Friday, February 15, 2008

Chavez Retaliates

He won't sell oil to ExxonMobil.

Oil is a fungible commodity in a global market, so even if Chavez stops selling to the U.S., he will presumably still sell to others. The oil that those others would’ve bought will still be on the market for the U.S. to buy; they may even flip the very same crude to the U.S. In other words, this is a fairly empty threat from Chavez. Remember how well the Arab oil embargo worked?

It may raise oil prices a bit, but the U.S. economy has endured a quadrupling of oil prices in the past 5 or 6 years without much disruption. It can surely absorb the small amount of increase that Chavez’s withdrawal would cause. Put frankly, the worst Chavez could do is stop about 50,000 barrels from getting to the U.S. … which isn’t a very big deal. Our strategic reserves could cover that for longer than Chavez could go without the revenue.

Like it or not, Chavez needs the U.S. — and our refineries, which are among the few in the world that can handle his high-sulfur crude — much more than we need him. Chavez has to know this, which is why he’s made this rather empty threat. He knows that if he sells his oil to somebody else it will likely end up in the U.S. anyway. I would imagine that he is counting on the political gains which would come from ramped-up anti-U.S. rhetoric, while still selling to the U.S. (through an intermediary), thus keeping the coffers full enough to continue funding his social programs.

But imagine the shape he’d be in if the U.S. called him on his bluff and stopped purchasing any oil which originated in Venezuela. We won’t do that, because there is no need to, but if we did that it would give us a minor headache but kill Chavez.

Labels: , ,

Monday, February 11, 2008

The Death Knell for Chavez?

In response to Chavez's seizure of oil company assets when he nationalized Venezuela's oil industry, the British government has frozen $12bn of Venezuela's assets. In protest, Chavez has once again threatened to stop selling oil to the U.S., saying that Venezuela would join an "economic war," and that they would not be the only country to do so. Daniel Drezner makes the obvious point:

If Chavez were to attempt an embargo, there's no doubt that the United States would feel a twinge of pain.

On the other hand, whatever twinge the U.S. felt would be mild compared to the massive spasms that would rip through Venezuela's economy from such a move -- especially since the only refineries that can handle Venezuelan oil are based in the United States.

This is one of those situations where, if economic warfare breaks out, the U.S. holds most of the cards.

I strongly suspect that Chavez's self-preservation motive will force him to back down -- but it would be kind of amusing if he believed his own bluster.

Drezner goes on to link to this NY Times article, describing how Chavez is losing his grip on Venezuela because of his economic mis-management:

These should be the best of times for Venezuela, blessed with the largest conventional oil reserves outside the Middle East and oil prices near record highs. But this country’s economic and social problems have become so acute lately that President Hugo Chávez is facing an unusual onslaught of criticism, even from his own supporters, about his management of the country.

In a rare turnabout, it is Mr. Chávez’s opponents who appear to have the political winds at their backs as they reverse policies of abstention and prepare dozens of candidates for pivotal regional elections. Mr. Chávez, for perhaps the first time since a recall vote in 2004, is increasingly on the defensive as his efforts to advance Venezuela toward socialism are seen as failing to address a growing list of worries like violent crime and shortages of basic foods.

While Mr. Chávez remains Venezuela’s most powerful political figure, his once unquestionable authority is showing signs of erosion. Unthinkable a few months ago, graffiti began appearing here in the capital in January reading, “Diosdado Presidente,” a show of support for a possible presidential bid by Diosdado Cabello, a Chávez supporter and governor of the populous Miranda State.

Outbreaks of dengue fever and Chagas disease have alarmed families living in the heart of this city. Fears of a devaluation of the new currency, called the “strong bolívar,” are fueling capital flight. While the economy may grow 6 percent this year, lifted by high oil prices, production in oil fields controlled by the national oil company, Petróleos de Venezuela, has declined. Inflation soared by 3 percent in January, its highest monthly level in a decade.


Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

False Populists


Matthew Yglesias questions the meaning of a sentence from Bush's State of the Union address from last night:

Here's a random note from last night. Bush, talking about a free trade pact with Colombia, said "If we fail to pass this agreement, we will embolden the purveyors of false populism in our hemisphere." The purveyors of false populism are, I guess, Hugo Chavez and other murky conspirators. But why is it false populism? Chavez is a real populist. Maybe you think he's a populist peddling fake solutions to Latin America's problems, but he's certainly not a secret pro-business neoliberal.

Or, perhaps Bush was referring to the fact that, despite Chavez's rhetoric, income inequality has increased during his tenure as Glorified National Leader and Great President. The economic disparities in Venezuela are nicely captured by the above photo, of Caracas. Similar stories may be told of Brazil (11th most unequal country in the world), Bolivia (6th most unequal), and just about every other country in Latin America, many of which are led by "real populists".

For the record, the U.S. was right at the global weighted average. List here.

Labels: , , ,

Sunday, January 27, 2008

Another Glimpse into Chavez's Fantasy World

Hugo Chavez says that Latin American countries should pull their currency reserves from the U.S., and has established a brand new bank to house the relocated cash.

Because, you know, Latin America never has currency crises or anything, and Chavez has never manipulated his own currency in order to combat runaway inflation due to his misguided price controls.

Nope. The U.S. is an unsafe, unprofitable place for investors, which is probably why the U.S. receives more FDI than any other country in the world every year.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

The Descent Into Authoritarianism Continues

Chavez threatens to take over private schools, installs a new curriculum to educate the "new citizen," and will nationalize any private schools which resist.

Venezuela is in trouble. Big, big trouble.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

Chavez's Growing Inequality Gap

By at least one measure, things aren't looking so good in Caracas:

Despite Chavez's "revolution for the poor" the Gini coefficient has increased from 0.44 in 2000 to 0.48 in 2005.
A commenter there piles on:

Part of it has to do that after soon nine years of chávez´s “socialist government” gas is sold at less than 12 US cents per gallon, less that its direct cost of distribution and with this about 10% of GDP is transferred from those who have nothing to those who buy gasoline. Annual gasoline subsidies amount to US$ 3.000 per car.
(ht: Marginal Revolution)

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

Chavez Consolidates Control

This was inevitable, but it's still sad.

Labels:

Obama Wants to Ease Cuban Embargo

About time. The utter ridiculousness of the Cuban embargo is apparent to anyone without an axe to grind.

Even better, the U.S. must improve its relations with S. America. We'll have opportunities as Chavez and Morales run their economies into the ground and consolidate more and more political authority, as Brazil straightens itself out and rises as an important international economy, and as the Cuban regime collapses or reforms. We need to start extending olive branches now; not to the leaders of these countries, who don't suffer much from embargoes anyway, but to the citizenry. Cuban-Americans who travel back to Cuba and/or repatriate some of their incomes can be the best P.R. tool we could imagine. It's a resource which should not be neglected.

Update: Thomas Barnett concurs.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, July 17, 2007

Nationalistic Socialism In Practice

And no, I don't mean Naziism. I mean the anti-internationalist/anti-American/neo-Marxist rhetoric which commonly comes from S. America these days.

This week's example is... Evo Morales in Bolivia. You may remember that Mr. Morales unceremoniously booted foreign companies out of his country last year, because they were exploitative and keeping the poor down and etc. Well... it didn't seem to work so well:

Bolivia is courting foreign energy investors again, less than 15 months after President Evo Morales ordered troops to occupy oil and gas fields as part of his plan to take control of the country's natural resources.

Investment in natural gas exploration and production has plummeted in the wake of Morales's nationalizations and contract revisions, putting at risk his promise to add 20 million cubic meters of gas exports a day to Argentina by 2011, almost triple the current amount. Without new sources of gas, Argentina, Chile and Brazil, Bolivia's biggest gas customer, face a growing prospect of energy shortages and rationing.

``The government is realizing it needs foreign investors, but it wishes it didn't,'' said Carlos Alberto Lopez, a Bolivian oil and gas analyst and former secretary of energy. ``Venezuela has been a big disappointment for them and now they are knocking on everyone's doors,'' he said by phone from Santa Cruz.

Morales's plans to rely on Venezuela's state oil company Petroleos de Venezuela SA, known as PDVSA, haven't panned out yet. Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez pledged in May 2006 more than $1.5 billion of new investment to explore for oil and gas and to build refining facilities and service stations.

You bite the hand of international economics, and it bites back. Hard.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, June 18, 2007

World's Worst Currencies

Chavez made the list, despite having bragged "we're going to end monetary instability in Venezuela." Chavez's reaction? Imprisoning those who violate price controls, introducing a 12.5 cent coin, and arbitrarily removing three zeros from the bolivar. The result? The official bolivar/dollar exchange rate is roughly half the black market rate. Chavez hasn't quite reached Mugabe-like levels of economic mismanagement, but he's on the same path.

Iran didn't make Foreign Policy's round-up, but they are similarly in trouble:

Some 60 economists this week wrote to Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadi-Nejad criticising his government for putting “short-term welfare above long-term sustainable development”.

Almost half way through his first four-year term, the letter underlines the acute dilemmas faced by the president in delivering short-term welfare promises as he manoeuvres to bolster political support.

The government’s indecision over two major issues – the price of petrol and bank lending rates – is a particular source of confusion.

More than three weeks after the lapse of the original date for petrol rationing – designed to curb a $5bn (€3.75bn, £2.5bn) bill for importing 35m of the 75m litres Iran consumes daily – the government is still groping its way around any decision it fears might be unpopular. Officials have this week made differing statements over when and how rationing – which was to begin tomorrow – will start....

Private bankers wrote to the economy minister last week demanding a freeze on loan rates to “make survival of private banks possible”.

But even with inflation officially at 13.6 per cent last year, Mr Ahmadi-Nejad is battling with the central bank over his insistence on a 12 per cent lending rate, down from the current 14 per cent in state-owned and 17 per cent in private banks. The Guardian Council, a constitution watchdog, is due to rule this week on a compromise.

“What the government describes as economic policies do not match any professionally-known theories, but are rather populist political policies,” said Mohammad Tabibian, former deputy head of the Management and Planning Organisation, a cross-governmental co-ordination body....

Many observers doubt official figures of 14 per cent inflation and 12 per cent unemployment. One economist told the FT that inflation was above 20 per cent, while unemployment was 25 per cent among university graduates.



There's no need to go to war with Iran; at this rate, they will crumble the same way the Soviet Union crumbled: through economic mismanagement coupled with fickle oil markets.

ht: Daniel Drezner

Labels: , ,

Thursday, May 31, 2007

Land Reform in Venezuela

Daniel Drezner looks at Chavez's land reform and does not like what he sees:

Hugo Chavez approaches the Mugabe level of economic mismanagement

On Thursday the Wall Street Journal's Jose De Cordoba had a front-pager describing how Hugo Chávez's agricultural reforms are going:

Now Mr. Chavez is taking his revolution to the Venezuelan countryside. "We must end latifundios," he said in a televised speech in March, referring to large agrarian estates. "The people order it, and we will do it, whatever the cost." Then he announced the seizure of a land area larger than the state of Rhode Island.

Since coming to power, The Chávez government has handed over 8.8 million acres, an area bigger than Maryland, for use by the poor. While much of this was state-owned land that was either idle or leased to ranchers, some 4.5 million acres were "recovered" from private owners, Mr. Chávez said recently. In some cases, the government compensated them. In most others... it has simply turned a blind eye to land invasions.

The government bills land reform as a way to make Venezuela self-sufficient infood. But so far, the effect has been to undercut production of beef, sugar and other foods, as productive land is handed over to city dwellers with no knowledge of farming. Established farmers and ranchers, fearing their land may be seized next, are cutting investment in their operations to a minimum.

The chaos in the countryside has contributed to shortages in basic items like milk and meat, a paradox in a country enjoying an economic boom traceable to high oil prices. Also spurring the shortages are price controls on certain foods that keep them prices below the cost of production. Meanwhile, 19%-plus inflation--as oil revenue floods the economy--spurs panic buying: purchasing price-controlled and other goods the shopper might not immediately need for fear of having higher prices in the future or not finding the items at all.

"You get up at dawn to hunt for a breast of chicken all over town. Housewives are in a foul mood." says Lucylde Gonzalez, a Caracas homemaker, who says she hasn't seen an egg in a week."

Chávez has now reached the Robert Mugabe level of economic incompetence by messing with the farm sector. Let's hope he does not move past that to the Mao Zedong/Great Leap Forward level of economic mismanagement.
So who gets the land? Either slum-dwellers from cities who don't know how to farm (and will mismanage the land), or political cronies who won't improve the socioeconomic standing of the Venezuelan poor. Either way, another popular political action which is paving the way to national economic disaster.

Labels: ,

Monday, May 28, 2007

This Ain't No Mecca, Man

RCTV, perhaps the most popular TV station in Venezuela, is now officially out of business, replaced by a state-run company. Pres. Hugo Chavez says the decision to limit the free press in this manner was due to the stations "subversive" programming. The masses protested, and were fired on by police.

Chavez's mask of populism is wilting away, exposing the authoritarian beneath.

Labels: ,