Thursday, November 15, 2007

Preach It!

Annie Duke -- professional poker player, Columbia grad, and mother of four -- testified before Congress on the illegitimacy of anti-internet gaming laws in the U.S. She even brought John Locke and John Stuart Mill (and Thomas Jefferson and James Madison) into it! The manner in which the bill outlawing online gaming (it was snuck into a Ports Defense bill) is shady, and the philosophy underpinning prohibition is disingenuous. Somehow, this woman was able to illustrate all these point -- and more! -- in a few minutes before Congress. The video is fuzzy, but the arguments are clear.

The WTO ruled against the U.S. law, saying that it went against the U.S.'s requirements in the WTO charter. The WTO acknowledged the right of the U.S. to opt out of WTO requirements for moral reasons, but ruled that the U.S. was not doing so because it still permitted gambling on horse races and state lotteries to continue online. Hopefully, this matter may be resolved.

This Salon.com article provides further background, and is the source for Duke's video.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

Antigua Defeats U.S. in WTO Battle

Antigua was unhappy because the U.S. banned offshore online gambling, which provided a lot of revenue for the island. The U.S. claimed that it was absurd for Antigua to take this dispute to the WTO, since regulating gambling comes under the jurisdiction of the U.S. government, not the WTO. The U.S. case makes intuitive sense, but it seems to violate WTO rules to which the U.S. agreed, so Antigua won the case. Now the U.S. has to either ban ALL online gaming -- including horse-bettering and lottery programs which are currently legal -- or allow Antiguan online casinos access to U.S. customers, or pay billions in restitution. Traditionally, this restitution comes in the form of punitive tariffs. But Antigua is too small to inflict any noticeable damage to the U.S., so Antigua asked for permission from the WTO to violate U.S. intellectual property, presumably through piracy of movies, music, technology, or something else. So far as I know, the WTO hasn't issued a final ruling on that point.

It's an interesting case, because it directly challenges the authority of U.S. lawmakers to pass laws in the age of the internet. It also could effect online casinos based in Malta and other countries which have been harmed by the U.S.'s online gambling ban. It also has ramifications for the expansion of intellectual property protections in the Doha negotiations, for which the U.S. is pushing hard.

Dani Rodrik has some commentary here.

Labels: , , ,