Thursday, May 31, 2007

Fact for the Day

An interesting factual tidbit from a recent Bloggingheads. Megan McArdle informs Daniel Drezner -- and me -- that in 1890, ~ 50% of Americans were foreign-born. Now, it's less than 10%. The Republic didn't collapse in 1890, and it won't collapse now if we allow more immigrants, whether skilled or unskilled, to come to the States. In fact, the new immigrants were instrumental in improving the nation's economy in the late 19th- and early 20th-centuries, and building towards American hegemony in the 20th-century. A similar thing could happen in the 21st-century, if only Lou Dobbs would get the hell out of the way.

Labels:

Land Reform in Venezuela

Daniel Drezner looks at Chavez's land reform and does not like what he sees:

Hugo Chavez approaches the Mugabe level of economic mismanagement

On Thursday the Wall Street Journal's Jose De Cordoba had a front-pager describing how Hugo Chávez's agricultural reforms are going:

Now Mr. Chavez is taking his revolution to the Venezuelan countryside. "We must end latifundios," he said in a televised speech in March, referring to large agrarian estates. "The people order it, and we will do it, whatever the cost." Then he announced the seizure of a land area larger than the state of Rhode Island.

Since coming to power, The Chávez government has handed over 8.8 million acres, an area bigger than Maryland, for use by the poor. While much of this was state-owned land that was either idle or leased to ranchers, some 4.5 million acres were "recovered" from private owners, Mr. Chávez said recently. In some cases, the government compensated them. In most others... it has simply turned a blind eye to land invasions.

The government bills land reform as a way to make Venezuela self-sufficient infood. But so far, the effect has been to undercut production of beef, sugar and other foods, as productive land is handed over to city dwellers with no knowledge of farming. Established farmers and ranchers, fearing their land may be seized next, are cutting investment in their operations to a minimum.

The chaos in the countryside has contributed to shortages in basic items like milk and meat, a paradox in a country enjoying an economic boom traceable to high oil prices. Also spurring the shortages are price controls on certain foods that keep them prices below the cost of production. Meanwhile, 19%-plus inflation--as oil revenue floods the economy--spurs panic buying: purchasing price-controlled and other goods the shopper might not immediately need for fear of having higher prices in the future or not finding the items at all.

"You get up at dawn to hunt for a breast of chicken all over town. Housewives are in a foul mood." says Lucylde Gonzalez, a Caracas homemaker, who says she hasn't seen an egg in a week."

Chávez has now reached the Robert Mugabe level of economic incompetence by messing with the farm sector. Let's hope he does not move past that to the Mao Zedong/Great Leap Forward level of economic mismanagement.
So who gets the land? Either slum-dwellers from cities who don't know how to farm (and will mismanage the land), or political cronies who won't improve the socioeconomic standing of the Venezuelan poor. Either way, another popular political action which is paving the way to national economic disaster.

Labels: ,

The State of the U.S. Economy

Greg Mankiw points us to an excellent OECD report:

The trend growth rate of GDP has slowed, mainly because of tighter limits on how quickly employment can grow. In particular, the labour force participation rate, which used to be rising quickly, is now trending down. Against this background, this chapter considers three policies that bear on long term employment trends. Raising the age at which workers become eligible for full social security benefits would discourage premature retirement and make the social security system more financially secure. The disability insurance system is discouraging a rising share of the population from staying in the workforce and should be made less generous and more selective. Substantial increases in the federal minimum wage are planned; however, increases in the Earned Income Tax Credit would achieve the same objectives more effectively and with less risk of job losses.

On the revenue side, it may be difficult to sustain the recent reductions in marginal tax rates, while meeting the fiscal burden from entitlement programmes, although this would be clearly desirable. To the extent that revenues have to be raised, the tax base should be broadened, rather than reversing reductions in marginal tax rates. Since the comprehensive tax reform in 1986, which broadened tax bases and reduced marginal rates, most of the resulting gains in simplicity and efficiency have been lost through a renewed expansion in tax expenditures. To be sure, not all of them are undesirable. However, tax expenditures, which are distorting, ill targeted and ineffective, should be reduced or abolished. The President’s Advisory Panel for Federal Tax Reform has recommended, inter alia, that tax preferences for mortgage interest payments, employers’ contributions to health insurance plan premiums, and state and local tax payments should be reduced. But, in addition to the Panel’s proposals, consideration should also be given to shifting the tax burden from direct taxes to consumption based indirect taxes – such as a national sales tax or a value added tax. This would produce efficiency gains, including reducing disincentives to saving. Furthermore, higher taxation of carbon based energy consumption would help reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
I can't find a thing wrong with it.

Labels:

Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Zoellick To Be New World Bank Prez

I don't know much about him, but most people who do think he's an "okay" choice at worst, and a "very good" one at best. I'll just point to them. DeLong qts. an anonymous source with positive and negative things to say. Yglesias sees it as a decent choice. Barnett is downright enthusiastic. Sounds like it could be a lot worse.

Labels:

The Truth about the Deficit

Andrew Sullivan points us to an article that says the national deficit is worse than they tell us:

The federal government recorded a $1.3 trillion loss last year — far more than the official $248 billion deficit — when corporate-style accounting standards are used, a USA TODAY analysis shows.

The loss reflects a continued deterioration in the finances of Social Security and government retirement programs for civil servants and military personnel. The loss — equal to $11,434 per household — is more than Americans paid in income taxes in 2006.

But then Kevin Drum looks a little closer:

BEATING A DEAD HORSE....At the end of a post where he freaks out over a preposterously inappropriate way of measuring the federal deficit, Andrew Sullivan says this:

I also noticed in my latest letter from the Social Security Administration that, as currently configured, I'll get 76 percent of what I'm due if and when I retire. My bet is that it will turn out to be less than half. The boomers are going to hog all of it for themselves.

Please. Just stop it. Assuming Wikipedia has his age right, Andrew will turn 65 in 2028. Even if we do absolutely nothing, CBO estimates that Social Security will pay out full benefits at least until 2053. Andrew will be 90 years old at that point. What's more, a very modest tax increase starting a decade from now combined with a very modest slowdown in benefit growth will keep the system solvent forever.

This is grade school arithmetic, and the basic data is available with no more than a few minutes of googling. Can we please knock off the scaremongering on this subject?

Labels: ,

Delusion of the Week

"God has spoken to me. I listen to God, and what I've heard is that I'm supposed to devote myself to rebuilding the conservative base of the Republican Party, and I think we shouldn’t be underestimated," - Tom DeLay, from the New Yorker.

ht: Andrew Sullivan

Oppenheimer on Einstein

A gem, reprinted from the March 17, 1966 issue of the New York Review of Books.

Labels:

Plame Was Covert

Case closed. So revealing her identity was a felony. So Libby's conviction is just. So right-wingers, at least those who still care about the rule of law, can just shut up.

Labels:

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Question for the Ages

Now that it's over, how will history judge the Cindy Sheehan era of American politics?

Labels:

Economic Heterodoxy

Christopher Hayes has an interesting article in The Nation about "heterodox" economists which has been causing a bit of a stir in the blogosphere. That is, those economists whose work and philosophy strays from the neoclassical textbook traditions. His thesis is that the heterodox are cast into the corner for philosophical reasons, such as their greater emphasis on market failures, irrational agents, and behavioral concerns.

Any article of this sort which comes from The Nation must be understood in that political context. The Nation has a vested interest in diluting the message of free-marketers, and so cherry-picking economists who stray from economic orthodoxy (whatever that is) is to be expected. Hayes maintains that these newer forms of economic study - such as behavioral economics - are resisted by the establishment. This may have been true several decades ago, but the profession seems pretty accepting of new perspectives now, provided that they are empirically-backed. Behavioral economists have won the Nobel Prize, after all, as have the developers of microcredit. The most well-known economists today are probably Levitt, Krugman, and Landsburg, none of whom are known for propagating laissez-faire policies.

But just because the economic profession is changing doesn't mean that it is changing to something that Hayes would approve of. The neoclassical models still hold up pretty well on the macro level, even if some revisions are being conducted on the micro level. So with regards to broad, sweeping, public policy proscriptions, there are very few serious economists - heterodox or orthodox - who would go very far down the same road as The Nation. This piece is probably best read as an attempt to marginalize and discredit the consensus of economists in order to further a political agenda.

Julian Sanchez has more thoughts. So does Tyler Cowen, who offers this nice line: "There's much talk in Hayes' article about discrimination against heterodox economists, but he gives surprisingly little attention to which of their valid propositions have been neglected. I'd like to see a simple list and start the debate there."

U.S. Torture Worse Than Gestapo?

Andrew Sullivan has a great post comparing our use of "enhanced interrogation techniques" to the Gestapo's "versharfte Vernehmung," which translates nicely to "enhanced interrogation," "sharpened interrogation," or "intensified interrogation". A must-read for anyone still unconvinced that the interrogation policies of the U.S. do not qualify as torture. The Gestapo at least acknowledged that they were torturing their prisoners, while the U.S. government is too busy playing semantic games to realize the moral morass into which they've fallen.

Fun Fact: the Gestapo outlawed induced hypothermia and waterboarding, which were both authorized by Pres. Bush. Over a hundred deaths have been documented at U.S. interrogation facilities. These are war crimes, and have been for a long time. Men were tried, convicted, and sentenced to death for employing these techniques in WWII. For those on the right to continue to defend the use of this torture is beyond the pale.

Labels:

Are We Losing in Afghanistan?

The Afghans seem to think so.

Ground Zero Construction

Monday, May 28, 2007

This Ain't No Mecca, Man

RCTV, perhaps the most popular TV station in Venezuela, is now officially out of business, replaced by a state-run company. Pres. Hugo Chavez says the decision to limit the free press in this manner was due to the stations "subversive" programming. The masses protested, and were fired on by police.

Chavez's mask of populism is wilting away, exposing the authoritarian beneath.

Labels: ,

Sunday, May 27, 2007

There's 'Populism' for You

It appears that Chavez isn't as people-friendly as he claims to be:

Tens of thousands of Venezuelan protesters marched on Saturday to the Caracas headquarters of an anti-government television station, which is being forced off the air after President Hugo Chavez's administration refused to renew its broadcasting license.

"What is happening here is simply the silencing of a television station," shouted soap opera actress Gledys Ibarra.

Critics condemned the closure for silencing an influential opposition voice and called the move evidence that Chavez's self-styled socialist revolution is concentrating power and muzzling the opposition.

The closure of RCTV drew heavy international criticism including a U.S. Senate resolution last week unanimously condemning "transgression of freedom of thought and expression" in Venezuela.
Those on the left who think that Hugo Chavez's regime is a friend to the "common man" have been drinking the same Kool-Aid served by Mssrs. Peron, Castro, and Guevara. It's an ideological trap, practiced by the most sinister politicians on the left and right: "i'll pay lip-service to your pet issues so long as you cede total control to me". It's a line which has been used by fascists, despots, theocrats, totalitarians, and monarchs all down the line. Venezuela is in trouble... and i wonder how long it will take the American left to recognize it.

Saturday, May 26, 2007

Why Debts to China Are Good for America

The re-emergence of populist politics in the U.S. since the last election has had one strange side-effect: the demonization of China. Presumably, China is a bad guy because they buy U.S. government bonds, and peg the yuan's value to the dollar. But these policies actually work in the U.S.'s favor. I've written about this a few times, but Greg Mankiw and Thomas P.M. Barnett both have short, succinct, illustrative posts about why this illogic is so frustrating. First, Mankiw:

Suppose the U.S. President were to propose the following policy: "My fellow Americans, I have just asked the Congress to increase taxes on all of us. After they pass my tax increase, I will instruct the Treasury to lend the additional tax revenue to the government of China."

Most Americans would, I suspect, be opposed to this proposal. They would see it as beneficial to China but without much benefit to the United States. With America eager to lend, China would enjoy lower interest rates. Why should Americans pay higher taxes to finance Chinese borrowing and spending?

I agree that this would be a strange and not very sensible policy for the U.S. government to pursue. But isn't it a bit odd that many Americans today are objecting to precisely the opposite of this policy. China is not borrowing from the U.S. government but is instead lending to the U.S. government by buying large quantities of Treasury bonds. The money used to buy these bonds could be returned to Chinese citizens in lower taxes. In other words, Chinese taxpayers are financing American spending and keeping our interest rates lower than they otherwise would be. And many Americans, including the President and Treasury Secretary, are complaining.

Unlike Matthew Slaughter, I would not argue that Chinese policy is incapable of affecting the real exchange rate. In a world of imperfect capital mobility, Chinese policy can affect international capital flows and thus the real exchange rate that equilibrates trade in goods and capital. But I am skeptical that their policy intervention is adverse to broad American interests. What the Chinese are doing, to boil it down to its essence, is buying U.S. government bonds (and some other American assets). The U.S. government is in the business of selling these bonds. There is no good reason to object when a willing buyer steps into the market.

These purchases most likely affect the exchange rate to some extent--and indeed the effect on the exchange rate could well be motiviating the purchases. It is crucial to keep in mind, however, that the exchange rate is a price, and a change in a price has opposite effects on different sides of the market. Cheap Chinese goods are bad news for U.S. producers that compete with those goods, but they are good news for U.S. consumers who buy these goods.

The more difficult question is whether the Chinese are acting against their own self-interest by saving so much and investing in foreign assets. Perhaps they are worried about potential future crises and want a large reserve fund for such a contingency. One can argue that the fund is now excessive. But it harder to argue that their saving and investing in our economy is a problem for us.

Before you say, "They are stealing our jobs," let me point out two things. First, while some jobs are lost to import competition, other jobs are gained because of lower interest rates and greater investment spending that capital inflows finance. Second, the U.S. unemployment rate is now low by historical standards. Based on either theory or evidence, the canonical political refrain of "jobs, jobs, jobs" makes little sense in this debate.
and now Barnett, who isn't an economist, but has good enough sense:

Bunch of these articles lately, pointing out what a lot of people have been saying for a while: pegging the yuan to the dollar has been great for America. We get deflationary pressure, plus our remains cheap from the recycling.

It’s really Europe that gets screwed in the process.

If China revalues, then what? It won’t cure the fact that Americans spend too much and save too little. It won’t reduce our imports, because restricting Chinese imports will lead to Americans simply importing the same products from other nations, not in our building such products ourselves. There is no substitution effect here.

And cheap Chinese imports don’t cause unemployment here, unless you think 4.5% is a lot of unemployment (actually, it’s close to our lowest number in decades).

China would actually benefit more than we would from such a revaluation, because it would help them shift money from investment to consumption, which would allow them to moderate the growth of the economy better and help avoid bubbles and crashes caused by excess liquidity (there is such a thing as having too much money in the system).

And yet watch Congress pursue all sorts of tariff threats, making you wonder if there’s one decent economist out of the 535.

China know that the only way for their economy to continue to grow at such rates is to ensure that the U.S. continues to buy their exports. They know that the only way to ensure that happens is to help keep the U.S. economy in good shape. China is acting in their interest by helping us fulfill our interests. We should be thanking them... not railing against them.

Labels:

Oh Lord, Save Us from Your Followers

"Christian" perfume:

Combining ingredients such as frankincense and myrrh, Virtue® is a perfume inspired by Biblical ingredients and marketed as a tool for spiritual attainment. The product's literature advises the consumer to "hold it in Sacred regard as a means to train yourself to readily contact your Spiritual Self," so as to "serve both your worldly fragrance needs and provide a means of focusing your Spiritual Intent." Pioneered by Vicki Pratt and Rick Larimore, Virtue retails for $80 a bottle.

Impeach Cheney

Impeach him for subverting the foreign policy of the United States, for attempting to push us into another war, and for encouraging American allies to start a war and drag the U.S. into it. Steve Clemens with an important article:

Multiple sources have reported that a senior aide on Vice President Cheney's national security team has been meeting with policy hands of the American Enterprise Institute, one other think tank, and more than one national security consulting house and explicitly stating that Vice President Cheney does not support President Bush's tack towards Condoleezza Rice's diplomatic efforts and fears that the President is taking diplomacy with Iran too seriously.

This White House official has stated to several Washington insiders that Cheney is planning to deploy an "end run strategy" around the President if he and his team lose the policy argument.

The thinking on Cheney's team is to collude with Israel, nudging Israel at some key moment in the ongoing standoff between Iran's nuclear activities and international frustration over this to mount a small-scale conventional strike against Natanz using cruise missiles (i.e., not ballistic missiles).

...

The zinger of this information is the admission by this Cheney aide that Cheney himself is frustrated with President Bush and believes, much like Richard Perle, that Bush is making a disastrous mistake by aligning himself with the policy course that Condoleezza Rice, Bob Gates, Michael Hayden and McConnell have sculpted.

According to this official, Cheney believes that Bush can not be counted on to make the "right decision" when it comes to dealing with Iran and thus Cheney believes that he must tie the President's hands.

On Tuesday evening, i spoke with a former top national intelligence official in this Bush administration who told me that what I was investigating and planned to report on regarding Cheney and the commentary of his aide was "potentially criminal insubordination" against the President. I don't believe that the White House would take official action against Cheney for this agenda-mongering around Washington -- but I do believe that the White House must either shut Cheney and his team down and give them all garden view offices so that they can spend their days staring out their windows with not much to do or expect some to begin to think that Bush has no control over his Vice President.

It is not that Cheney wants to bomb Iran and Bush doesn't, it is that Cheney is saying that Bush is making a mistake and thus needs to have the choices before him narrowed.

Labels:

Unbelievable

from Andrew Sullivan:

A reader writes:

You asked

"Second, of course, the hideous term: "enhanced interrogation techniques.' I'm not sure where exactly this came from..."

Well, "enhanced interrogation techniques" is a fairly decent English translation of the Gestapo euphemism "verschaerfte Vernehmung" which was the code word for torture in the Third Reich. Look it up.

The dictionary confirms it. So Dean Barnett is picking up his terms from the Gestapo. Way to go, Dean.

Labels:

Tuesday, May 22, 2007

I'm Becoming a Disciple of T.P.M. Barnett

Two great posts from one of our best strategic thinkers:

There are always intell reports that explore all potential downsides. Their existence proves nothing, because that's intell's job: list me the bad things that can happen if I do this, or if I don't do this.

It's like the surgeon telling you before the op about all possible complications. Their potentiality is but one element to be calculated in your decision.

That's why this notion of "faulty intell" is all wrong. It's not how intell works. You get a range of potential outcomes (inevitably, all worst case) and then you make your call.

The presumption of "good" or "bad" intell can't really be proven per se. Some always ends up being "amazingly prescient," the rest is a load of hyperbolic crap.

When things work out, no one cares about all the "bad" intell. But when it goes badly (always for a host of reasons and decisions, or simply because the decisionmakers prefer the sub-optimal outcome to no action at all), then the "amazingly prescient" intell is inevitably touted as "proof" of the intell "failure" (I made this argument first in PNM).

Also inevitably, there will be calls for "reform," none of which can possibly overcome this essentially political decisionmaking process, nor will it stop the very same politicians from declaring their pet defense programs "crucial" because "we live in a world of COMPLETE UNCERTAINTY!"

In short, no president can be "controlled" or "corrected" by perfect intelligence--a useless concept if ever there was one.

Bush and Cheney made their decisions. Until the casualties began piling up ("high" by today's standards, marginal by yesterday's), their decisionmaking was supported--in poll after poll and congressional vote after vote--by the clear majority of Americans and their leaders. Once the bodies piled up and a sense of non-progress ensued, a clear majority turned against those decisions--and those decisionmakers.

That's just how it works in our political system.

So the real correction is--duh!--get the casualties down, not "fix intell."

Iraq stopped being a binary outcome a long time ago. Kurdistan is where we've won, and Kurdistan is where we'll manage to define a partial victory, reduce our exposure and casualties by concentrating the bulk of our troops there, and continue to sequence the rest of Iraq toward something better over time (back to Hoagland and Friedman--and me for two-plus years now--on engaging Iran and keeping this Big Bang strategy alive).

For some, it will always be solely about kinetics and the intell that justifies it.

To others, it'll always be a mix, a sequence, a balance.

The former is a strategy all right, just not a grand one.

And no amount of good intell will overcome that mindset.

And:

An overwrought argument from Mann, who specializes in them.

China is no "new" model or threat. It follows the model of Singapore, and before that South Korea, and before that Japan: a single-party state that bases almost all of its legitimacy on rising income and development through export-driven growth. It is a self-liquidating model: eventually the society wants more political freedom to go with that wealth. China's just so fricking huge and so poor that this process isn't going fast enough for Mann--hence the inevitable "threat."

Mann recognizes neither those past examples nor the significant economic and personal freedoms unleashed inside China over the past quarter century. His Z not having been reached fast enough, he discounts all movement from A since the bizarre depths of Mao's cultural revolution, which is no more distant politically than our Vietnam.

While China's "new" model, such as it is, appeals greatly to many authoritarian regimes in the Gap, there are scant few there that can possibly replicate it (yeah, size matters)..

I mean, name one Gap regime to date that has successfully emerged using China's model? Just interacting with China economically hardly connotes successful subversion to its model. It simply indicates recognition that external economic connectivity is a prerequisite for raising incomes at home, and yeah, if you're an authoritarian leader ruling over a stagnate economy, that's attractive.

As for our take on it, we should logically welcome any so-called model that promotes external economic connectivity, because we know where that goes historically (i.e., where Japan and South Korea finally ended up: creating political freedoms that match their system's potential--something that took us a while to achieve as well).

In short, China carries our economic model's water for us, pushing us to marry up our political model with it over time (what we seek to encourage in China, we logically seek to encourage in similar situations across the Gap). Hardly an alternative model, China's path is but a steppingstone to outcomes we naturally seek. I mean, crawling might be described as an alternative to walking, but only until you're able to walk, then it suddenly seems like a passing phase.

China's "model" will never move beyond crawling, because it's about transforming a hugely rural, impoverished, disconnected society (one-sixth of humanity) into an urban, consumeristic, connected one. Once achieved, and China is nowhere near that at this time, with well over half its population still living in very Gap-like conditions, then its model self-liquidates that all before it.

China's future leaders know this, so do our smart observers. Mann ain't one of the them. He knows his China from a long way back now, and he'll never recognize another.

Confusing China's influence-peddling with model propagation is a new academic fad in search of actual data to prove its distinctiveness, but there is none. China's model is not unique, but a copycat of something we've seen before in "rising Asia," just not on this scale. Prior to that, the USSR had its own bankrupt version. China's model will extend itself only where China extends itself, and since China's economic ties remain exceedingly mercantilistic, that won't be far.

In short, the academic tomes touting China's "victory" are arriving just as the Gap is beginning to turn on China, and just as China's starts feeling the scary blowback from its extension of trade nets deep into the Gap. As always, the academics are right on time.

Hardly a great threat, this "model," but merely a tool to be manipulated by leaders more strategically imaginative than our current crew--or the ideologically-myopic Mann.

The first is funnier. The second is more substantive. I think I'm becoming a disciple of T.P.M. Barnett.

Labels:

Sunday, May 20, 2007

Is the GOP Changing?

If Giuliani wins the GOP nomination despite his social liberalism, will it signify a changing of the GOP's core principles?

In a debate at TNR, Thomas Edsell says "yes." Ramesh Ponnuru says "no" and cites Colin Powell's almost-candidacy from 1995-6 as evidence. i think i'm with Ponnuru, but I still think that Giuliani has little chance of ending up with the GOP nomination. His poll numbers have been dropping, and I think it's because more Americans are learning more about what Giuliani thinks about issues, rather than simply remembering what Giuliani represents. It's why Giuliani deflected Ron Paul's sober-minded statement about the dangers of "blowback," using it as an excuse to rile up everyone's emotions about 9/11. It's a potent weapon, but it's Giuliani's only one, and I don't think it's strong enough to win him the nomination.

It is sad, tho, when the most substantive take on foreign policy among GOP prez hopefuls comes from a cranky old libertarian. Even sadder that the GOP has responded by trying to shut him up.

Labels:

Shooting Themselves in the Foot

David Frum has a nice post about the new immigration compromise, and how it will effect the GOP in the '08 elections. most of it sounds about right to me.

i haven't had time to really examine the immigration proposal, but at first glimpse it looks like bad policy to me.

Labels:

Pot/Kettle No. IV: Stupid Blogger Edition

what? did Marty Peretz really just say this?

This will annoy what's his name who blogs a lot about me. Has he nothing better to blog about? Actually, that's how makes a living: by writing about people who are smarter than him and know more about the world than him. And since neither smarts nor knowledge carry much cachet; with the left blogosphere (also not with the right blogosphere) its stars like what's his name ridicule the writers whose arguments he can't quite grasp.
"What's his name" is, of course, Matthew Yglesias. Who, of course, rips Peretz to shreds in one sentence:

In my next life, maybe I'll try to take a more respectable path to media prominence, something like using my wife's money to buy an established magazine.
Yglesias is a contributing editor at The Atlantic. Peretz is an editor at the magazine his wife bought him. and Peretz is talking about "cachet"?

Labels:

Saturday, May 19, 2007

More on Comey

Benjamin Wittes at TNR pulls no punches on Comey's testimony:

At least as Comey relates it, this affair is not one of mere bad judgment or over-aggressiveness. It is a story of profound misconduct on Gonzales's part that, at least in my judgment, borders on the impeachable. Put bluntly, faced with a Justice Department determination that the NSA's program contained prohibitive legal problems, the White House decided to go ahead with it anyway. In pursuit of this goal, Gonzales did two things that both seem unforgivable: He tried to get a seriously ill man to unlawfully exercise powers that had been conveyed to another man and to use those powers to approve a program the department deemed unlawful. Then, when Ashcroft refused, the White House went ahead and authorized the program on its own. In terms of raw power, the president has the ability to take this step. But it constitutes a profound affront to the institutional role of the Justice Department as it has developed. The Justice Department is the part of the government that defines the law for the executive branch. For the White House counsel to defy its judgment on an important legal question is to put the rawest power ahead of the law.

The much-derided John Ashcroft, on the other hand, showed himself when it counted to be a man of courage and substance whom history will surely treat more kindly than did contemporary commentary. Few attorneys general get tested as Ashcroft did that night in 2004. One can disagree with him about a lot of things and still recognize the fact that ultimately, he passed the hardest test: From a hospital bed in intensive care, he stood up for the rule of law. More broadly, the Justice Department seems to have performed admirably across the board--from the OLC having taken its job seriously, to the willingness on the part of the department brass and Mueller to lose their jobs to defend the department's ability to determine the law for the executive branch. Had the story ended with Comey's victory, it would have been an ugly crisis with a happy ending.

This is a much bigger story than the MSM wants to admit. Those who imagine a left-wing bias should ask themselves: if the media is out to destroy Bush, then why has there almost no coverage of this incident?

Labels:

Good News from Baghdad

Instapundit directs us to Outside the Wire, where we discover that the surge is working. Well, kind of. Please read the entire article; lots of great writing and pictures:

Is there hope for Baghdad? Yes. The additional U.S. forces from the surge are already showing limited signs of success. They are not the signs quantified by London or D.C. think tanks.


Every Battalion Commander I talked with gave me the same metrics to measure success--Commerce, people returning to their homes, essential services, kids playing soccer in fields they haven't played on in 2 years, professionalization of the police and security services.


Those are things that do not fit well in an index and things a person can only see on the ground by going back to the same areas of operation every few months.


Which is why I will be back in Dora and West Rasheed in a few months.




As nice as that is to read - and it certainly is nice - the fact remains that progress can also be measured by indexes: levels of violence, kids in school, etc. and all those indicators remain pretty negative. But it is important to remember that the violence isn't the entire story: playgrounds and jobs and electricity all matter as well.

Labels:

How to Get Rich

Apparently, it's easy:

Ohio State economics professor Jay Zagorsky suggests different factors: "Staying married, not getting divorced, thinking about savings." Wow.
Economists usually also include things like graduating from high school, not having kids before marriage, and not getting married too early. And they also say that this will make it exceptionally unlikely that you don't become poor, not necessarily that you will get rich.

But whatever.

More Bad Stuff from Russia

Putin has come under fire from the E.U.:

VOLZHSKY UTYOS, Russia (AP) - European Union leaders criticized Russia's human rights record—and were faulted in return—at the end of a summit Friday that produced no formal agreements but helped illustrate the widening political chasm between Moscow and the West.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel complained that opposition activists were being prevented from traveling to a planned protest in the Volga River city of Samara, near the site of the EU-Russia summit.

"I'm concerned about some people having problems in traveling here," Merkel told reporters. "I hope they will be given an opportunity to express their opinion."

Among the activists kept from boarding flights was former chess champion Garry Kasparov, now a leading political foe of President Vladimir Putin. Officials confiscated activists' passports and tickets at Moscow's Sheremetyevo airport, and held them for about five hours. Activists in Samara also said they were harassed.

Russia's democratic freedoms and its treatment of critics are two of the most sensitive issues haunting Russia-EU relations. Merkel's remark came during a sometimes fractious exchange over the topics between Putin and EU leaders at a news conference.

Putin said his government does not fear protests, but insisted government opponents must abide by official regulations. He also blamed some violence on demonstrators.

"They don't bother me in any way," Putin said of the so-called "Dissenters' Marches" staged by Kasparov and others, which police have brutally dispersed.

The refusal of the Bush admin. to deal harshly with Putin is another in a long line of failures. But there is plenty of blame to go around. Putin has been enabled for years by several U.S. presidents, the EU, the UN, and his own citizenry. It shouldn't really surprise us that Putin, an ex-KGB agent, has used this as an opportunity to solidify his position as Russia's leader and to re-shape the government to meet his preferences.

Good News

Glenn Reynolds passes along some good news from Iraq:

Am still in Anbar and just went another day without hearing a single shot fired. Am out with a small group of Marines who live with a much larger group of Iraqis. I enjoy the Iraqi food more than the food at the dining facilities. Some of the Marines out here live in shipping containers. Their "toilet" is WAG bag. (Waste Alleviation and Gelling.) It's every bit as exciting as it sounds. Basically it's a little ziplock baggie -- one-time use only.

I was told that a chemical munition (artillery shell) was found within the last few days.

Today, went on a patrol with Iraqis and a couple of Marines and we talked with Iraqi villagers for a couple of hours. I got to talk with a man who was about 81. His hearing was not good, so I had to sit close. He said he worked for the British RAF here in about 1945-46. I asked him if the British treated him well and he said they treated him very well. Said he made the equivalent of about 25 cents per day but that was good money back then. There is, in fact, a British-Polish-Indian-Aussie-Kiwi cemetery nearby. (I visited and photographed many of the headstones some days ago.)

All the villagers we got to talk with were very friendly. Kids wanted their photos taken, that sort of thing. They were not asking for candy and that was nice. There was a train track nearby (looked to be in very good condition), and a locomotive turned over on its side, derailed. I asked a man what happened, and he said that about four years ago, during the war, an "Ali Baba" (thief) tried to steal the train but ran head-on into another train! He said the police caught the Ali Baba and he has no idea what happened after that.

Marines are getting along well with the locals. They wave a lot, and stop to talk. If the rest of Iraq looked like this, we could all come home!

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Prostitution Insurance

Libertarian economist Arnold Kling presents a short, concise argument against universal health care in the form of an analogy. Well worth reading. Of course, there are plenty of strong arguments in favor of universal health care. But the simple fact is that any universal health policy would not resemble Medicare. Just as in Canada and Europe, universal health care actually covers fewer treatments than under the current American system. If we keep the status quo, we will be forced to reduce benefits within the next few decades or the system will go broke. If we provide universal care, we will be forced to reduce benefits for those under Medicare/Medicaid immediately. Obviously, senior citizens and the American poor currently covered by Medicare/Medicaid won't be happy about a reduction in their benefits. But there's the tradeoff.

Of course, there are other tradeoffs as well: higher taxes, lower salaries for doctors, longer wait times for treatments, denial of treatments, and other adverse consequences. All of which are byproducts of the Canadian and European universal systems.

Wolfowitz to Resign

Probably the best move, although the situation is far more convoluted than appears on the face. I wonder if this means that Ms. Riza will get her job back.

About Time

China has decided to reform their currency controls, fight excessive liquidity, moderate their balance of payments imbalances, and temper their blistering growth - currently at nearly 12% - to prevent a debt crisis or excessive inflation.

There are several good things about this. First, it will help create a policy framework for China to continue growing at sustainable rates. Second, it will help Western countries - like the U.S. - narrow their current account deficits, which might help bring a successful conclusion to Doha. Third, it lowers the potential for China's bubble to burst, or for inflation to run roughshod over the economy, killing that country's poor. Fourth, it removes one of the last American excuses for liberalizing trade further, as China can now band together with the G-20 to force America to practice what it preaches. I think I like everything about this.

Labels: ,

Smoking Pot Leads to Gay Incest

Reefer Madness has just been supplanted.

ht to Julian Sanchez.

Labels:

Trade-Offs

The biggest problem with left-wing economic platforms is often that trade-offs are ignored. In a great article in TAP, James Galbraith makes the point exceedingly well on the topic of trade. the lesson should be clear: populists who mean well often do much more damage than good, and thinking through the full consequences of action is necessary.

UPDATE: Paul Krugman concurs.

Labels:

Thank God He's a Mormon

If Mitt Romney didn't belong to one of the wackier religions in the world, he might have a chance of being elected. This would be a bad thing, for reasons completely separate from his religious beliefs. Andrew Sullivan explains why:

Here's a fascinating interview with Sean Hannity, a man who would love the Republican candidate to campaign on torturing detainees. Of course, Fox News skews the debate by focusing entirely on the one in a million "ticking time-bomb" scenario. What else would you expect from Brit Hume? But Romney reveals in this clip that he does not believe the president is bound by the law in this question. He says that he will not provide a definition of "what is torture and what is not torture," because a president should be able to keep terror supects guessing. So he supports "enhanced interrogation techniques" and not torture, but refuses to say what the difference is. And he says the president gets to pick. And U.S. citizens are subject to this regime. The logic of Romney's position, then, is that the president can designate any human being or citizen an "enemy combatant," detain them indefinitely without charges or recourse to the courts, and torture them using any method he wishes as long as he says it's not torture and he is under no obligation to explain what torture is. This is tyranny. Period.
It is tyranny. But Sullivan needed to go one step further, and note that this is currently the official policy of the United States: torture is what Pres. Bush says it is. The tyranny already exists, and Romney is merely affirming it. as did Rudy, although he at least had the stones to come right out and say it:

"Last night's debate was about the definition of torture, and whether you — how you define torture, and I haven't changed my position one bit."

"I said, I don't think we should embrace torture, even in that situation."

"But I do think we should go right up to the limit in a situation like that. Which means enhanced techniques, aggressive techniques."

"It was quite clear in what I said, and I think honestly what Governor Romney said, that neither one of us was talking about torture. But we were talking about going further than Senator McCain was talking about."

"The technique that was being described last night [water-boarding] would not fit into the category of torture."

(bold by me)

the problem, of course, is that water-boarding is torture, no matter what Rudy's personal opinion happens to be. it is considered torture -- and therefore illegal -- by both domestic and international law. the Khmer Rouge believed it to be torture. the U.S. has tried and convicted people in past for water-boarding. the State Dept. says that it is illegal. The U.S. Army says it's illegal So it shouldn't matter what Rudy, or Romney, or Bush happens to think. Water-boarding should never be a practice of the United States, because it is against the law.

But the law is secondary to these guys. Imagining themselves as Pres. Palmer in an episode of 24 seems like a greater concern. Sullivan is right: this is tyranny.

Labels: , ,

In Which Pres. Bush Ignores the Law

James Comey, formerly No. 2 at the Justice Dept., is now on record as saying that Pres. Bush personally circumvented the Justice Dept. in ordering illegal wiretapping operations to continue. this was over the protests of Atty General Ashcroft, Deputy Atty General Comey, FBI chief Mueller, and other senior Justice Dept. officials. they all knew the wiretapping program was against the law. they all said it was against the law. they all refused to approve the plan. but other people, including the Pres.'s then-chief of staff - Andrew Card - and Alberto Gonzalez and Dick Cheney - did not care about the rule of law. their opinion was that the president was not subject to the law, and they were willing to take advantage of a morbidly ill man to codify that belief. in protest, Comey, Ashcroft, Mueller, and other Justice Dept. officials were prepared to resign en masse in protest.

but then Pres. Bush intervened. he instructed the Justice Dept. to keep their mouths shut and erect a "legal" framework for continuing the program (which has since been declared illegal by the Supreme Court). meanwhile, Madrid was attacked by terrorists. Comey, Ashcroft, and Mueller agreed to postpone their resignations while waiting for a legal review. in the end, Comey signed off on the program. in testimony, he didn't say why he changed his mind.

why did Nixon resign? oh, right; he to be impeached for participating in illegal surveillance activities. so why have we let Bush stick around? regardless of one's personal political views, the grounds for impeachment were obvious long ago. Mr. Comey's belated testimony only reinforces the point.

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

What Is Our Foreign Policy?

Michael Crowley, who is awfully cute, asks an obvious question which i have wondered about for some time now: Why does the United States ally ourselves with nations who actively sponsor terrorism, or allow terrorist groups to freely operate on their soil? Today it's Pakistan, who has nukes, a large Taliban presence, and tolerates al-Qaeda camps in their country. This, of course, says nothing about Saudi Arabia, Turkey, or Israel.

Obviously, Bush wasn't serious when he said that any nation which aids or abets terrorists is an enemy of the United States.

Pot/Kettle No. III: Idiotic Politicking Edition

Did Dick Cheney really say what he just said?

"Democrats have to be responsible for the consequences of the policy recommendations they make."
Like his policies or hate them, the fact remains: Rumsfeld has resigned; Powell has resigned; Condi has been completely ineffective and is starting to get pressure to resign; Wolfowitz has resigned from the Bush admin., and may have to resign from the World Bank; Tenet has resigned; Brownie has resigned; Miers withdrew her nomination; Ashcroft has resigned; Gonzalez will probably have to resign, and several of his top aides have already done so; the GOP lost both the House and the Senate.

In fact, the only two people who have been immune to the "consequences of the policy recommendations" they have made have been Pres. Bush and Vice-Pres. Cheney. Cheney's biggest areas of policy influence - the energy policy and Iraq War - are both unmitigated disasters. His approval ratings are in single digits. By lying about pre-war intelligence instead of actually trying to educate the citizenry of the evils and danger of Saddam, he and Pres. Bush have likely set their party back a decade or more, and have virtually guaranteed a completely Democratic federal government in '08.

For the sake of his administration, his party, and the country, Dick Cheney should keep his mouth shut.

Labels:

Thursday, May 10, 2007

Condi Implicated in Oil for Food Scandal?

It sure looks like it.

Either that, or she's a terrible leader:

According to the Volcker report, surcharges on Iraqi oil exports were introduced in August 2000 by the Iraqi state oil company, the State Oil Marketing Organization. At the time, Condoleezza Rice, now secretary of state, was a member of Chevron’s board and led its public policy committee, which oversaw areas of potential political concerns for the company.
In any case, people are starting to call for Condi's resignation, and Chevron's complicity hasn't even been officially announced yet.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, May 8, 2007

Wha?

Doug Wilson says that all inflation is theft. i'm not sure why, exactly, he thinks this, but i suspect that he simply understands nothing at all about economics. arguments more cogent than his (or his defenders in the comments) are welcome.

However, I think he comes out on top in the first round of his debate with Christopher Hitchens. amazingly, so did Al Sharpton in another debate, but for completely different reasons. perhaps Hitch should stick to politics?

Labels: , ,

Monday, May 7, 2007

Tax Gas

TNR joins the Pigou Club.

i'm attracted by the idea, but even simpler solution seems possible: cut subsidies. if Americans had to pay market prices for gasoline - as Europeans do - then they would consume less of it - as Europeans do. increasing taxes on a subsidized industry makes less sense to me than simply cutting out the subsidies. the effect is the same, but with an added plus: it reduces economic distortions instead of increasing them.

Labels: , ,

Is Sarkozy the new Thatcher?

David Bell at TNR asks the question.

Labels: ,

God Save the Queen

The Plank points us to a BBC story compiling some of more inane comments made by Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh, husband of HM Queen Elizabeth. a sampling:

During a state visit to China in 1986, he famously told a group of British students: "If you stay here much longer, you'll all be slitty-eyed".

Still throwing spears? (Question put to an Australian Aborigine during a visit in March 2002)

"Oh no, I might catch some ghastly disease." (in 1992 in Australia, when asked to stroke a Koala bear)

"Aren't most of you descended from pirates?" (in 1994, to an islander in the Cayman Islands)

"You managed not to get eaten, then?" (in 1998, to a student who had been trekking in Papua New Guinea)
Eddie Izzard had a very funny bit along these lines in, i think, Dress to Kill (it may have been Glorious; i can't find an online vid.).

i simply do not understand what the American people hold the ridiculous British royal institution in such high regard. for that matter, i don't understand why the British do.

Labels:

Sunday, May 6, 2007

A Book I Desperate Need

The Joy of Drinking by Barbara Holland, reviewed in today NY Times.

a great bit:

She reminds us that in 1787, two days before their work was done, the 55 delegates to the Constitutional Convention “adjourned to a tavern for some rest, and according to the bill they drank 54 bottles of Madeira, 60 bottles of claret, 8 of whiskey, 22 of port, 8 of hard cider and 7 bowls of punch so large that, it was said, ducks could swim around in them. Then they went back to work and finished founding the new Republic.” Note the 55 delegates and 54 bottles of Madeira. Which founder was slacking?

Labels:

Sarkozy Wins

apparently, voter turnout was very high, and Sarkozy won by a big margin. i'm actually kind of surprised by how pleased i am at the news. To the extent that France has problems, Ms. Royal was not the person to fix them.

Labels:

Saturday, May 5, 2007

Pobre Paris

Good Klein has got it right. The rich shouldn't be able to buy their way through the justice system. Because that would be, y'know, unjust.

The country we live in allows one to up-grade one's jail room for a fee of ~ $82/day. A quirk of the system which, I assume, Ms. Hilton will take full advantage of.

Labels:

Season. Over.

ugh.

After a month's wait and two failed postponements, the Cardinals on Saturday confirmed former Cy Young Award winner Chris Carpenter will undergo surgery to alleviate what the club has described as an impingement of his right elbow.

Carpenter will miss at least the next three months, according to the release, which stated "no timetable has been set for his return."

to be perfectly honest, any right-thinking StL fan probably saw this coming. and it's probably for the best: after re-upping Carp for another 5 years, the Cards can't risk some major damage. a torn ligament might take 18 months to repair, and Carp's already had Tommy John surgery once.

the real problem with the team, of course, is the offense. the team is averaging under 3 runs/game. if you take out three bizarro Sunday games in which the team scored 10 or more runs, the average offensive output is ~ 2 runs per game. Carp or no Carp, you're not going to win that way.

i'd suggest re-building, but the team doesn't really have any way to do it. obviously Pujols is untouchable. Rolen probably should be, although his complete lack of production makes the point moot: if he's not producing, nobody will want him. if he is, then we need to keep him. beyond those two and Wainwright/Reyes, i don't know who is tradeable. surely nobody would bite for Eckstein, Kennedy, Molina, Edmonds, or Encarnacion. and those are the guys we need to replace. Izzy might have some value, but that's about all.

it's still early, but i'm afraid that this year is already lost. and barring an impact signing or two (or three), next year may be as well.

ugh.

Labels:

The French Are Not Happy

So says Will Wilkinson, over at Free Exchange. And he knows why:

Why so glum? The numbers show that high average incomes, a low unemployment rate, extensive economic freedom, and relatively open labor markets tend to boost happiness levels, while generous welfare handouts, lower levels of inequality, and bigger government have little or no positive effect. The areas where the French do relatively well, such as low inequality and size of government, tend not to make its people feel much better, while the areas where they do poorly, such as unemployment and economic freedom, take a real bite out of happiness.
Apparently, this lack of happiness has turned to self-loathing:

The French dislike themselves even more than the Americans dislike them, according to an opinion poll published on Friday.
To combat this phenomenon, Ms. Royal has said that France will burn if Mr. Sarkozy is elected president:

France risks violence and brutality if right-winger Nicolas Sarkozy wins Sunday's presidential election, his Socialist opponent Segolene Royal said on Friday.

On the last day of official campaigning, opinion polls showed Sarkozy enjoyed a commanding lead over Royal, who accused the former interior minister of lying and polarizing France.

"Choosing Nicolas Sarkozy would be a dangerous choice," Royal told RTL radio.

"It is my responsibility today to alert people to the risk of (his) candidature with regards to the violence and brutality that would be unleashed in the country (if he won)," she said.

Hmm.

Labels: