Monday, May 5, 2008

Gas Taxes, Meet Econ 101

McCain and Clinton want a summer cessation of the gas tax. Obama says that it is political pandering and won't help people who are hurting at the pump.

Obama is right.

When the short-term demand for a good is inelastic (meaning: short-term demand is relatively unresponsive to variations in price), as the demand for gasoline is, then a reduction in taxes will lead immediately to increased consumption until the price of gas once again reaches the market-clear price. In other words, if the gas tax is suspended the price will fall. When the price falls, people will buy more gas. Because of the increase in the quantity of gas demanded, the price will go right back up to its pre-tax-suspension level.

However, the quantity of gasoline demanded will increase if the tax is suspended. So such a policy would essentially be a hand-out from taxpayers to oil companies, with the added cost of environmental degradation and an increase in carbon emissions. 

In short, it's a remarkably stupid policy proposal. Obama should be commended for refusing to pander when given such an easy opportunity. He is losing ground in the polls for the sake of intellectual honesty, while Clinton and McCain are gaining cheap points by preying on peoples' ignorance. So good for him, and bad on them.

(P.S. This economic intuition is a fundamental assumption for members of the Pigou Club. If you share their goals and ethical assumptions, then it's easy to share their conclusion that gas taxes should be significantly higher; not lower.)

UPDATE:

Bryan Caplan likes the idea. But not for the same reasons as Clinton. His support is of a more cynical nature: he thinks that lowered taxes will preclude price controls, which he views as a greater evil, and in any case he thinks that eliminating the taxes won't have any strong negative effect. The second part is almost certainly true, and the first part is likely but not assured (and it is likely true because of American political tradition and our aversion to price controls; not because of the "irrationality" of the citizenry). If the profits of oil companies increase while gasoline prices continue upwards (as seems likely), then it seems likely that populist policies -- including price controls or other ill-minded ideas -- would become more likely, not less. I could draft the speech now: "Oil companies are getting rich on the backs of hard-working Americans. We tried to lower the burden by cutting out the taxes, but the greedy oil executives just grabbed more of the surplus. And so we should act punitively to re-direct money from these robber-barons back to the American people." And so price controls begin.

I know that Caplan knows more about game theory than I do, so maybe I'm missing something. But it seems to me as if he's acting as if this were a one-shot game, when it clearly isn't. 

Labels: , , , , ,

Thursday, April 3, 2008

Obama: A Uniter and a Divider

Peter Suderman, guest-blogging at McArdle's place, sees some canny rhetoric from Obama:

But reading through it, I was also impressed, in a way, not just by his typically soaring rhetorical style, but by his sharp rhetorical tactics. Basically Obama likes to present problems in a moderate conservative frame — and then use that frame to argue for fairly standard liberal policy. So you get passages up front that are positively rapturous in the way they describe the American market — calling it the "envy of the world" and talking about how it "provided great rewards to innovators and risk-takers." It's not quite Larry Kudlow, but it's more than just the generic "America is a land of opportunity" line that every politician has to recite from time to time. Those broad criticisms he mounts about the problems with an outdated regulatory system would be at home in speeches made by plenty of Republicans. But it's in the back end where he tends to switches things up, calling, in this case, for greater financial oversight, harsher punishments for "market manipulation," etc. It's a nice trick, one he employs quite a bit, and I suspect it goes a long way toward bolstering his image as a uniter. It's easy to give up rhetorical ground if you're strengthening your control of the policy territory.

Labels:

Sunday, March 16, 2008

Why Clinton Can't Win

Megan McArdle points us to TAPPED, where Mark Schmitt explains why Clinton can't win the Democratic nomination by any legitimate means:

What would happen if an agreement were announced today that there would be re-votes in Florida and Michigan? Immediately, the previous primaries in those states would become dead letters. Instead of being 200,000 votes down in the popular vote (by her campaign's count), or 500,000 down (by my count, which gives Clinton her Florida votes), Clinton would be down in the popular vote by almost 1 million. And 193 delegates that they are currently counting would suddenly disappear.

And at that point, the magnitude of Clinton's deficit would be too obvious to spin away. Yes, there would be two additional large-state contests in which to win back the million popular votes and hundreds of delegates. But unless she did significantly better in both states than she did in the illegal primaries, she would lose, not gain, ground, by her own calculations. Since she was on the ballot alone in Michigan before, it's highly unlikely that she will do better there. It's very possible that she could do better than the 50 percent she won in Florida in January, but since it would now be a two-person race, it's a dead certainty that Obama would do significantly better than the 32 percent he got in January, thus adding to his total popular vote margin and delegate count even if he lost again, and so it would be a net loss for Clinton. Re-votes cannot help Clinton be "perceived" as the winner of the popular vote.

Contrary to the gullible media's belief that "time" is a "powerful ally" on Clinton's side, in fact, Clinton's only ally is uncertainty. The minute it becomes clear what will happen with Michigan and Florida -- re-vote them, refuse to seat them, or split them 50-50 or with half-votes, as some have proposed -- is the minute that Clinton's last "path to the nomination" closes. The only way to keep spin alive is to keep uncertainty alive -- maybe there will be a revote, maybe they'll seat the illegal Michigan/Florida delegations, maybe, maybe, maybe. In the fog of uncertainty, Penn can claim that there is a path to the nomination, but under any possible actual resolution of the uncertainty, there is not.



So if Clinton can't win by legitimate means, then why is she still in the race? And what sorts of illegitimate tactics will she be willing to employ to bury Obama?

Labels: , ,

Thursday, March 13, 2008

A Shift in Conscience

So, noted playwright and filmmaker David Mamet has outed himself as an ex-Liberal -- in the Village Voice no less! Basically, his turn towards libertarianism has happened for the same reason he was originally became a liberal in the 1960s: a believe that government is inept in the best of times, and corrupt and oppressive in the worst. In the 1960s, that belief led many to liberalism, which then stood in support of civil rights and the Voting Act, and against the Vietnam war. In other words, the biggest gains for the cause of liberty and freedom could be found in the left-wing movement. But in the aughts, distrust of government and support for civil liberties nearly necessitates some libertarian tendencies, and so Mamet moved in that direction.

I suspect that many people in the coming years will go in the "left-libertarian" direction that is best represented (at this point in time) by Obama. In this view, the government isn't a nanny but a tool; it isn't an end but a means. Of course, who knows what an Obama presidency would look like, so this might be a projection, but one could hope that the left principles of full social equality for everyone might meet the right principles of government skepticism to forge a new coalition dedicated to liberty, but without coercion.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, March 5, 2008

Amazing

Via Matthew Yglesias, watch Hillary Clinton specifically cite her experience in explaining why she was going to vote in favor of the Iraq War "with conviction".

Of course, now she is saying that her experience will prevent her from making exactly these sorts of mistakes. Perhaps Obama's never-ending faith in "hope" and "change" as panacea, but Clinton is obviously doing the same thing with her "experience" and "tried and tested" tropes. This election is not Change vs. Experience; it's about judgment and policy.

Labels: , ,

Identity

Daniel Drezner says that the real victim of identity among the leading presidential candidates is... John McCain:

This leads to a central irony about this campaign. I don't doubt that Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton have suffered a multitude of small slights in their professional and personal lives because of their gender or race. However, if you think about this as a contest to see who has suffered the greatest because of their identity, it's not even close.

The candidate who has suffered the most in his lifetime is.... John McCain. As an individual, he has paid a much higher price for his identity as an officer in the United States military than Obama or Cinton has individually paid for their race or gender. And there's simply no way to spin it otherwise.

The suffering that McCain underwent at the hands of a foreign government in the midst of a war doesn't compare very well with the way Obama/Clinton are seen by their fellow countrymen in an election campaign.

Still, it's difficult for me to see how the respective identities of any of these three candidates have hurt them politically (unlike, say, Romney's Mormonism which clearly did hurt him). It's arguable that neither McCain nor Clinton would even have a political career of any significance without their identities, and it seems like Obama's has helped him create and sell his "building up bridges" and "bringing people together" narratives which have served him so well.

Labels: ,

Monday, March 3, 2008

Touche

Jack Nicholson endorses Clinton by compiling some of his most notable moments:



But Obama's fans fight back:

Labels: ,

Quote for the Day

From Daniel Drezner:

I've said it before and I will say it again: Democrats cannot simultaneously talk about improving America's standing abroad while acting like a belligerent unilateralist when it comes to trade policy.
This in a post discussing how NAFTA-bashing from the Clinton and Obama campaigns irks the governments of Canada and Mexico.

Labels: , ,

Friday, February 22, 2008

The Audacity of Nit-picking

Greg Mankiw reads The Audacity of Hope and mostly likes what he finds. But he does find something to quibble with:

The sloppiest sentence so far (page 146):
Over the past decade, we've seen...hefty corporate profits, but a shrinking share of those profits going to workers.
I am pretty sure that the share of profits going to workers has been stable--at zero. Profits are what owners get to keep after workers have been paid.
In strictly econo-speak, Mankiw is right, of course. But Obama is not an economist, and neither are 99.99% of his readers. What Obama meant is clear: corporate profits have been increasing, while salaries have remained stagnant -- or declined, in real terms -- for most of the population. This is also an economic statement, with empirical backing, which Mankiw completely ignores.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Who Has It Harder: Obama or Clinton?

Obviously, both Obama and Clinton have to break down the exclusive white-man president's club if they are to attain America's top office. But which of the two has more to overcome? Turns out, measured strictly by examining the strength of gender and race biases, that it's Clinton.

Labels: ,

Thursday, February 7, 2008

Tie Goes to the ... Runner?

According to an Obama campaign memo, accidentally leaked, the Obama camp is expecting a virtual tie in delegates after all the primaries and delegates. So what happens in that case? Well, the superdelegates could decide it, and currently Clinton has a fairly significant lead in that category. Or, the delegates from MI and FL could be seated, which would tip the nomination to Clinton. Or, there could be a new contest in MI and FL -- perhaps a caucus -- in order to determine their delegates. A caucus could help Obama.

In other words, it will be a very long time before this is decided. It is very unlikely that there will be any resolution before the Democratic Convention. Which is in the last week of August.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

Obama's Executive Experience

Clinton says he has none, and repeatedly say that Clinton is the right choice because she'll be ready to lead "from Day One". But Andrew Sullivan points to the only direct comparison we have between Clinton's and Obama's executive leadership capabilities: their campaigns. Clinton started the campaign will all the money, all the connections, and the biggest political machine this side of Karl Rove behind her (and, it should be noted, the support of Rove as well, since Rove considers Clinton to be beatable).

And yet? Obama has won this campaign. He may not win the nomination in the end, but his campaign has bettered Clinton's in nearly every respect: fund-raising, organization, grass-roots support. He has won every caucus state in the Democratic primary thus far, and this requires strong organization and mobilization. Clinton, with all the king's horses and men behind her, has turned in a lackluster performance. Obama is currently leading in the pledged delegate count (and has since Iowa), and only trails in the total delegate count because of Clinton's entrenched support among superdelegates.

There is a direct comparison between the executive capabilities of these two candidates; and Obama wins.

UPDATE: Brad DeLong sees it a bit differently:

both have now demonstrated an ability to run an excellent political campaign. Running a successful presidential political campaign is not the same thing as governing a country, but both have demonstrated substantial administrative competence over the past two years--and neither has betrayed the moral failure of telling big lies or making themselves hostage to special interests in the way that, say, George H.W. Bush did and thus crippled their presidency in advance. A Barack Obama who was just a pretty face who could give a nice speech could not have run the campaign he has run over the past two years. And the Hilary Rodham Clinton who made such an administrative mess of health reform in 1993-1994 could not have run the campaign she has run over the past two years. Thus I am now confident that either has a reasonable shot of being in the top 20% of American presidents.
Despite having proudly worked in the Clinton administration, he voted for Obama "because [Obama] gives a really nice speech," and all other categories were in a virtual tie.

I agree that Clinton's campaign has been decently-run. There haven't been any major screw-ups. But her campaign has been remarkably... conservative. She hasn't taken any gambles; she's triangulated about her support for the Iraq War, her plan for pulling out of Iraq (she hasn't provided one yet), fiscal responsibility vs. the expansion of social services, etc. Her campaign certainly hasn't demonstrated the bold, transformative leadership that she claims to have delivered for the past 35 years. She has shown herself to be calculating and somewhat savvy, but that's all. Her campaign has not been incompetent, but it has been uninspiring.

Obama, on the other hand, has overcome the massive party apparatus supporting Clinton. He has been more imaginative in his policy prescriptions, more consistent on Iraq, more gracious and optimistic than the Clintons, more able and willing to forge broad coalitions, get new people involved in the political process, and more inspiring.

Obama's campaign has run circles around Clinton's, giving their two starting points. And this is something to consider when looking forward. Clinton is still the front-runner at this point, but if the recent past means anything, my money is on Obama to carry more pledged delegates into the convention. What happens then is anyone's guess.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

The Conservatives' Case for Obama

Andrew Sullivan lays it out nicely here:

It's a long year and, mercifully, I don't have to address all the many good points you've made in the past week or so by email about the weirdness of a conservative supporting Obama. Right now, I'm considering who should get the Democratic nomination. It seems to me that a conservative who picks Obama over Clinton or Edwards in that context doesn't betray any great principles.

But in the general? Isn't he a leftist? A socialist even? Derb's splutter is not unreasonable as splutters go.

A preliminary comment. Compared to what? It seems to me that any Republican cavilling at Obama's incremental liberalism who has not exploded in rage during the last seven years has no standing to debate this question.

No conservative who has not gone nuclear at the Bush administration's Medicare bill, or its doubling of federal education spending, or its adding $32 trillion to unfunded liabilities, or its long record of nanny-state initiatives, or its trampling of states rights in education, drug laws, marriage laws, and on and on ... has much of a leg to stand on when complaining - now - about big government liberalism. In many ways, it's much worse coming from the Republicans, because Bush and his cronies have legitimized left-liberalism in ways that even Clinton could not (and did not).

Of course, I have exploded in rage at the GOP. But part of that explosion is a hope that they are collectively punished for trashing the brand and the principles of conservatism. If the fall comes around and there is a vast difference between the spending plans of the Democratic and the Republican nominee, I'll happily revisit this question. But I should add that, while I've never met a tax cut I didn't like, I've never subscribed to the idea that indefinite government debt is a conservative principle. And sometimes, as Reagan showed, that means raising taxes. Clinton's tax hike did not kill the economy. Something similar won't either. And the notion that a bankrupt government in a post-industrial economy needs to maintain the same economic policies as the 1980s is arguable. If you didn't catch Chris Caldwell's typically sharp essay on Sunday, check it out.

I have further thoughts - on foreign policy, climate change and identity politics - but I'll save them for later posts. But let's be clear here: Compared to Bush, Obama is a conservative. He is promising nothing like the expansion of government or debt that Bush pushed through in eight years. Nothing like. That doesn't mean I like the idea of even bigger government. It does mean that a little historical context helps.



I'm not a big states' rights guy, but other than that I pretty much agree. Sullivan's Atlantic cover article from a few months back is also pretty good, although some of his arguments fail the further he stretches them out.

Labels:

Monday, January 28, 2008

Bill Blacker Than Barack?

So says Andrew Young, Clinton friend and former ambassador to the U.N.:

This week, while making the remarkable accusation that the Obama camp was responsible for raising the race issue, Mr. Clinton mentioned Andrew Young as someone who would bear that out. It was an extremely unfortunate reference.

Here’s what Mr. Young, who is black and a former ambassador to the United Nations, had to say last month in an interview posted online: “Bill is every bit as black as Barack. He’s probably gone with more black women than Barack.”

He then went on to make disgusting comments about the way that Bill and Hillary Clinton defended themselves years ago against the fallout from the former president’s womanizing. That’s coming from the Clinton camp!

Wow. Just... wow.

Labels: ,

"The Greatest Betrayal"

And what is this betrayal? Well, according to the N.Y. chapter of N.O.W., the "greatest betrayal" came when Teddy Kennedy endorsed Obama over Clinton. And the ladies are upset:

“Women have just experienced the ultimate betrayal. Senator Kennedy’s endorsement of Hillary Clinton’s opponent in the Democratic presidential primary campaign has really hit women hard. Women have forgiven Kennedy, stuck up for him, stood by him, hushed the fact that he was late in his support of Title IX, the ERA, the Family Leave and Medical Act to name a few. Women have buried their anger that his support for the compromises in No Child Left Behind and the Medicare bogus drug benefit brought us the passage of these flawed bills. We have thanked him for his ardent support of many civil rights bills, BUT women are always waiting in the wings.

“And now the greatest betrayal! ...

“This latest move by Kennedy, is so telling about the status of and respect for women’s rights, women’s voices, women’s equality, women’s authority and our ability – indeed, our obligation - to promote and earn and deserve and elect, unabashedly, a President that is the first woman after centuries of men who ‘know what’s best for us.’”
Wow.

UPDATE: Slate.com's XX blog is similarly miffed:

So, that's it—an endorsement of any candidate but Hillary is a betrayal of the feminist cause? I suppose the more sophisticated version is that interest groups expect the politicians they support to support them blindly in their time of need. This is their time of need, the NY NOW chapter argues, ergo, Kennedy should be with them. But that assumes that the feminist time of need equates with electing Hillary. Would most women, or even most feminists, agree with that? I just can't. And what does this narrow-cast way of evaluating a candidate really have to recommend it? I can't think of anything on that score, either. Can some other women's group please speak up to say that if Kennedy has good reason to think that Obama would be the best president for the country, and a damn fine president for women, then supporting him is A-OK with them?


(ht: Andrew Sullivan)

Labels: ,

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

Obama and Farrakhan

So, Roger Cohen noticed that Obama's pastor's magazine gave Louis Farrakhan an award, and he recoiled:

The Obama camp takes the view that its candidate, now that he has been told about the award, is under no obligation to speak out on the Farrakhan matter. It was not Obama's church that made the award but a magazine. This is a distinction without much of a difference. And given who the parishioner is, the obligation to speak out is all the greater. He could be the next American president. Where is his sense of outrage?
Henry Farell at Crooked Timber disagrees, and intimates that Cohen is holding Obama to a different standard because of his race:

There’s something else going on here. I strongly suspect that Barack Obama is being asked to condemn Louis Farrakhan not because there’s some bogus two-degrees-of-separation thing going on, but because Barack Obama is black, and because black politicians are supposed to condemn Louis Farrakhan before they can be trusted. This isn’t racism, but it’s an implicit double standard, under which black politicians have a higher hurdle to jump before they deserve public trust than white ones. More generally, this is a bad, wrongheaded, and even dangerous article. Richard Cohen shouldn’t have written it, and the Washington Post shouldn’t have printed it.

Fontana Labs at Unfogged agrees with Farrell:

Oh yes. Underneath this is the "show us you're one of the good ones!" demand that Obama has to meet in order to demonstrate that he's palatable to annoying white people like Cohen. Fuck a bunch of that, I say, but Obama cannot-- though it would be richly satisfying to hear him do it.
I really couldn't disagree more. It is perfectly fine for people to question Mitt Romney about the bizarre views of Mormons, including the fact that they were an officially a racist organization until the 1970s, as Christopher Hitchens has done. It is right and proper to ask Romney to denounce this past racism, and give an explanation for his participation in it. Similarly, it is perfectly appropriate to ask Obama why he patrons a church whose leader -- Jeremiah Wright -- offered an award to a demagogue such as Farrakhan, especially in the context of Wright's teachings in black liberation theology. It is fine to ask Obama to comment on this fact, and I would hope that he would respond by denouncing Farrakhan.

I don't see it as a function of Obama's race. One's of Obama's closest associates, from whom he got the title for The Audacity of Hope, on some level admires a racist and espouses a bizarre, conspiratorial religion. It is perfectly appropriate to ask Obama to clarify his views on this topic.

UPDATE: Obama did repudiate Farrakhan in the debate last night. Issue closed.

Labels: ,

Monday, January 7, 2008

Germany *Hearts* Obama

For some, he's the new JFK:

Germany has developed a serious case of Obama-mania.

Barack Obama’s high standing in Germany goes beyond his opposition to
the unpopular war in Iraq. The country’s sudden crush is bound up with
near-constant comparisons here between the young senator from Illinois and
President John F. Kennedy Jr. – still admired in Germany and particularly in
Berlin.

The Berliner Morgenpost over the weekend ran with the headline, “The New Kennedy.” The tabloid Bild declared, “This Black American has become the new Kennedy!” And the headline
for the editorial in the Frankfurter Rundschau read simply: “Lincoln,
Kennedy, Obama.
”

Labels: ,