Friday, February 22, 2008

First Strike Capabilities

I agree with Matthew Yglesias' general tenor here, but I find this part strange:

Simply put, a scenario in which the United States possesses an effective ability to shoot down a Russian or Chinese ICBM threat would be completely intolerable in Moscow or Beijing. It would, in effect, give the United States a viable a threat of a nuclear first strike. Neither Russia nor China is going to let that happen. Instead, they'll spend money on building up their nuclear arsenals in order to maintain their deterrent capacity. Thus, at great cost to the Unites States, to Russia, and to China we'll be back at the status quo. But beyond the monetary cost, the large buildup in Chinese nuclear capabilities that would result from this situation would force India to engage in a nuclear build-up of its own. And that, in turn, would force Pakistan to follow suit. This large increase in the global stock of nuclear weapons would, of course, imply an increase in the odds of a nuclear accident or the loss or theft of nuclear material. At the same time, a nuclear buildup of this sort might create incentives for Iran to reinitiate its nuclear weapons research program.
In truth, the U.S. already has massive first strike capabilities against China or Russia (or anybody else), and the U.S. already has started building up and modernizing its nuclear arsenal. Neither Russia nor China responded to this by starting a news arms race; those countries still have too many domestic problems which take priority to spend untold billions on weaponry which would still be decades behind the U.S.

Second, India and Pakistan have their own reasons for building and maintaining a nuclear arsenal which have nothing to do with the U.S. or China, and they will continue to stand-off against each other no matter what we do.

Third, N. Korea and Iran weren't persuaded by calls to nonproliferation in the past, nor were they encouraged to pursue nuclear weaponry because of American expansion of arms. Indeed, their programs were begun and expanded during the period of time when the U.S. was dis-arming.

The Nonproliferation Treaty is essentially dead in the water, and that's a shame. Resuscitating it is possible, with the U.S. and Russia on board, but there's no guarantee that the NPT will have any serious deterrent effect in any case. McCain's policy is overly simplistic and uninspired -- as usual -- but it's not as disastrous as Yglesias is claiming it is.

Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, October 25, 2007

Or, There's Option "B"

Matthew Yglesias is clearly not following Christopher Hitchens' drift:

I briefly considered responding to Christopher Hitchens' defense of "Islamofascism" (the term not the doctrine) via a roundabout discussion of Orwell fetishism, but suffice it to say that I identify with the pragmatist tradition and the thing to ask about a term like this is what does "Islamofascism" do.

And it's pretty clear what it does, namely provide a spurious patina of unity and sameness to diverse phenomena involving Muslims Behaving Badly so that al-Qaeda, Hezbollah, Hamas, Iran, Assad, Saddam, Iraqi insurgents, Somali Islamists, plus sundry oppressive folk practices common in portions of the Islamic world like female genital mutilation in parts of Africa, "honor killings" in parts of South Asia, etc. The question to ask ourselves is what, if anything, is accomplished by devising and deploying a term that unites all those phenomena. If you want to use emotional outrage at 9/11 to leverage political support for an invasion of Iraq, then the answer is obviously "yes." Similarly, if you want to leverage outrage at 9/11 into political support for a bombing campaign in Iran then the answer is "yes."

But I don't want to do either of those things, and, indeed, I think the people who do like to do those things are having an immensely detrimental impact on our ability to understand events in the contemporary world and pull the United States out of the foreign policy tailspin we've been in recently. Which is a long way of saying, I'm not buying.

Or there's another option: one might despise religion in general, and especially the oppressive elements espoused by fundamentalist practitioners of one particular religion (including, to greater and lesser degrees, all of the groups listed by Yglesias and many others). One might even, if one was a writer, write a book on the topic. And, if so, one might call it something like God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything.

Oh, wait.

(for the record, Hitchens doesn't support bombing Iran.)

Labels:

Monday, September 3, 2007

N. Korea Abandons Its Nuke Program

So sayeth the Grey Lady:

The top American negotiator with North Korea said today that the country had agreed to disable its main nuclear fuel production facility by the end of the year and to account to international monitors for all of its nuclear programs, including what American intelligence agencies believe was a second, secret program purchased from Pakistan.

At the end of a two-day meeting in Geneva — exactly the kind of one-on-one session that the Bush administration had refused to hold in recent years — Christopher R. Hill, the assistant secretary of state for East Asian and Pacific affairs, said that the two sides had agreed on what would be a speedy next step, following action by the North this summer to turn off its main nuclear reactor.

“One thing that we agreed on is that the D.P.R.K. will provide a full declaration of all of their nuclear programs and will disable their nuclear programs by the end of this year, 2007,” Mr. Hill told reporters in Geneva, according to the Associated Press. He was using the initials for the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, the North’s formal name.

But in a separate news conference, his counterpart, Kim Kye-gwan, who heads the North Korean negotiating team, made no mention of an end of the year deadline. He spoke instead of an accord to disable North Korea’s equipment and provide an accounting of its facilities, fuel and weapons in return for what he called “political and economic compensation.”

A few things here. First, the Bush admin. should get credit here. In fact, this continues a series of foreign policy successes since 2001. The Iraq disaster and Iran war-mongering get all the headlines, but Bush convinced Libya to give up its nuclear program, forced the removal and arrest of A.Q. Khan (who had sold weaponry, including nuclear devices, off the shelf to Iran, Libya, N. Korea, and was trying to sell to Saddam) in Pakistan, rallied the international community to put strong pressure on Iran to give up its nuclear program, and has now bribed the D.P.R.K. into abandoning its nuclear ambitions. These are subtle victories, but substantial ones, all of which eluded Pres. Clinton. Some credit is due here.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, August 15, 2007

The Giuliani Doctrine

Matthew Yglesias destroys Rudy's recent essay in Foreign Affairs. It's worth reading the whole post, but here's the upshot:

The result of this policy is going to be an endless series of wars, a bankrupt country accounting for way more than fifty percent of world defense expenditures, fewer and fewer countries willing to cooperate with us on key priorities and, perhaps worst of all, more and more nuclear proliferation as countries decide its not safe to live in a world where the Rudy-led USA is the big kid on the block.
I don't think he's over-stating the case. After all, Giuliani's chief foreign policy advisor is Norman Podhoretz -- who is already on record as saying that the Iraq War "couldn't have gone better," and who wants to unilaterally bomb Iran -- and Giuliani has been the most hawkish of the the GOP candidates in the debates.

Giuliani must be opposed. At all costs.

Labels: , ,

Friday, July 20, 2007

Quote of the Day

George Packer, in The New Yorker, regarding Iran:

The regime there is brutal, and we should talk to it.
There is a lot of truth to this sentiment. The whole article is very good, and should be read.

(ht: Daniel Drezner)

Labels:

Wednesday, July 11, 2007

Know Your Rights

At least 15 students were beaten up and arrested for protesting the continued imprisonment of 8 other students, who have held since May. This is a pretty common occurrence in Iran today, and this is why we should not bomb them (no matter what Podhoretz or Giuliani says). You see, these pro-democracy, pro-liberalization movements will continue to pick up steam in Iran, especially if the government continues to beat and arrest students who are demanding their rights. The economic situation in Iran is pretty bad because of Ahmadinejad's mis-management, and the people are becoming aware of it.

Yes, Ahmadinejad still calls for the destruction of Israel. Yes, he is still intent on developing nuclear power, most likely for weapons. But his people are turning on him, and this will continue as the economic situation deteriorates and pro-democracy movements gain ground. If we bomb Iran, or engage them militarily in any way, nationalism will surge in Iran and the people will rally around Ahmadinejad (think of the pro-Bush, pro-America, anti-Taliban sentiment in the U.S. after 9/11 as compared to the fractious political scene on 9/10, when no one knew or cared who the Taliban was, and more people disliked Bush than liked him).

Now, if Iran actually does threaten the U.S., then we should be prepared to act military in response. But to act preemptively would be disastrous. Anyway, Iran can't threaten the U.S. directly, and Israel has 200 nukes and the largest military (by far) in the MidEast. There is no threat from Iran, and if we encourage pro-democratic movements there with money and verbal support, we can do some good. If we invade or bomb the place, we will set back the cause of democracy and liberty in Iran for a generation or more.

The pro-liberty, pro-democracy, anti-war, anti-Mullah movement is alive and well, and will only grow. Unless we invade and turn the country against us.

Labels:

Tuesday, July 10, 2007

Giuliani hires Podhoretz

Rudy Giuliani must be opposed at all costs. He has just hired Norman Podhoretz, the man who wants to unilaterally bomb a country -- Iran -- which has not provoked us to war.

The man who said of the Iraq war: "an amazing success." He waves his fist and declaims, "There were WMD, and they were shipped to Syria. ... This picture of a country in total chaos with no security is false. It has been a triumph. It couldn't have gone better." He wants more wars, and fast. He is "certain" Bush will bomb Iran, and "thank God" for that.

Yes. He said that Iraq "couldn't have gone better". It was bad enough that Giuliani enthusiastically supports torture in violation of domestic and international law, saying things like:
"I would tell the people who had to do the interrogation to use every method they can think of" when asked if he would support the use of waterboarding, a technique perfected by the Khmer Rouge, and used by the Imperial Japanese and Waffen SS in WWII. That was bad enough to disqualify him from holding any public office.

But now his senior foreign policy advisor is a man who is clearly deluded about the situation on the ground in Iraq, is clearly deluded about the situation in Iraq pre-war, and wants to start bombing more countries for no particular reason. This clearly eliminates Giuliani as a viable voting option for anyone who cares about liberty, justice, the rule of law, or the international interests of the United States. Which should include everyone.

At this point, Romney seems like the best of a lot of bad options on the GOP side.

Update: Apparently, a lot of Catholics agree that Giuliani must be opposed. (ht: Andrew Sullivan)

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, June 18, 2007

World's Worst Currencies

Chavez made the list, despite having bragged "we're going to end monetary instability in Venezuela." Chavez's reaction? Imprisoning those who violate price controls, introducing a 12.5 cent coin, and arbitrarily removing three zeros from the bolivar. The result? The official bolivar/dollar exchange rate is roughly half the black market rate. Chavez hasn't quite reached Mugabe-like levels of economic mismanagement, but he's on the same path.

Iran didn't make Foreign Policy's round-up, but they are similarly in trouble:

Some 60 economists this week wrote to Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadi-Nejad criticising his government for putting “short-term welfare above long-term sustainable development”.

Almost half way through his first four-year term, the letter underlines the acute dilemmas faced by the president in delivering short-term welfare promises as he manoeuvres to bolster political support.

The government’s indecision over two major issues – the price of petrol and bank lending rates – is a particular source of confusion.

More than three weeks after the lapse of the original date for petrol rationing – designed to curb a $5bn (€3.75bn, £2.5bn) bill for importing 35m of the 75m litres Iran consumes daily – the government is still groping its way around any decision it fears might be unpopular. Officials have this week made differing statements over when and how rationing – which was to begin tomorrow – will start....

Private bankers wrote to the economy minister last week demanding a freeze on loan rates to “make survival of private banks possible”.

But even with inflation officially at 13.6 per cent last year, Mr Ahmadi-Nejad is battling with the central bank over his insistence on a 12 per cent lending rate, down from the current 14 per cent in state-owned and 17 per cent in private banks. The Guardian Council, a constitution watchdog, is due to rule this week on a compromise.

“What the government describes as economic policies do not match any professionally-known theories, but are rather populist political policies,” said Mohammad Tabibian, former deputy head of the Management and Planning Organisation, a cross-governmental co-ordination body....

Many observers doubt official figures of 14 per cent inflation and 12 per cent unemployment. One economist told the FT that inflation was above 20 per cent, while unemployment was 25 per cent among university graduates.



There's no need to go to war with Iran; at this rate, they will crumble the same way the Soviet Union crumbled: through economic mismanagement coupled with fickle oil markets.

ht: Daniel Drezner

Labels: , ,

Thursday, April 26, 2007

The Danger of Neoconservatism...

... is that it doesn't know where to stop. so we've got John McCain singing "Bomb bomb bomb bomb bomb Iran" to rounding applause (tho, in truth, McCain is less of a neo-con than old-school hawk).

thankfully, the reality-based community seems to be holding sway on this issue. Obama gave a speech in which he comes off as more hawkish than he has before, and sent some liberals into a tizzy. Jonathan Chait parsed it nicely at The Plank, and i don't think an Obama presidency would have any interest in an Iranian invasion unless we were *massively* provoked.

Still, the mood in some circles on the right seem to think that invading Iran may be done with the same justification of the invasion of Iraq. But the these arguments aren't transitive - they were specific to Iraq, and the same conditions don't apply to Iran. Yes, Iran is pursuing WMD, but that wasn't the case for invasion didn't hinge on that point. Iran is not committing genocide; they didn't invade Kuwait, fire on American planes patrolling no-fly zones every day for a decade, pervert the Oil-for-Food program, etc.

But the most telling difference is in the structure of the governments. Iran, despite bestowing large power upon whichever Grand Ayatollah is the current Supreme Leader, has some semblance of actual democracy, which we found out when Ahmadinejad's party did exceptionally poorly in Tehren's most-recent city-wide elections. how significant this was is up for debate, but such a thing was inconceivable in Saddam's Baghdad. the people of Iran are relatively free to show dissent, and anti-Ahmadinejad protests are relatively common.

a pair of recent articles, from outposts on the right, gives us a glimpse into the nature of the people of Iran, and give some hope for intra-country reforms. good reading.

Labels: