Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Pax Corleone

Three schools of thought in international relations explained... by the Corleone brothers. Entertaining, yet smart.

Labels: ,

Saturday, May 24, 2008

Wise Words from Peter Thiel

He says (via Marginal Revolution):

...there is no good scenario for the world in which China fails.

Labels: , ,

Monday, May 5, 2008

Why American Health Care Is So Expensive

Slate.com reports that it isn't the fault of the insurance companies or health care providersd; rather, it's our fault:

The debate about health care tends to be informed by three notions about health insurance:

The profits of private insurers are so big that cutting them out would meaningfully lower costs.
Private insurance clearly costs more than a government-run system such as Medicare.
Mergers that have created a small number of huge and powerful insurers increase health care costs.
None of these is true.

Myth No. 1: Insurers' profits are responsible for our health care costs.

This is the most pervasive and most crowd-pleasing of the health care myths. The profits of the big health insurance companies are central to the rhetoric of the health care debate, figuring heavily in the Democratic primary campaign. Barack Obama's platform includes a promise to force insurers to spend enough on care "instead of keeping exorbitant amounts for profits and administration." Michael Moore, the director of Sicko, has hammered the point repeatedly, thundering about how insurers maximize profits by "providing as little care as possible."

The problem here is that between them the five biggest health insurers—UnitedHealthCare, Wellpoint, Aetna, Humana, and Cigna—which cover 105 million members, last year had profits between them of $11.8 billion. This is not a small number; these are very profitable companies. But total U.S. health care costs last year were in the area of $2.3 trillion.

So, with a membership that included a little more than half of the Americans covered by private insurance, these five insurers' profits came to 0.5 percent of total health care costs. (One interesting point of comparison: In 2006, the income earned by the 50 biggest nonprofit hospitals alone came out at $4 billion.)

Critics also argue that insurance companies pass along excessive administrative costs to their customers. Wellpoint, for instance, spends 18 percent of the premiums it takes in on sales and administrative costs. That represents a real concern but merely raises the next question: Can a government-run program that cuts out insurers do it for less?

...

Diagnosis

Patient, heal thyself. It's not insurers that push expensive drugs, long-shot end-of-life treatments, and redundant procedures. It's customers who ask for them. And mainly doctors and hospitals who profit. How to deal with those issues is a question that will affect the health care bottom line more than whether it's the government or private companies that provide insurance. Too bad it's one we have hardly even started to answer.


I wonder if Michael Moore is ready to lose his (free) lunch?

Labels: , ,

The Subprime Crisis Explained

Oh, and it's hilarious:


Labels: , ,

Gas Taxes, Meet Econ 101

McCain and Clinton want a summer cessation of the gas tax. Obama says that it is political pandering and won't help people who are hurting at the pump.

Obama is right.

When the short-term demand for a good is inelastic (meaning: short-term demand is relatively unresponsive to variations in price), as the demand for gasoline is, then a reduction in taxes will lead immediately to increased consumption until the price of gas once again reaches the market-clear price. In other words, if the gas tax is suspended the price will fall. When the price falls, people will buy more gas. Because of the increase in the quantity of gas demanded, the price will go right back up to its pre-tax-suspension level.

However, the quantity of gasoline demanded will increase if the tax is suspended. So such a policy would essentially be a hand-out from taxpayers to oil companies, with the added cost of environmental degradation and an increase in carbon emissions. 

In short, it's a remarkably stupid policy proposal. Obama should be commended for refusing to pander when given such an easy opportunity. He is losing ground in the polls for the sake of intellectual honesty, while Clinton and McCain are gaining cheap points by preying on peoples' ignorance. So good for him, and bad on them.

(P.S. This economic intuition is a fundamental assumption for members of the Pigou Club. If you share their goals and ethical assumptions, then it's easy to share their conclusion that gas taxes should be significantly higher; not lower.)

UPDATE:

Bryan Caplan likes the idea. But not for the same reasons as Clinton. His support is of a more cynical nature: he thinks that lowered taxes will preclude price controls, which he views as a greater evil, and in any case he thinks that eliminating the taxes won't have any strong negative effect. The second part is almost certainly true, and the first part is likely but not assured (and it is likely true because of American political tradition and our aversion to price controls; not because of the "irrationality" of the citizenry). If the profits of oil companies increase while gasoline prices continue upwards (as seems likely), then it seems likely that populist policies -- including price controls or other ill-minded ideas -- would become more likely, not less. I could draft the speech now: "Oil companies are getting rich on the backs of hard-working Americans. We tried to lower the burden by cutting out the taxes, but the greedy oil executives just grabbed more of the surplus. And so we should act punitively to re-direct money from these robber-barons back to the American people." And so price controls begin.

I know that Caplan knows more about game theory than I do, so maybe I'm missing something. But it seems to me as if he's acting as if this were a one-shot game, when it clearly isn't. 

Labels: , , , , ,