all you do is enjoy yourself the whole time? I mean, don‘t you want to know what it is like to kill a man? DON’T YOU WANT TO TASTE BLOOD!? Besides, virtue.

Vote John McCain.

Oh, goodness that’s not fair! But, really, that whole thing is just as embarrassing as misspelling ‘Friedman’. I am more and more coming to the conclusion that National Greatness Conservatism, like all quasi-fascist movements, is based on a weird romantic teenager’s fantasies about what it means to be a grown up. The fundamental moral decency of liberal individualism seems, to the unserious mind that thinks itself serious, completely insipid next to very exciting big boy ideas about shared struggle, sacrifice, duty, glory, virtue, and (most of all) power. And reading Aristotle in Greek.

I sometimes think that liberal individualism is something like the intellectual and moral equivalent of the best modernist design — spare, elegant, functional — but hard to grasp or truly appreciate without a cultivated sense of style, without a little discerning maturity. National Greatness Conservatism is like a grotesque wood-paneled den stuffed with animal heads, mounted swords, garish carpets, and a giant roaring fire. Only the most vulgar tuck in next to that fire, light a fat cigar, and think they’ve really got it all figured out. But I’m afraid that’s pretty much the kind of thing you get at the Committee for Social Thought. If you declaim the importance of virtue loudly enough, you don’t have to actually think.



I find his last paragraph to be entirely correct.

Labels: , ,

Saturday, January 19, 2008

The Civil War in Four Minutes




This is pretty neat. For some reason, I didn't realize that the South had been cut nearly in almost right away, and that by the end of 1864 they were split into three sections. Even given the utter incompetence of nearly all Union generals but Sherman and Grant, and the favorable terrain in the Mid-Southern states like Tennessee, the South really had no chance at all. The North moved into their territory right away, and were never pushed back.

Labels:

Friday, January 18, 2008

Cowen, Rodrik, and Harford on Trade and Ethics

More reaction to Landsberg's article on why we shouldn't compensate "losers" from trade.

First, Harford:

...people lose their jobs all the time for reasons that have nothing to do with foreign trade. I'd argue that they deserve some help. Why are jobs lost to foreign competition so privileged?
Bingo. I would further this by saying that we already have many protections in place for all displaced workers -- such as unemployment benefits, subsidized education, etc. -- that extends to those workers displaced by trade. Why should those who lose their jobs to trade, as opposed to any other source, get more than that? The most likely answer seems to be: political nationalism. But that seems to be an inappropriate response to the question.

Then Rodrik:

The question of how we should respond to a trade-induced change in income distribution is not one on which economists can offer any expertise. This is a question about ethics, values, and norms, none of which is part of an economist's training. Landsburg's take on this is as good as mine--which is as good as that of any person on the street.
Cowen reacts fairly strongly in the negative to this view:

Every now and then I feel a deep responsibility to rebut an argument. In my view anyone doing policy economics has an obligation to learn more about ethics -- much more -- than the guy in the street would know. Would someone doing experimental economics feel free of the obligation to learn some empirical psychology? Would someone doing trade feel free of the obligation to learn some trade law, some history, and some political science? No. What's the difference? Economists like to separate the "positive" and "normative" aspects of what they do, but this distinction has not much impressed the moral philosophers who have looked at it nor has it impressed Amartya Sen. The very decision to use economic tools emphasizes some considerations and excludes others. The final policy analysis is not just pure prediction but rather it is also an implicit presentation and weighting of both different kinds of information and different values. So if you are doing policy economics, it is imperative that you think about ethics at a very deep level, and read widely in ethics. You are doing ethics whether you like it or not! Furthermore I don't doubt that Dani already has a deeper understanding of ethics than the (often very crude) man in the street.

That said, I don't agree with the ethics Dani does discuss, noting that he must have felt he had some good reason to put forward the concerns he did and not others. (As a rule of thumb I'll note that those who profess the impassability of ethical terrain have just in fact traversed it.) I don't worry much about the procedural fairness if a poor country trades at better prices by paying its labor less or by polluting. Low wages are precisely the wages we want to see bid up, and if there is a concern for the losers I would not call the issue a procedural one but rather one of outcomes. And pollution can be a moral crime but attacking trade is not usually a good way to go after it. Tax the pollution, not the trade.

Right. I have had many arguments with professors on this topic. Many economists like to believe that their studies are value-free; that they are scientists, and not philosophers. To an extent that is true, but the assumptions underlying all economic study requires an ethical underpinning. Economists often talk about "best" and "second-best" policies, or "perfect-world" scenarios; but what are these if not ethical judgments? The entire study of economics, as we are taught on day one of Econ 101, is the study of how people and nations make choices given the inherent scarcity of resources. In other words, how we choose between different options. For policy-makers, especially on the macro level, this is truly an ethical concern.

The hottest economic topics these days -- bailouts for defaulting homeowners, tax cuts/redistribution, income inequality, international trade -- are all ethical topics first and foremost. Economists would rather not face this fact, because to do would require more work on their part. Justifying their models and assumptions in an ethical framework is no simple matter, so economists just assume those ethical concerns away. This is not right, it is not proper, and it is detrimental to the causes that economists seek to further, since those who share different ethical beliefs may simply reject the conclusions of economists on ethical grounds (esp. on trade, where environmental, cultural, and labor standards are given so much weight). Since economists generally refuse to argue on those terms, the argument is lost to them before it even begins.

This shouldn't happen. Economists should have much to say on the topic; it's just a shame that they generally refuse to join the argument.

Labels: , , ,

Economics: No Longer the 'Dismal Science'

Alex Tabarrok is optimistic about the future:

People used to think that more population was bad for growth. In this view, people are stomachs--they eat, leaving less for everyone else. But once we realize the importance of ideas in the economy, people become brains--they innovate, creating more for everyone else.

New ideas mean more growth, and even small changes in economic growth rates produce large economic and social benefits. At current income levels, with an inflation-adjusted growth rate of 3% per year, America's real per capita gross domestic product would exceed $1 million per year in just over 100 years, more than 22 times higher than it is today. Growth like that could solve many problems.

In the 20th century, two world wars diverted the energy of two generations from production to destruction. When the horrors ended, the world was left hobbled and split. Communism isolated much of the world, reducing trade in goods and ideas--to everyone's detriment. World poverty meant that the U.S. and a few other countries shouldered the burdens of advancing knowledge nearly alone.

The battles of the 20th century were not fought in vain. Trade, development and the free flow of people and ideas are uniting all of humanity, maximizing the incentives and the means to produce new ideas. This gives us reason to be highly optimistic about the future.

Of course, Tabarrok is a libertarian, and libertarians are born optimists w/r/t the potential of mankind. It is still true that we don't understand very well how development occurs, or how to maximize growth across the board. China and India are growing very fast, but it isn't without side effects. Still, the overall trajectory of the world in the 21st century is better -- so far -- than the trajectory of the 20th. There are good reasons for optimism.

Labels: , , ,

Preach It, Brother

Ezra Levant, a Canadian publisher, explains to the Canadian government that he doesn't have to explain to the Canadian government why he decided to reprint the Danish Muhammed cartoons.

The "Canadian Human Rights Commission" doesn't seem to understand.

Labels:

Thursday, January 17, 2008

Canada Puts the U.S. on Its Terror Watch List

No joke. All those tortures really add up quick, don't they?

UPDATE: Erm, not "Terror Watch List," but "Torture Watch List". My mistake. But honestly, torture is a form of terrorism, especially when it is being done to foreign nationals.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

U.S. Wealth in a Global Context

A map re-naming U.S. as existing countries, according to equivalent GDPs. My state has the same GDP as Mexico. Texas has the same as Canada. California has the same as France. It's a pretty amazing map.

ht: EconLog

Labels:

Should winners from trade compensate the losers?

Steven Landsburg says no.

I agree with him in principle, but I still think that publicly-funded education and re-education programs are worth it. There are strong reasons for believing that these programs provide a positive social surplus and can lead to strong productivity growth.

But the idea that winners from trade should directly compensate losers has no basis in economic theory. We should encourage education and training for its own sake; not because of some utilitarian ethical concern.

UPDATE: Dani Rodrik kind of disagrees:

Similarly, what is at issue in globalization debates is the procedural fairness of some types of outsourcing. Trade is controversial because it involves exchanges of the type we routinely block at home (e.g., exchanges that involve unfair labor or environmentally harmful practices). This often makes trade look different from other instances of redistribution.
There's some trouble here. First of all, which is more unfair: allowing imports of products from countries with different labor standards than the U.S., or requiring every other nation in the world to adopt the exact same standards as the U.S. as a prerequisite for trading with us?

Second is the double standard, whereby we refuse to allow people to sell us their goods because we disapprove of the lax standards of production, but we gladly sell our goods to the same people regardless of those standards and without a second thought.

By some European standards (say, France), American labor protections are incredibly lax. Yet how would we respond if they started putting tariffs on American exports because our labor standards are "unfair"? We would respond with outrage and incredulity, and we would be right to do so. We should expect nothing less from other countries.

If we choose to trade off economic freedom and efficiency in exchange for tighter labor standards, that is our right. But we cannot pretend that the balance we have found is the perfect one for all countries and regions. States and individuals should be free to decide these matters on their own. Anything less is what would actually be "unfair". After all, it's not as if we don't have the option, as consumers, to not purchase goods made under laxer policies than our own. Forcing foreign nations to abide by standards that we have created and modified over time, and preventing Americans from exercising their own economic freedom as consumers, is not a more "fair" system for anyone.

Now, obviously, Rodrik would not advocate for protectionism outright. And yet, when he and others maintain that we should require labor and environmental standards be negotiated into trade contracts, and that we should subsidize (i.e. "protect") American jobs through government intervention, he is really advocating a type of non-tariff trade protectionism in disguise.

Labels: ,

Bad Headline

Here's the headline: "Inflation jumps in 2007".

Here's the beginning of the article: "Higher costs for energy and food last year pushed inflation up by the largest amount in 17 years, even though prices generally remained tame outside of those two areas."

Yes, that's right. The first sentence contradicts the headline. You have to make it to the end of the article to get the appropriate context:

Outside of food and energy, inflation rose a more moderate 0.2 percent in December. This measure of core inflation rose by 2.4 percent for all of 2007, down slightly from a 2.6 percent increase in 2006.

The Federal Reserve is closely watching to see whether the jump in food and energy becomes more widespread and starts pushing core inflation higher.

Analysts said that with core prices generally remaining well-behaved, it will give the central bank the leeway to cut interest rates further to battle a serious economic slowdown triggered by a steep slump in housing and a spreading credit crisis. ...

Energy costs rose by 17.4 percent this past year while food costs rose by 4.9 percent. Both were the biggest increases since 1990. Gasoline prices were up 29.6 percent, the biggest increase since they soared by 30.1 percent in 1999.

The 2.4 percent rise in prices outside of food and energy was the smallest since a 2.2 percent rise in 2005.



The Fed looks at core inflation independent of food and energy costs because food and energy costs are much more volatile than the rest of the economy for reasons which have nothing to do with economic stability. A hurricane in the Gulf of Mexico, for example, might cause oil and food prices to rise but everything else in the economy to stay relatively the same. The Fed shouldn't be looking at weather forecasts when setting monetary policy.

Additionally, energy prices are highly sensitive to oil prices which are set globally, not nationally. Also, some rise in energy and food prices will affect core inflation, since energy and food are inputs to other goods, and can replace other types of consumption and investment spending.

All in all, I look at this and see good news: core inflation was lower in 2007 than it was in 2006. This should give the Fed some flexibility in combating the financial meltdown which is still deepening.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

Obama and Farrakhan

So, Roger Cohen noticed that Obama's pastor's magazine gave Louis Farrakhan an award, and he recoiled:

The Obama camp takes the view that its candidate, now that he has been told about the award, is under no obligation to speak out on the Farrakhan matter. It was not Obama's church that made the award but a magazine. This is a distinction without much of a difference. And given who the parishioner is, the obligation to speak out is all the greater. He could be the next American president. Where is his sense of outrage?
Henry Farell at Crooked Timber disagrees, and intimates that Cohen is holding Obama to a different standard because of his race:

There’s something else going on here. I strongly suspect that Barack Obama is being asked to condemn Louis Farrakhan not because there’s some bogus two-degrees-of-separation thing going on, but because Barack Obama is black, and because black politicians are supposed to condemn Louis Farrakhan before they can be trusted. This isn’t racism, but it’s an implicit double standard, under which black politicians have a higher hurdle to jump before they deserve public trust than white ones. More generally, this is a bad, wrongheaded, and even dangerous article. Richard Cohen shouldn’t have written it, and the Washington Post shouldn’t have printed it.

Fontana Labs at Unfogged agrees with Farrell:

Oh yes. Underneath this is the "show us you're one of the good ones!" demand that Obama has to meet in order to demonstrate that he's palatable to annoying white people like Cohen. Fuck a bunch of that, I say, but Obama cannot-- though it would be richly satisfying to hear him do it.
I really couldn't disagree more. It is perfectly fine for people to question Mitt Romney about the bizarre views of Mormons, including the fact that they were an officially a racist organization until the 1970s, as Christopher Hitchens has done. It is right and proper to ask Romney to denounce this past racism, and give an explanation for his participation in it. Similarly, it is perfectly appropriate to ask Obama why he patrons a church whose leader -- Jeremiah Wright -- offered an award to a demagogue such as Farrakhan, especially in the context of Wright's teachings in black liberation theology. It is fine to ask Obama to comment on this fact, and I would hope that he would respond by denouncing Farrakhan.

I don't see it as a function of Obama's race. One's of Obama's closest associates, from whom he got the title for The Audacity of Hope, on some level admires a racist and espouses a bizarre, conspiratorial religion. It is perfectly appropriate to ask Obama to clarify his views on this topic.

UPDATE: Obama did repudiate Farrakhan in the debate last night. Issue closed.

Labels: ,

Tom Cruise is Crazy

WaPo Does Something Right

A nice, brief article explaining why the notion of "energy independence" is such a canard. These are mostly economic arguments, but there's a healthy dose of pragmatism as well.

I wish that the GOP presidential would pick up on this, and stop citing "energy independence" as a major goal. Even if it were possible, these claims ring hollow because of the nature of the Republican party, its historical ties to oil-exporting nations (e.g. the Bush family's relationship with the Saudi royals), the meddling of the U.S. into affairs of oil-exporting nations in the last three GOP presidents (Reagan in Iran/Lebanon, H.W. Bush in Iraq/Kuwait, W. Bush in Iraq/etc.).

But it won't happen, because "energy independence" has become a useful tool for Republican politicians to instill fear into their constituents. That theme is practically a constant now, as most major GOP politicians fear-monger over immigration, the inability of many voters to differentiate between Muslims (e.g. Sunni/Shiite, Islamists/modernists, democrats/dictators, etc.), gays, etc.

The history of this stuff in the GOP has a long and deep history (especially since the end of WWII) from McCarthyism to AIDS scares to the "bomb all the brown people back into the Stone Age" attitude of many GOP constituents after 9/11.

The fact is that we are deeply and irrevocably tied to the rest of the world, and the sooner we acknowledge that fact and try to make the most of it, the better we'll be. I don't know if the GOP is capable of leading the country in this area anymore.

Well, maybe McCain can. Maybe.

Labels: , ,

Monday, January 14, 2008

Lessons from Singapore

Bryan Caplan has evidently been reading up on Singaporean government policies. He has two posts in favor of two Singaporean policies: health care and unemployment. First, health care:

If the following is true, all the comparisons showing that the U.S. greatly outspends Europe without getting better health are beside the point, because Singapore makes Europe look like the U.S.:
The Singapore government spent only 1.3 percent of GDP on healthcare in 2002, whereas the combined public and private expenditure on healthcare amounted to a low 4.3 percent of GDP. By contrast, the United States spent 14.6 percent of its GDP on healthcare that year, up from 7 percent in 1970... Yet, indicators such as infant mortality rates or years of average healthy life expectancy are slightly more favorable in Singapore than in the United States... It is true that such indicators are also related to the overall living environment and not only to healthcare spending. Nonetheless, international experts rank Singapore's healthcare system among the most successful in the world in terms of cost-effectiveness and community health results.
How does Singapore do it? ...

More details on how Singapore's system works:

  • There are mandatory health savings accounts: "Individuals pre-save for medical expenses through mandatory deductions from their paychecks and employer contributions... Only approved categories of medical treatment can be paid for by deducting one's Medisave account, for oneself, grandparents, parents, spouse or children: consultations with private practitioners for minor ailments must be paid from out-of-pocket cash..."
  • "The private healthcare system competes with the public healthcare, which helps contain prices in both directions. Private medical insurance is also available."
  • Private healthcare providers are required to publish price lists to encourage comparison shopping.
  • The government pays for "basic healthcare services... subject to tight expenditure control." Bottom line: The government pays 80% of "basic public healthcare services."
  • Government plays a big role with contagious disease, and adds some paternalism on top: "Preventing diseases such as HIV/AIDS, malaria, and tobacco-related illnesses by ensuring good health conditions takes a high priority."
  • The government provides optional low-cost catatrophic health insurance, plus a safety net "subject to stringent means-testing."


This doesn't sound too far off from the "Jane Galt" health care plan, which I generally support, although Singapore's plan is more detailed. But Caplan also likes Singapore's mechanism for fighting unemployment:

Imagine my surprise, then, when I discovered that Singapore has figured out a stunningly clever way to use tax cuts to reduce unemployment. Instead of focusing on stimulating demand, Singaporean tax policy hits the margin that matters: labor costs. When there is a surplus of labor, they cut employers' share of the payroll tax (known in Singapore as the CPF). Details appear in Henri Ghesquirre, Singapore's Success:
The government directly intervened to temporarily lower the cost of business in Singapore through... its power to lower the CPF contribution rate of employers...

Elsewhere, substantial nominal currency devaluation is often the last and only resort in the face of downwardly sticky nominal wages, often with higher inflation as an undesirable side effect. In contrast, Singapore uses the direct intervention methods at its disposal. In addition, there is built-in wage flexibility, because an important portion of workers' remuneration is automatically lowered if GDP falls short of target.

With flexible wages, of course, it doesn't matter who legally pays the a tax. But the whole problem with recessions is that wages are somewhat sticky - you can have surplus labor for years before wages fall enough to restore full employment. By cutting employers' share of the tax, the Singaporeans greatly speed up the wage adjustment process.
Caplan asks whether such a system for correcting unemployment would be successful in the United States. I don't think it would be, for the simple reason that our government is much more democratic that Singapore's. In the U.S., populists would likely oppose lower corporate taxes in lean periods even if the positive effects were strongly felt by workers. Economic conservatives would oppose raising corporate tax rates in boom periods. The advantage of this plan is its flexibility, which can be taken advantage of by an authoritarian government but not by a democratic one. The proper policies would likely not be enacted at the appropriate times, so the system would break down.

This is a shame.

Labels: ,

Saturday, January 12, 2008

Krugman's pessimism

Megan McArdle points us to QandO, where we find that Paul Krugman has predicted a recession in every single year since Bush came to office (except 2001, Bush's first year, presumably because he hadn't had time to do anything yet):

Like Megan, I think "a recession seems likely-ish", but "Krugman predicts" is generally a good sign to bet the other way.

  • "[R]ight now it looks as if the economy is stalling..." — Paul Krugman, September 2002

  • "We have a sluggish economy, which is, for all practical purposes, in recession..." — Paul Krugman, May 2003

  • "An oil-driven recession does not look at all far-fetched." — Paul Krugman, May 2004

  • "[A] mild form of stagflation - rising inflation in an economy still well short of full employment - has already arrived." — Paul Krugman, April 2005

  • "If housing prices actually started falling, we'd be looking at [an economy pushed] right back into recession. That's why it's so ominous to see signs that America's housing market ... is approaching the final, feverish stages of a speculative bubble." — Paul Krugman, May 2005

  • "In fact, a growing number of economists are using the "R" word [i.e., "recession"] for 2006." - Paul Krugman, August 2005

  • "But based on what we know now, there’s an economic slowdown coming." - Paul Krugman, August 2006

  • "this kind of confusion about what’s going on is what typically happens when the economy is at a turning point, when an economic expansion is about to turn into a recession" - Paul Krugman, December 2006

  • "Right now, statistical models ... give roughly even odds that we’re about to experience a formal recession. ... [T]he odds are very good — maybe 2 to 1 — that 2007 will be a very tough year." - Paul Krugman, December 2006

Atrios, Huffington Post, Media Matters/Eric Boehlert, The Daily Show's Jon Stewart and Glenn Greenwald are constantly telling me things like how "it's worth taking note of just how constantly wrong all of our Most Serious Political Analysts are" (Glenn Greenwald, again) and how there should be some sort of consequence for that sort of relentless wrongness. Doesn't seem to apply to their own, though.


Krugman's latest column? He predicts a pretty horrible recession which the Fed is powerless to control or stop.

I think the likelihood of a recession is pretty strong. But I don't expect it to be especially long or especially deep. Still, the fact that Krugman is now predicting one for '08 gives me pause, and reminds me of Lewis Black's joke:

"President Bush now says that he believes in global warming. As a result, I'm no longer sure."

Labels: ,

Friday, January 11, 2008

Fair Fight

Brad DeLong absolutely dismantles the "fair tax" proposed by Mike Huckabee:

From another perspective, however, you have to scorn Huckabee. He is adding yet more layers of confusion to America's conversation about taxes. Huckabee says that the FairTax would mean a 23 percent sales tax rate on all items. First of all, the real tax rate proposed is 30 percent. The FairTax would add 30 cents to every dollar spent, but since 30 cents is 23 percent of $1.30, the FairTaxers call the rate 23 percent.

Second, and more important, both conservative and liberal economists believe the real rate would end up even higher. Estimates of the actual rate of taxation required for the FairTax to be "revenue neutral" (meaning for it to bring in exactly the same amount of revenue that the federal government collects under the current system) start at 30 percent and keep climbing. William Gale of the liberal Brookings Institution think tank says it's a de facto 44 percent sales tax. Calculations go still higher once you add in all the necessary and politically inevitable exemptions on big-ticket items -- like a new home or hospital care. Congress' Joint Committee on Taxation, which draws members from both parties and both houses, says the real rate would be 57 percent. (And this leaves aside the enormous federal outlay required by the "prebates," which even FairTax advocates say would cost the government $485 billion per year.)

... it's a mammoth tax cut for the crowd making more than $200,000 a year and a substantial tax increase for those making between $30,000 and $200,000 a year. Does this make economic sense? It is hard to see how: What makes the $200,000-plus crowd especially deserving of a tax cut? This is part of a pattern with Huckabee. Anxious to distinguish himself on policies from his competitors but without the staff and the network to perform due diligence on policy proposals, he ends up with ideas that aren't fully worked out and don't make much substantive policy sense.

... Governor Huckabee promises that this plan would be "like waving a magic wand, releasing us from pain and unfairness."

... Is Huckabee's FairTax smoke and mirrors? Yes. Is it voodoo economics? Yes.



But Arnold Kling asks for a more nuanced perspective:

Our current tax system takes its biggest bite out of people who earn much more than they consume. Because the Fair Tax (or any consumption tax) would abstain from tapping this rich vein of unspent earned income, it would taking larger bites out of others to obtain the same revenue.

Consumption taxes reduce tax rates drastically on people who earn more than they consume. To be revenue neutral, they have to increase taxes drastically on people who consume more of what they earn. Whether this is a bug or a feature of consumption taxes is more debatable than Brad lets on.

I'm (mostly) with DeLong. If I were starting a system from scratch, I might consider a national sales tax, although I'd prefer a broad-based value-added tax instead. But considering the system we have now, trying to convert to such a system would be disastrous. Additionally, the main selling points of the "fair tax" -- it would simplify the system and lead to a lower overall tax burden -- simply appear not to be true. Additionally, I do believe in a weak utilitarian framework for setting certain aspects of social policy, and that would dictate a progressive tax scheme. Adding that in to a system of national sales taxation would be very difficult.

DeLong is also correct about Huckabee's intellectual capabilities: they are small. He is proposing this plan without fully understanding the consequences of it or the costs of implementing it.

Labels: , ,

Politics as Cult

Arnold Kling says the Ron Paul movement strongly resembles a cult-movement. In some way (tho certainly not all) I agree.

He also says that all mass political movements are cult-ish. I disagreed with him at first, but the more I think about it the more convinced I become.

Labels:

Mac Attack

The Economist examines McCain's policy proposals and finds them wanting.

Still, McCain is beginning to emerge as my preferred GOP candidate. I could live with Thompson or Romney also, but Thompson doesn't seem to have a chance and Romney would get creamed in a general election. So, McCain is starting to look like the best GOP candidate. I would be very happy with a McCain vs. Obama election (and I would hope for Obama to win).

Thursday, January 10, 2008

The Economic Future of America

In the newest issue of The Atlantic, Megan McArdle looks into her crystal ball to examine what will happen when the baby boomers have all retired. Specifically, she is concerned with how we are going to pay for our Social Security and Medicare obligations to them. She is cautiously optimistic. Well recommended.

As a companion, McArdle participated in a roundtable discussion with Clive Crook and Philip Longman which may be found here. On her blog, McArdle responds to some general criticisms of her piece here.

I am taking some flak, as expected, for the optimism of my piece on the baby boomers. How can I be so darn cheery when we've got $55 trillion in unfunded obligations coming down the pike?

Well, the point of the piece was to stop focusing so much on cash figures. All government spending numbers are impressively large--that's what happens when you're dealing with a very rich, very populous nation.

But our entitlement problem is not that our unfunded liabilities have a net present value of $55 trillion. That is a very big number, but we're not going to get handed a bill for it all next week. It's a slice of a much, much bigger figure: the NPV of our future income.

Prices are very, very useful things. But they can often obscure as much as they hide in economic debate: a $20,000 Hermes handbag does not consume 100 times as many economic resources as a $20 Target handbag, and the illusion that it does fuels much of the current debate over redistributing wealth.

The ultimate price tag of Medicare is hazily unknowable, and really, the number does not much matter. And the argument that this spending is "unsustainable" is not particularly interesting; as Herb Stein famously said, "If something cannot go on forever, it will stop." If the spending is really, actually, unsustainable then the government will eventually stop trying to sustain it. These are not the interesting questions.

My (partial) list of the interesting questions:

  1. Is Medicare well structured to provide good health care to the elderly?
  2. Is Medicare encouraging today's workers to save less than they will ultimately need? In other words, is the program likely to be severely curtailed in the future, leaving workers who counted on it worse off than they would have been had it never existed?
  3. Is Medicare encouraging, or discouraging, the medical innovation that could make future generations better off?
  4. What is the deadweight loss of the taxation required to pay for Medicare, and does this represent a good use of our money?
  5. Is this massive transfer from old to young just? Does this answer change if it turns out that future generations are likely to massively trim the program?

My answer is that Medicare is a bad program on many fronts: badly structured, economically and medically destructive, and a fairly injust transfer of resources. But none of those things have anything to do with eye-popping NPV figures. A bad program doesn't become a good program just because it's cheap.

Labels: , ,

Bad News from Beijing

Apparently, inflation in China has become such a concern that the government is ready to take drastic measures:

Prime Minister Wen Jiabao responded Wednesday to growing public anxiety about inflation by announcing that China would freeze energy prices in the near term, even as international crude oil futures have continued to surge.

The new effort to fight rising prices comes with inflation hitting an 11-year high in China. A recent nationwide public opinion survey found that “rising prices of consumer goods” ranked as the top public concern, followed by income inequality and corruption.

The latest freezes, announced on the government’s main Web site, came after Mr. Wen presided over a Wednesday meeting of the State Council to revise policies on price controls.

Prices of oil products, natural gas and electricity will be frozen in the near term. Rates for public water bills will also be frozen, as will the price of public transportation tickets.

The edict also called for stabilizing prices on medical services and for certain agricultural fertilizers. It ordered local governments to monitor prices closely and warned that punishments would be strengthened for those who violate government price-control policies.



To some extent, inflation is a by-product of an economy that is growing too big, too fast. But the fact that the government is resorting to price controls is a bad sign. Either the Chinese government can't control its monetary base, or else it is pursuing a bad policy out of desperation. The Chinese may believe that price controls are a lesser evil than intentionally slowing the rate of economic growth while so many of its citizens still live in abject poverty. But price controls are unsustainable even in the medium-run. At some point something will have to give: either inflation will return, or the economy must slow.

Labels: ,

The Micromagic of Microcredit

The microcredit movement has garnered plenty of attention in recent years, and its founder -- Muhammed Yunus -- was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 2006. The concept is simple: small loans to third-worlders interested in beginning or expanding a small business may be the most effective way to foster economic development in poorer regions. The loans have a track record of repayment in 98% of cases and generally require a very small amount of investment (as low as $20). Some believe that microcredit loans do more for third-world development than charity or government aid since the money goes directly to those who can use it to increase growth. The legend of microcredit is so amazing that it sounds to good to be true.

Karol Boudreaux and Tyler Cowen examine the issue, and find that the commonly told story of microcredit is, in some ways, too good to be true. They find that the institution certainly has a net positive impact, but the results aren't quite so miraculous as proponents sometimes claim.

The achievements of microcredit, however, are not quite what they seem. There is, for example, a puzzling fact at the heart of the enterprise. Most microcredit banks charge interest rates of 50 to 100 percent on an annualized basis (loans, typically, must be paid off within weeks or months). That’s not as scandalous as it ­sounds—­local moneylenders demand much higher rates. The puzzle is a matter of basic economics: How can people in new businesses growing at perhaps 20 percent annually afford to pay interest at rates as high as 100 ­percent?

The answer is that, for the most part, they can’t. By and large, the loans serve more modest ­ends—­laudable, but not world changing.

Microcredit does not always lead to the creation of small businesses. Many micro­lenders refuse to lend money for start-ups; they insist that a business already be in place. This suggests that the business was sustainable to begin with, without a microloan. Sometimes lenders help businesses to grow, but often what they really finance is spending and consumption.

That is not to say that the poor are out shopping for jewelry and fancy clothes. In Hyderabad, India, as in many other places, we saw that loans are often used to pay for a child’s doctor visit. In the Tanzanian capital of Dar es Salaam, Joel Mwakitalu, who runs the Small Enterprise Foundation, a local microlender, told us that 60 percent of his loans are used to send kids to school; 40 percent are for investments. A study of microcredit in Indonesia found that 30 percent of the borrowed money was spent on some form of ­consumption.

Sometimes consumption and investment are one and the same, such as when parents send their children to school. Indian borrowers often buy mopeds and ­motorbikes—they are ­fun to ride but also a way of getting to work. Cell phones are used to call friends but also to run ­businesses.

For better or worse, microborrowing often entails a kind of ­bait ­and ­switch. The borrower claims that the money is for a business, but uses it for other purposes. In effect, the cash allows a poor entrepreneur to maintain her business without having to sacrifice the life or education of her child. In that sense, the money is for the business, but most of all it is for the child. Such ­life­saving uses for the funds are obviously desirable, but it is also a sad reality that many microcredit loans help borrowers to survive or tread water more than they help them get ahead. This sounds unglamorous and even disappointing, but the ­alternative—­such as no doctor’s visit for a child or no school for a ­year—­is much ­worse.

The whole article is not very long, and well worth reading.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, January 9, 2008

Ron Paul's Bigoted Past

A look at Paul's newsletters, which spanned several decades, reveals the ugliness:

But, whoever actually wrote them, the newsletters I saw all had one thing in common: They were published under a banner containing Paul's name, and the articles (except for one special edition of a newsletter that contained the byline of another writer) seem designed to create the impression that they were written by him--and reflected his views. What they reveal are decades worth of obsession with conspiracies, sympathy for the right-wing militia movement, and deeply held bigotry against blacks, Jews, and gays. In short, they suggest that Ron Paul is not the plain-speaking antiwar activist his supporters believe they are backing--but rather a member in good standing of some of the oldest and ugliest traditions in American politics. ...

What's more, Paul's connections to extremism go beyond the newsletters. He has given extensive interviews to the magazine of the John Birch Society, and has frequently been a guest of Alex Jones, a radio host and perhaps the most famous conspiracy theorist in America. Jones--whose recent documentary, Endgame: Blueprint for Global Enslavement, details the plans of George Pataki, David Rockefeller, and Queen Beatrix of the Netherlands, among others, to exterminate most of humanity and develop themselves into "superhuman" computer hybrids able to "travel throughout the cosmos"--estimates that Paul has appeared on his radio program about 40 times over the past twelve years. ...

From his newsletters, however, a different picture of Paul emerges--that of someone who is either himself deeply embittered or, for a long time, allowed others to write bitterly on his behalf. His adversaries are often described in harsh terms: Barbara Jordan is called "Barbara Morondon," Eleanor Holmes Norton is a "black pinko," Donna Shalala is a "short lesbian," Ron Brown is a "racial victimologist," and Roberta Achtenberg, the first openly gay public official confirmed by the United States Senate, is a "far-left, normal-hating lesbian activist." Maybe such outbursts mean Ron Paul really is a straight-talker. Or maybe they just mean he is a man filled with hate.
His defense? Other people wrote them, and they were merely printed under his name. But is that any better?

Labels:

Monday, January 7, 2008

Why We Aren't in a Recession Yet



The graph above, via Krugman, shows the decline in residential housing investment (the blue line) being offset by an increase in the American export sector (red line), both expressed as percentages of GDP.
All the economists who had predicted a recession for this year (including me) could not have predicted the increase in exports which seems to have saved us (so far), because they could not have expected the value of the dollar to drop so heavily this year. Things don't look especially good for the short-term future, but if exports stay strong then any recession which does hit may be shorter and less painful than it otherwise would be.
This also shows us why a return to protectionism would be horrible: it would likely result in the institution of foreign tariffs against our products as retaliation. Since we may end up relying more on exports to sustain the overall economy until the housing market recovers (and employment gets better), this would be disastrous. It would also increase inflation worries, which could keep the Fed's policy tighter, making recovery take longer.

Labels: ,

But Who's Counting?

How many viewers does the brand-spanking-new Fox Business Channel get on a typical weekday?

6,300.

Germany *Hearts* Obama

For some, he's the new JFK:

Germany has developed a serious case of Obama-mania.

Barack Obama’s high standing in Germany goes beyond his opposition to
the unpopular war in Iraq. The country’s sudden crush is bound up with
near-constant comparisons here between the young senator from Illinois and
President John F. Kennedy Jr. – still admired in Germany and particularly in
Berlin.

The Berliner Morgenpost over the weekend ran with the headline, “The New Kennedy.” The tabloid Bild declared, “This Black American has become the new Kennedy!” And the headline
for the editorial in the Frankfurter Rundschau read simply: “Lincoln,
Kennedy, Obama.
”

Labels: ,

Sunday, January 6, 2008

The "Fair Tax"

Mike Huckabee won the Iowa caucus and has gained a lot of national momentum without having to explain much about his proposed economic policies. Many conservatives, such as the Club for Growth and other supply-siders, paint him as a closet economic liberal because tax rates went up during his tenure as Arkansas governor. Huckabee, for his part, has come out in favor of the "fair tax," a nebulous name for a somewhat interesting economic idea. Instead of the "flat" income tax proposed by some conservatives (e.g. Steve Forbes), the "fair tax" proposes to eliminate all income taxes and replace them with a national sales tax, usually assumed to be roughly 23%. The concept is so alien to our current system that many people are confused by it, but Megan McArdle has done a decent enough job summarizing its major tenets, benefits, and flaws:

Leaving aside the moral quandaries inherent in the flat tax--I will blog
about those in another post--here are the specifics: the fair tax is essentially
a 30% sales tax, with a "prebate" mailed to everyone to cover necessities up to
the federal poverty level. Advocates promise that we can eliminate the IRS, that
everyone will get to keep 100% of their paycheck, and that angels will descend
from heaven singing "Hallelujah" the moment it is passed.


The proposal's technical merits are as follows:


Compliance is considerably easier to get from companies than it is from individuals; overall, I would expect the level of tax compliance to rise slightly under this scheme.

Consumption taxes are generally agreed to be economically preferable to flat income taxes, because they encourage savings and investment.

It ends the enormous amount of time that Americans spend trying to figure out their taxes.


It involves radical tax simplification, an idea that would be endorsed by virtually every economist as an improvement over the current system.

The prebate simplifies welfare policy by eliminating the means-testing component.

The downsides:

It's unlikely to raise as much revenue as claimed

Because the tax is not calculated separately, but included in the price, it would be to some extent less transparent than the income tax

It will end up being quite regressive, with the highest effective burden falling on the lower tiers of the middle class.


After eliminating the IRS, you're going to have to create a new, very
large government bureaucracy to manage distribution of the "prebate". Also, now
every American citizen will have to immediately register any change in address
with the Federal government

This will not stop politicians from playing
games with the tax code; stand by for long campaign arguments over increasing
the prebate.

[In short] It's not the worst possible tax policy, but it's certainly not
the best one either.



She is more optimistic than I am, and so I link to Bruce Bartlett, who has written an excellent article describing the trouble with the "fair tax". It should be read by everyone who is interested in the idea. Note: this will never get done, if only because it is regressive and a lot of the most negative effects will be felt by retirees (who get a lot of their "income" by drawing down savings which have already been taxed as income) and larger, lower middle class working families. These groups are very strong lobbies, and will never allow it to happen.

Labels: ,