Sunday, September 23, 2007

Words of Wisdom from Joseph Schumpeter

From a Reason Magazine review of Thomas McCraw's Prophet of Innovation: Joseph Schumpeter and Creative Destruction:

“Capitalism stands its trial before judges who have the death sentence in their pockets,” wrote Schumpeter. “The only success a victorious defense can possibly produce is a change in the indictment.” Thus the major indictment of capitalism by the socialists of the 1850s was for immiserating the working people. When this proved scientifically wrong, the socialists of the 1890s indicted it for imperialism. When that too proved wrong, at any rate by the lights of the best economic scientists who troubled to look into the matter (among them Joseph Schumpeter), the socialists of the 1950s indicted it for alienation. When this accusation seemed less fresh, the socialists of the 1990s indicted it for environmental decay. Schumpeter wrote that “such refutation,” rationally proving the latest indictment wrong, “may tear the rational garb of attack [on capitalism and all its work] but can never reach the extra-rational driving power that always lurks behind it.”
Schumpeter, like Marx, believed that the collapse of capitalism was inevitable for sociological reasons. Schumpeter rued this perceived reality, Marx celebrated it. Were it not for Hayek and Friedman, they both might have been right (and they might still be). But the lesson here is to watch the shifting rhetoric of anti-capitalists. If they are unsuccessful with one attack, they will simply move to another one, hoping to overwhelm people with accusations until they start believing they are true.

They keep cycling back through the list -- immiseration of workers, imperialism, inequalities, environmental collapse -- as needed, neglecting history and scientific study in favor of rhetoric and ideology. Schumpeter recognized this early on, and his words still carry much weight today.

Labels: ,

Friday, September 21, 2007

Did Syria Get Nukes from N. Korea?

Umm... maybe. Kevin Drum notices some weird press coverage:

I don't know how closely you've all been following the story of the Israeli air strike in Syria a couple of weeks ago, but in one of the initial accounts of the raid the New York Times slipped in a suggestion that it was actually aimed at a nuclear installation that had been imported from North Korea. It was kind of weird because this allegation popped up casually in about the seventh paragraph of the story and then popped back out without a trace.

Since then the nuclear story has continued to putter along in the background, but most observers have discounted it. The consensus seemed to be that it was just some garden variety saber rattling, maybe from Cheney's shop, and in fact the raid was actually a test of Syrian air defenses or perhaps a dry run for attacking Iran. Or a raid against a Hezbollah weapons dump. Or something.

Well, maybe so. But today the Washington Post has a long front-page story that puts the nuclear scenario front and center again. The whole thing is still murky, since everyone seems to agree that it doesn't really make sense, but it's now pretty hard to ignore. Either someone is dead serious about planting some disinformation about a Syria-North Korea nuclear connection in the press, or else there really is such a connection. I don't know what to think about it myself, but it's now officially a story to follow.

Indeed.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

The state of the German Economy

Megan McArdle contradicts Dean Baker, and makes the case that Germany isn't doing all that well, relative to the U.S. Countering Baker is a dangerous game, but I think she is right. The future could look much worse for Germany, but it could also look much better.

Labels: , ,

Politically Incorrect Blogging

Alex Tabarrok points us to a study indicating that Bill Cosby may have been right:

Several years ago Bill Cosby chided poor blacks for spending their limited incomes on high-priced shoes and other items of conspicuous consumption instead of investing in education. Cosby was widely criticized but I went to the numbers, specifically Table 2100 of the Consumer Expenditure Survey and found the following for 2003:

Average income of whites and other races: $53,292.
Average income of blacks: $34,485.

Expenditures on footwear by whites and other races: $274
Expenditures on footwear by blacks: $440.


As I noted then "to do a proper comparison we would have to correct for income and other demographic variables." The correction has now been done by three researchers in an NBER working paper (non-gated version). The results didn't surprise me. How about you?

Using nationally representative data on consumption, we show that Blacks and Hispanics devote larger shares of their expenditure bundles to visible goods (clothing, jewelry, and cars) than do comparable Whites. We demonstrate that these differences exist among virtually all sub-populations, that they are relatively constant over time, and that they are economically large.

To give the authors credit where credit is due they also show that the differences in conspicuous consumption are large and important. The differences in spending on clothing, jewelry, and cars, for example, can explain half of the differences in wealth between the races (conditional on permanent income) and a significant share of the differences in education and health spending.

This is indeed significant: half the differences in wealth accumulation between the races are explained by this phenomenon (so it isn't all George W. Bush's fault after all, I guess). Tabarrok guesses that this is best explained in terms of signaling: an upper-middle-class white collar worker receives less of a marginal social benefit from conspicuous consumption than do lower-class citizens. Since average incomes for whites are higher, whites may be less inclined as a group to spend it all on physical goods in order to convey status; instead, they may spend it on getting their child into a high-profile private school, or on a larger suburban home. Meanwhile, blacks may be more inclined as a group to purchase goods which convey outward signs of high status such as cars, clothes, and jewelry.

In other words, Brad DeLong might be right: much of our consumption might be nothing more than a hopped-up East African plains ape pissing contest.

Labels: ,

The Descent Into Authoritarianism Continues

Chavez threatens to take over private schools, installs a new curriculum to educate the "new citizen," and will nationalize any private schools which resist.

Venezuela is in trouble. Big, big trouble.

Labels: ,

New Poll of Iraqis

An interesting new poll of Iraqis gives some interesting results:

The results of the poll reflect a great degree of dissatisfaction with the US "surge", with a vast majority of respondents considering the move to have made the situation in the country worse rather than better.

...

The latest poll data reflects a slight increase in the number of respondents who consider al-Qaeda and foreign jihadis responsible for fomenting violence.

There was a significant reduction from February to August 2007 in the numbers who believe that the US and coalition forces are mainly to blame.

...

The autumn 2007 poll reflects growing disillusionment with the occupying forces' presence in Iraq. There is a growing consensus among respondents that coalition troops should leave the country immediately.

Some 47% of respondents now back an immediate withdrawal, compared with 35% in February.

...

One of starkest statistics from the poll is the overwhelming support for attacks on coalition forces among Iraq's minority Sunni population; 93% of those surveyed said they considered it acceptable. By the same majority - 93% - respondents reject violence against Iraqi forces.

The polls aren't as clear-cut as they might seem at first glance. For example, in the second graph, many fewer respondents thought in Aug. '07 that the U.S. government is responsible for the violence in Iraq than thought the same in Feb. '07. The shift is actually pretty striking. So, if the people think that violence has gone up, but fewer people think that the U.S. is to blame for it... it's a bit of a mixed message. Similarly, the number of those who think that al-Qaeda/foreign jihadis are responsible for the uptick in violence has increased from Feb. to Aug., as has the number of those who blame their own government. The number of those who blame "sectarian disputes" has also sharply decreased, which is a good sign for those still hoping for some sort of sectarian reconciliation.

Perhaps most tellingly, 47% of Iraqis support immediate withdrawal of U.S. forces... but 53% don't, preferring the U.S. to stay "until security is restored" or some variant of the same. Those in favor of immediate withdrawal have increased their numbers since Feb., but they are still the minority. this is a key point.

Strikingly, 93% of Iraqis think that attacks against Iraqi troops are not justified, while 57% think that attacks against U.S. troops are justified (although those numbers are heavily skewed by Sunnis). Only 18% of Sunnis think attacks against Iraqi troops are justified, despite the fact that these troops are majorly comprised of Shiites. Other questions yield similarly mixed results.

The upshot: Sunnis say they want a strong unified state (but have largely boycotted the central gov't, indicating that they want some other type of strong unified state than is currently in place), Shia split their support between a strongly unified state or a confederal system, while the Kurds want their independence. This is the primary crux of the political problem... reconciling those three views. But, as we can tell, partition isn't going to fix it, since the Sunnis would be inclined to continue violence until reunification occurred. Similarly, the Kurds seem unlikely to cede regional autonomy under any system. These views have nothing to do with President Bush or the invasion; they are influenced by history and culture and the current security dilemmas and credible commitment problems.

Perhaps the strongest thing to take away from this poll is that Iraqis don't really like being dominated by foreigners, be they jihadists or Americans. This signifies that there is still a strong sense of national unity, even though it clearly manifests itself in different ways. Still, that's really positive; perhaps it can be built on. We've seen snippets of this at other times, like when the Iraqi soccer team won the Asian Cup. The outward displays of nationalism was impossible to miss.

Still, and as always in Iraq, the truth of the situation is much more nuanced than a quick glance would indicate. But there appears to still be some hope buried in these poll numbers.


Labels:

Multilateralism? What Multilateralism?

Dani Rodrik calls the efficacy and legitimacy of the IMF into question, calling it a tool of the U.S.:

Mark Thoma brings up IMF' new policy of surveillance on exchange-rate policies and quotes from a piece by IMF Managing Director Rodrigo de Rato on the subject. He refers to an earlier post of mine and encourages me to return to the topic as I had promised.

I will do that at some point, but for the moment let me just point to the obvious hypocrisy at work here. Rato writes:

This reform represents a victory for multilateralism that demonstrates ownership of how Fund surveillance will be strengthened and members' willingness to live up to their responsibilities in the process.

A victory for multilateralism? He has got to be kidding. The new policy was instituted at the behest of the United States, with the express purpose of bringing pressure on the Chinese.

And when the IMF staff took "multilateralism" seriously and reported its view that the dollar was overvalued, they were told to mind their own business and not to meddle with U.S. policies. So while we shall see plenty of reports coming out of the IMF on the undervalued Remninbi, don't expect anything on the dollar soon.



This in the face of the Obama/Clinton legislation to put tariffs on China unless they allow the value of the RMB to rise. The logical shortcomings of U.S. policy is astounding. After all, imagine the U.S. reaction is the E.U. threatened sanctions unless we allowed the value of the dollar to further depreciate. The difference, of course, is that the dollar is a major international reserve currency, so depreciation could more severely hurt holders of dollars, and those are not limited to citizens of the U.S. (tho they certainly include citizens of the U.S., particularly those who get more value from imports than exports). But it's even worse for us, because the Chinese hold a lot of U.S. debt. If the value of the RMB rises relative to the dollar, then servicing that debt becomes more expensive for us. So Obama and Clinton are essentially begging China to increase our debt burden and increase our costs of living, or else they are threatening to do it for them. Remarkably stupid.

The IMF needs independence to be productive and credible. The U.S. needs a consistent policy to maintain credibility. The Chinese are looking at us and wondering what the hell we're thinking.

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, September 15, 2007

In Which Bono Kills African Babies

Ah, if only it were true:

Labels:

Is the Surge Working?

The answer to that question heavily depends on the metric one is using. In one sense, Pres. Bush and his defenders are right: violence is down in Baghdad and Anbar, and there isn't any corresponding increase in other regions. In another, Pres. Bush's detractors are also correct: this decrease in violence has not led to social improvements (i.e. the power still isn't on; unemployment is still very high; the oil is still not being pumped), and the fact that the violence has decreased might be more correlation than causation anyway.

Michael Greenstone, an economist as MIT, has recently concluded a study on the matter. He acknowledges the security and military successes of the surge, but finds an interesting result:

This paper shows how data from world financial markets can be used to shed light on the central question of whether the Surge has increased or diminished the prospect of today's Iraq surviving into the future. In particular, I examine the price of Iraqi state bonds, which the Iraqi government is currently servicing, on world financial markets. After the Surge, there is a sharp decline in the price of those bonds, relative to alternative bonds. The decline signaled a 40% increase in the market's expectation that Iraq will default. This finding suggests that to date the Surge is failing to pave the way toward a stable Iraq and may in fact be undermining it.
Financial markets represent the aggregated common wisdom of those who are willing to put their money where their mouth/brain is. Couple this with the fact that some foreign oil companies are making deals directly with the Kurdish regional government, rather than the national Iraqi government, and the consensus in the financial sector seems to be that the chance of the a collapse of the Iraqi government have gone up in the past 6-7 months. Obviously this process may have been underway well before the surge began. But it doesn't appear that the surge has been successful in obviating this risk.

Political commentators would be wise to take note; it's never a good idea to bet against the financial markets.

(ht: Freakonomics)

Labels: ,

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Iraqi Oil Deal Disintegrating?

Some discouraging news from Baghdad:

A carefully constructed compromise on a draft law governing Iraq’s rich oil fields, agreed to in February after months of arduous talks among Iraqi political groups, appears to have collapsed. The apparent breakdown comes just as Congress and the White House are struggling to find evidence that there is progress toward reconciliation and a functioning government here.

Senior Iraqi negotiators met in Baghdad on Wednesday in an attempt to salvage the original compromise, two participants said. But the meeting came against the backdrop of a public series of increasingly strident disagreements over the draft law that had broken out in recent days between Hussain al-Shahristani, the Iraqi oil minister, and officials of the provincial government in the Kurdish north, where some of the nation’s largest fields are located.

Mr. Shahristani, a senior member of the Arab Shiite coalition that controls the federal government, negotiated the compromise with leaders of the Kurdish and Arab Sunni parties. But since then, the Kurds have pressed forward with a regional version of the law that Mr. Shahristani says is illegal. Many of the Sunnis who supported the original deal have also pulled out in recent months.

The oil law — which would govern how oil fields are developed and managed — is one of several benchmarks that the Bush administration has been pressing the Iraqis to meet as a sign that they are making headway toward creating an effective government.

Again and again in the past year, agreement on the law has been fleetingly close before political and sectarian disagreements have arisen to stall the deal.

One of the participants in Wednesday’s meeting, Deputy Prime Minister Barham Salih, who has worked for much of the past year to push for the original compromise, said some progress had been made at the meeting, but that he could not guarantee success.

“This has been like a roller coaster,” said Mr. Salih, who is Kurdish. “There were occasions where we seemed to be there, where we seemed to have closure, only to fail at that.”

“Given the seriousness of the issue, I don’t want to create false expectations, but I can say there is serious effort to bring this to closure,” he said.

This isn't a good thing, but it may not be as catastrophic as some commentators seem to think. After all, this is a legislative battle, not a military one. This sort of compromise will be perpetually necessary if the Iraqi government is to generate and sustain any sort of legitimacy. The fact that the sides seem pretty close to a deal, and in fact had a tentative agreement in place, points positively to the fact that negotiations are taking place. The negative aspect, of course, is that these negotiations have not led to any legislation at this point. But the same could be said of the recent U.S. immigration battles, or Congress' inability to pass resolutions asking the President to withdraw combat troops from Iraq, or any number of other pieces of legislation that ended up DOA.

This is the nitty-gritty of representative democracies. This is a real and substantive test of the strength and validity of the Iraqi government. If they can eventually produce an oil-sharing agreement that has broad-based support from all sides, then the government may be on a path towards relevance. If not, then the ballgame is over. But the fact that this is taking a long time doesn't mean that there is no chance for a positive result. The legislative game is slow; reaching agreement takes a lot of time. We should continue to pressure the Iraqis to come to agreement as quickly as they can, but we must do so while recognizing that oil is the most important issue in Iraq, and this is the first experiment with such far-reaching legislation in the nation's history. Realistic expectations are necessary.

Labels:

Now That's What I Call Leadership

AP headline: "Thompson gives no opinion on Schiavo". Thompson's excuse? It was sooo long ago:

"I can't pass judgment on it. I know that good people were doing what they thought was best," Thompson said. "That's going back in history. I don't remember the details of it."
Despite the fact that Thompson is apparently an actual candidate now, I still get the feeling that he is remarkably unconcerned about, y'know, stuff. After all, he announced his candidacy on a late-night comedy show, has not issued any policy proposals, and is best known as a side character on a network drama despite several decades in public office. I'll need something more substantive before I begin to take him seriously. For now, I'm assuming that his presidential candidacy is a P.R. attempt to bolster his acting career, and not the other way 'round.

Then again, everyone else in the GOP field is so vulnerable that such a bland candidate might have a chance. He might be so unoffensive that he ends up with the nomination. After all, no substantive record + no actual views on anything + no policy proposals = no major downsides. That might be good enough to win the GOP this time through.

Labels:

Why No Attacks?

Megan McArdle finds Amy Zegart warning people not to jump to conclusions -- like, the Bush admin. anti-terrorism policy must be working because we haven't had any terrorist attacks since 9/11 -- since causality is much different than correlation. Ms. McArdle runs through other possibilities unrelated to Bush's policies to explain why attacks might not have occurred, mostly demographic, attitudinal, and legal factors, but ignores one big one: we have been attacked. Not "we" as in the U.S. proper, but I think it's silly to assume that the U.S. proper is al-Qaeda's only target. It isn't. But there have been attacks in the U.K., Spain, Afghanistan, Iraq, and many developing countries. Not all of these are directly associated with al-Qaeda (tho some probably are), but they are representative of the larger jihadist movement. Part of this was bin Laden's intent: to radicalize other Muslims, even if it wasn't under his banner specifically.

The U.S. is too isolated for a lot of attacks on the mainland. But our allies have been hit, as have other regimes that jihadists despise. This fact is often lost, but it shouldn't be.

Elsewhere, Ms. McArdle has a pretty strong primer on taxes, how they influence incentives, and why tax deductions are worse than tax cuts.

Labels: ,

The Mysterious FED Actions

Robert Barro e-mails Greg Mankiw to let him know that the effective FED funds rate for the month of August was 5.02%, or 23 base points lower than its declared target. I knew this was going on, but I hadn't see the official numbers. (At one point, I'd read that the funds rate was 4.88%, but I didn't realize that it was under 5.25%, on average, for the whole month). There are several ways of interpreting this.

1. The FED wants to tell the markets that it is serious about controlling inflation, so it hasn't yet changed the official rate. But it also wants to tell the markets -- and especially the big bankers -- that it is serious about preventing a credit crunch, so it has given itself a lot of flexibility to deviate from the official rate for short periods of time.

2. The FED can't effectively control the funds rate anymore.

3. The FOMC has become unhinged from the FED board of governors.

4. The FED is preparing for an official rate cut this fall, but didn't want to wait until then to quiet the markets and ensure short-term liquidity.

5. The FED is not preparing for an official rate cut this fall, but didn't want to freak out bankers who were already concerned about a lack of liquidity.

6. The FED wanted to signal to some key players in the economy (e.g. big bankers) that it would help keep the ship afloat, but didn't want everyone to become too expectant of the FED to come bail them all out, so it allowed the effective rate to temporarily drop.

7. A temporary effective decrease allowed the FED to postpone a decision about whether or not to officially lower the funds rate until a later date, while they got more information about the overall state of the economy and watched to see the extent of the subprime meltdown. All this without committing to any substantive action.

I think that #s 1, 6, & 7 are extremely likely; #s 4 & 5 are fairly likely, and one of the two (but not both) are likely true; #s 2 & 3 are extremely unlikely. But I could very easily be wrong about any and all of this.

Update: Megan McArdle hopes that the FED is just fooling us, but seems to place a much higher probability on the possibility that the FED has lost control of monetary policy than I do. For the most part, I'm operating under the assumption that the FED knows what it's doing, knows what it wants to do, and is able to execute that strategy. But it is a possibility that monetary policy has become unhinged from typical controls. That would be very, very bad. I don't think that's happened, but it is possible.

Labels:

R.I.P., Abdul-Sattar Abu Risha

He may not have been the world's nicest guy, but there are a serious lack of them in Iraq right now. He was a pragmatic leader, and empowering him -- and other Sunni tribal leaders -- as a counter-balancing force to the Shiite militias is the best chance we've got for creating any sort of lasting peace and working government. Hopefully, Abdul-Sattar's murder will galvanize others to take his place, will elicit sympathy from those previously predisposed against him, and lead to a stronger push against terrorism and for political solutions.

I'm not necessarily hopeful that this will happen, but it's worth hoping for.

Labels:

Adios, GOP

All the Republican candidates for president (except John McCain) refused to participate in a Univision-sponsored debate en espanol. Probably because all of them (except John McCain, who supports more lax immigration laws) are too cowardly to have to explain -- to their faces -- why they want to keep Spanish-speaking people a chance to lift themselves out of poverty by chasing the American Dream.

The Democrats already had their debate on Univision. The fact that the GOP won't will hurt them politically. Their stance on immigrations ("it's illegal!") has already clipped them ethically. It's pretty disgusting, really, and it could cost the GOP elections for generations.

Labels:

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Political Upheaval in Japan

Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe suddenly announced his resignation. He was a proponent of close ties with the U.S., a stronger political and military presence in Asia, and a constitutional amendment to allow the use of Japanese military forces for non-defensive purposes. His was strongly criticized by China and other regional powers for this stance, and his popularity has sunk in his own country, which seems more concerned with Japan's economy in general, and with the ability of the government to live up to its pension commitments to its elderly in particular. The nation has aged in recent decades, and the economy has stagnated. The repercussions from his resignation may lead to widespread reorganization of the government, and a clear shifting of mandate.

It's possible that a similar political situation may face the United States in coming decades. We'll have to wait and see.

Labels:

Wal-Mart's PR Makeover

Wal-Mart has a new slogan: "Save Money. Live Better." Who knows if it will resonate with the larger population, but I like it. It really gets at the positive aspects of Wal-mart (specifically) and international trade (generally). Namely, that our standards of living improve as we specialize in our comparative advantages and trade with each other. That's not to say to say that there aren't trade-offs, but in the aggregate, standards of living do improve. The "low prices" mantra means less in an age of low inflation and broad big-box market dominance. But people sometimes need to be reminded of the contributions Wal-mart and the other massive retailers make to society; the fact remains that the net effects of Wal-mart are positive, and probably massively so.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, September 11, 2007

Why Is Income Inequality Increasing?

According to a new Brookings study by Claudia Goldin and Lawrence Katz, much of the increase in income inequality is due to an increase in the education premium:

Another key point we will make is that the majority of the increase in wage inequality since the 1980 has come from rising education wage differentials, particularly rising returns to post-secondary schooling.
This disputes earlier research blaming skill-based technological change, or more surplus going to capital, or whatever. It also disputes Paul Krugman's assertion that it is all George W. Bush's fault. It's a perfect example of how convoluted economics can be, especially when you are looking for policy implications.

Labels: ,

Neuro-Politics Blogging

Apparently, the brains of liberals function differently than the brains of conservatives.

Conservatives tend to crave order and structure in their lives, and are more consistent in the way they make decisions. Liberals, by contrast, show a higher tolerance for ambiguity and complexity, and adapt more easily to unexpected circumstances.

The affinity between political views and "cognitive style" has also been shown to be heritable, handed down from parents to children, said the study, published in the British journal Nature Neuroscience.

Labels:

Thursday, September 6, 2007

Not this again

For some reason, people are still arguing over supply-side economics (particularly, the Laffer curve). This centers on a new book by TNR senior editor Jonathan Chait, who has a forth-coming book entitled The Big Con: The True Story of How Washington Got Hoodwinked and Hijacked by Crackpot Economics (an excerpt may be found here). This book was great when Paul Krugman wrote it in the early-90s as a criticism of Reaganomics (Peddling Prosperity), but the current crop of GOP fiscal idiots don't follow the same pattern. Well, I don't know. The point -- just how influential is extreme supply-side economics these days -- is being debated all over the blogosphere.

Megan McArdle says that Chait's case is "overblown". Matthew Yglesias disagrees, and quotes a bunch of people (Bush, Cheney, etc.) spouting off supply-side nonsense. McArdle rejoinders by accusing Chait (and Ezra Klein, who had come to Chait's defense) of setting up supply-siders as straw men, knocking them down, and then concluding that tax cuts aren't a good idea. Yglesias responds by saying that Chait hasn't done this at all. Brad DeLong and Mark Thoma take Yglesias' side. Tyler Cowen takes McArdle's. Greg Mankiw thanks McArdle for defending him and Glenn Hubbard from inappropriate accusations.

It's weird, because the question isn't whether or not extreme supply-siders, inspired by the Laffer curve, are right or wrong when they say that tax cuts will pay for themselves by boosting economic growth enough to boost government revenues. Everyone agrees that this is ludicrous. The question isn't even over whether or not tax cuts can be good for economic growth. Everyone agrees that this is true. The question isn't even whether or not tax cuts can improve economic growth enough to for themselves in the context of the entire economy. Everyone agrees that this is true. The question is: how influential is the Laffer curve in the GOP leadership?

My guess, although it's impossible to know for sure, is that the idea might still hold some sway among late-70s/early-80s true believers left over from the Reagan administration (e.g. Cheney), or among people who don't know anything at all about economics (e.g. Bush), but that the idea is completely devoid of intellectual backing at this point. There aren't any notable economists who support extreme supply-siderism (that i know of), and I'd be willing to wager that even the Cheneys and Bushes of the world know that the things they say are untrue (or, at least, are possibly untrue).

So... the divergence. McArdle (and Cowen) sees the complete lack of intellectual support for these ideas on the right, and conclude that the ideas are no longer influential. Chait and Yglesias see the words of the national leadership of the GOP giving lip-service to these ideas, and conclude that they still hold sway. Who is right?

Neither, really. Well, both, I guess. Yglesias backs into it:

Meanwhile, the reason people like Jon and I and other liberals spend so much time pointing out that this claim is false is precisely the same as the reason conservatives spend so much time defending it: it's an extremely potent political claim.
McArdle's right; supply-siderism is no longer intellectually influential. The Yglesias/Chait contingent is also right: these things are still in the political discussion, and the Bush admin. still uses them as potent political weapons to convince voters to pass tax cuts. The Bush admin. doesn't actually believe that the tax cuts will pay for themselves, but a lot of other people do. And plus, if they can convince people of it, then the opposition for tax cuts disappears. The trade-off is gone... tax cuts come with no downside.

Alex Tabarrok issues a challenge to Yglesias, et al:

Following Jon Chait, Matt Yglesias writes:

...the central element of the Republican Party's tax policy -- lower taxes rates will lead to higher tax revenues -- is a discredited crackpot notion.

Fine, but a more fruitful question which I'd like to see Yglesias, Chait and others grapple with is why discredited, crackpot ideas can become central elements of a winning political party in the world's most important democracy. Explain the demand side and give us your policy prescriptions.

I answer him, and the underlying debate, in the comments:

Alex -

I assume you've read Caplan's book? I think you'll find your answer there. Unfortunately, there is no workable "policy prescription" which will make voters rational alluvasudden. The work of the reality-based economists and politicos is to educate people to the *true* costs and benefits of policy, and punish those who knowingly lie about them.

everyone acknowledges that the Laffer curve does exist. The question is, which side of the curve are we on? The GOP folks that Yglesias is talking about have a prior assumption that tax cuts (esp. the top marginal rates) are always a good end, but they recognize that this is a normative judgment which isn't universally persuasive. so, to gain support for their preferred policies, they engage in intellectual dishonesty by arguing that the U.S. economy is on the right side of the Laffer peak, when in fact we are on the left side of it.

Right-wing economists who are not intellectually dishonest -- like Greg Mankiw and Glenn Hubbard -- do not do this. They acknowledge that, given the economic realities in the U.S., further tax cuts will not pay for themselves; they are in favor of tax cuts despite what they will do to federal revenues, because they believe that tax cuts are good things in and of themselves. But their bosses don't think that this is a politically feasible argument, so they lie and deceive. This drives left-wing economists (e.g. "Rubinomics" folks) and left-wing literate politicos absolutely batty, and understandably so. They are prevented from having a debate on the merits, because the extreme supply-siders won't acknowledge reality before coming to the debate.

Yglesias (and Chait) are not arguing against Mankiw; they are arguing against the WSJ editorial page, the Heritage Foundation, Pres. Bush, V.P. Cheney, etc.

Labels: ,

Another Blow to Bush

A federal judge has struck down the provision in the PATRIOT Act allowing the federal government to demand the internet records of Americans from internet service providers without notifying their customers or obtaining a court order. The judge rightfully ruled that the provision "offends the fundamental Constitutional principles of checks and balances and separation of powers".

This is another example of the judiciary working to restrain the authoritarian impulses of the Bush administration, despite Congress' unwillingness to do so. I'm sure the ruling will be challenged, and will probably end up in the Supreme Court. But the basic principle is sound: the President ought not be able to spy on American citizens without oversight.

Labels: ,

Giuliani Gets Swift-Boated, pt. 2

The hits keep on coming, for Giuliani. A couple of months ago, a group of NYC firefighters blasted Rudy for not providing them with proper equipment, causing excess deaths of firefighters on 9/11. Now, a new film critically examines Rudy's 9/11 record.

The videos attack Giuliani by saying he failed to prepare New York City for a major disaster, he ignored sick ground zero workers after the terrorist attack and he profited financially from his association with the tragedy after leaving office in 2001.

"We want to use this forum to reach people and show and tell and say, 'Look here are some truths that we want you to know,'" Greenwald told The Associated Press. The video blitz has an accompanying web site, therealrudy.org.

So far, Rudy's teflon-like ability to deflect criticism on any and all issues by relying on his True American Hero status has served him well. But if his 9/11 cred begins to erode, it will be difficult for him to sustain any political momentum. At least, that's what I'm hoping.

Labels:

Wednesday, September 5, 2007

The Trouble with Constraining Markets

Economists recognize that restricting labor mobility causes market distortions just as restricting capital mobility does. They also recognize that current U.S. immigration policy does just that. There may be proper reasons for limiting the amount of immigrants allowed into the country. These might include social stability, national security, or predatory usage of our welfare system. But limiting access to U.S. labor markets to foreign workers does a disservice not only to them, but also to domestic producers. This, in turn, does a disservice to all Americans. The NY Times has an illustrative article:

Steve Scaroni, a farmer from California, looked across a luxuriant field of lettuce here in central Mexico and liked what he saw: full-strength crews of Mexican farm workers with no immigration problems.

Farming since he was a teenager, Mr. Scaroni, 50, built a $50 million business growing lettuce and broccoli in the fields of California, relying on the hands of immigrant workers, most of them Mexican and many probably in the United States illegally.

But early last year he began shifting part of his operation to rented fields here. Now some 500 Mexicans tend his crops in Mexico, where they run no risk of deportation.

“I’m as American red-blood as it gets,” Mr. Scaroni said, “but I’m tired of fighting the fight on the immigration issue.”

A sense of crisis prevails among American farmers who rely on immigrant laborers, more so since immigration legislation in the United States Senate failed in June and the authorities announced a crackdown on employers of illegal immigrants. An increasing number of farmers have been testing the alternative of raising crops across the border where there is a stable labor supply, growers and lawmakers in the United States and Mexico said.

The gut reactions of ill-informed observers might be to belittle American producers who move across the border. But this would be disingenuous. The producers are responding as one should expect: they are responding to incentives. The government of United States is to blame for not creating a viable immigration policy that provides "liquidity" to labor markets. The resulting frictions are the result of the market distortion... not the other way around.

Labels: , ,

Iraqi Police Not Doing Well

In fact, there are doing so poorly that a study led by fmr. Marine Core Gen. James Jones suggests that they should be disbanded. Ouch:

Iraq's security forces will be unable to take control of the country in the next 18 months, and Baghdad's national police force is so rife with corruption it should be scrapped entirely, according to a new independent assessment.

...

The report also offers a scathing assessment of Baghdad's Ministry of Interior and recommends scrapping Iraq's national police force, which it describes as dysfunctional and infiltrated by militias.

These units "have the potential to help reduce sectarian violence, but ultimately the (Iraq Security Force) will reflect the society from which they are drawn," according to the report, a copy of which was obtained by The Associated Press. "Political reconciliation is the key to ending sectarian violence in Iraq."


The military, however, is doing better.

The 20-member panel of mostly retired senior military and police officers concludes that Iraq's military, in particular its Army, shows the most promise of becoming a viable, independent security force with time. But the group predicts an adequate logistics system to support these ground forces is at least another two years away.

Labels:

Monday, September 3, 2007

Thomas Barnett Blogging

Barnett begins his column this week by citing Krueger's study "What Makes a Terrorist," ties that to the idea that the way to fight global terrorism is to foster the growth and strengthening of the middle classes in developing countries, esp. those with authoritarian governments (i.e. almost all of the MidEast). The upshot:

In the end, it’s true that politics explains terrorism, but likewise that economics explains politics.

This long war requires long efforts, not seductive shortcuts.

The United States should be in the business of applying both its hard and soft power assets toward the same end: defending and extending globalization’s spread. Feed stomachs and wallets first, and then hearts and minds will follow.

Elsewhere, Barnett is interviewed at Time's China blog. Nothing especially revelatory, but still interesting.

Labels: , , ,

Interesting Bush Revelation

Buried in a mostly-inconsequential article on Bush's state of mind last December, and his plans for the future, there is a very interesting anecdote:

Mr. Bush acknowledged one major failing of the early occupation of Iraq when he said of disbanding the Saddam Hussein-era military, “The policy was to keep the army intact; didn’t happen.”

But when Mr. Draper pointed out that Mr. Bush’s former Iraq administrator, L. Paul Bremer III, had gone ahead and forced the army’s dissolution and then asked Mr. Bush how he reacted to that, Mr. Bush said, “Yeah, I can’t remember, I’m sure I said, ‘This is the policy, what happened?’ ” But, he added, “Again, Hadley’s got notes on all of this stuff,” referring to Stephen J. Hadley, his national security adviser.

It would be nice to actually see those notes, but the point is important. Earlier in the piece, Bush takes full responsibility for the decision to go to war in Iraq ("This group-think of ‘we all sat around and decided’ — there’s only one person that can decide, and that’s the president"), but apparently delegated all authority over the occupation to Bremer, to the point that he was actually surprised and dismayed by Bremer's management. It's amazing to me that Bush was so disconnected from the actual policy decisions of the CPA, and it may have doomed the entire Iraq enterprise. The decision to put all authority in the hands of Bremer instead of splitting it with Khalilzad as initially planned had worse ramifications than Bush could've imagined, but the decision to do so still falls on him.

So, why did Bush give Bremer the Presidential Medal of Freedom?

UPDATE: Paul Bremer calls Pres. Bush a liar. He says that Bush knew about the plan to dissolve the Iraqi army, and he's got letters to prove it:

A previously undisclosed exchange of letters shows that President Bush was told in advance by his top Iraq envoy in May 2003 of a plan to “dissolve Saddam’s military and intelligence structures,” a plan that the envoy, L. Paul Bremer, said referred to dismantling the Iraqi Army.

...

After recounting American efforts to remove members of the Baath Party of Saddam Hussein from civilian agencies, Mr. Bremer told Mr. Bush that he would “parallel this step with an even more robust measure” to dismantle the Iraq military.

One day later, Mr. Bush wrote back a short thank you letter. “Your leadership is apparent,” the president wrote. “You have quickly made a positive and significant impact. You have my full support and confidence.”

On the same day, Mr. Bremer, in Baghdad, had issued the order disbanding the Iraqi military. Mr. Bush did not mention the order to abolish the military, and the letters do not show that he approved the order or even knew much about it. Mr. Bremer referred only fleetingly to his plan midway through his three-page letter and offered no details.

...

Mr. Bremer indicated that he had been smoldering for months as other administration officials had distanced themselves from his order. “This didn’t just pop out of my head,” he said in a telephone interview on Monday, adding that he had sent a draft of the order to top Pentagon officials and discussed it “several times” with Mr. Rumsfeld.

A White House official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because the White House is not commenting on Mr. Draper’s book, said Mr. Bush indeed understood the order and was acknowledging in the interview with Mr. Draper that the original plan had proved unworkable.

“The plan was to keep the Iraqi Army intact, and that’s accurate,” the official said. “But by the time Jerry Bremer announced the order, it was fairly clear that the Iraqi Army could not be reconstituted, and the president understood that. He was acknowledging that that was something that did not go as planned.”

So let's see those notes, Mr. Hadley.

Labels: ,

N. Korea Abandons Its Nuke Program

So sayeth the Grey Lady:

The top American negotiator with North Korea said today that the country had agreed to disable its main nuclear fuel production facility by the end of the year and to account to international monitors for all of its nuclear programs, including what American intelligence agencies believe was a second, secret program purchased from Pakistan.

At the end of a two-day meeting in Geneva — exactly the kind of one-on-one session that the Bush administration had refused to hold in recent years — Christopher R. Hill, the assistant secretary of state for East Asian and Pacific affairs, said that the two sides had agreed on what would be a speedy next step, following action by the North this summer to turn off its main nuclear reactor.

“One thing that we agreed on is that the D.P.R.K. will provide a full declaration of all of their nuclear programs and will disable their nuclear programs by the end of this year, 2007,” Mr. Hill told reporters in Geneva, according to the Associated Press. He was using the initials for the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, the North’s formal name.

But in a separate news conference, his counterpart, Kim Kye-gwan, who heads the North Korean negotiating team, made no mention of an end of the year deadline. He spoke instead of an accord to disable North Korea’s equipment and provide an accounting of its facilities, fuel and weapons in return for what he called “political and economic compensation.”

A few things here. First, the Bush admin. should get credit here. In fact, this continues a series of foreign policy successes since 2001. The Iraq disaster and Iran war-mongering get all the headlines, but Bush convinced Libya to give up its nuclear program, forced the removal and arrest of A.Q. Khan (who had sold weaponry, including nuclear devices, off the shelf to Iran, Libya, N. Korea, and was trying to sell to Saddam) in Pakistan, rallied the international community to put strong pressure on Iran to give up its nuclear program, and has now bribed the D.P.R.K. into abandoning its nuclear ambitions. These are subtle victories, but substantial ones, all of which eluded Pres. Clinton. Some credit is due here.

Labels: , , ,